12 ms·
The Times selected as an "NYTimes Pick" a comment from someone in Berlin who absolutely makes my blood boil. (S)he starts off by stating privilege as a 5th-gen
by rconti 11y ago
The Times selected as an "NYTimes Pick" a comment from someone in Berlin who absolutely makes my blood boil.
(S)he starts off by stating privilege as a 5th-generation San Franciscan (obviously, the kind who DESERVE to live in the city), and who fled in the tech boom of the 90s. The usual rant about whitewashing and yuppies and artists being pushed out ensues. Of course they don't want more housing built, because then dirty artists from other places would move in -- you need to preserve the history of San Francisco's starving artists, and never let new culture of any kind in.
Except (s)he says, okay, maybe some "affordable" housing should be built. No discussion on the endless problems of how to manage the waiting list for this "bucket" of housing, or what happens when those people become too successful.
And, in the end, (s)he has moved to Berlin, a city almost TWICE as dense as San Francisco. No doubt some NIMBY in Berlin at some point whined about building more housing for these "outsiders", but I'm sure (s)he does not have the critical thinking necessary to recognize that such a special flower could be the same force in Berlin that (s)he whines about happening to San Francisco.
- skewart 11y agoYeah, the comment section on that article is pretty sad. The number of people whose argument against building more housing is a fear that it will make the city "ugly" is astounding. It's mind-numbingly selfish and greedy to think that a family should barely be able to make ends meet, and children should spend less time with their long-commuting parents, just so that SF can meet your personal aesthetic sensibilities. Look, I love architecture and design, and I love beautiful cities, and I would love to remake all of North America according to my personal taste. But I'm not so entitled as to think that my occaisional aesthetic pleasure is more important than someone else's basic livelihood. Also, not to mention, the whole argument that density has to be ugly and "unliveable" is utterly ridiculous and false - there are lots of dense cities that are widely considered beautiful - Paris and Barcelona come to mind. /rant As the article says, it's easy to get worked up about this stuff. I suspect the "but it will be ugly" commenters are actually well-intentioned.
- rconti 11y agoWell absolutely. And one commenter there (or here) mentioned the negative externalities of someone else's development driving down your property values or making your schools overcrowded or whatever. All of these things are deserving of sympathy and consideration, but.. well, currently they're getting too much of it.
- skewart 11y agoAbsolutely. > or making your schools overcrowded To which I say, build more schools! With more housing and people comes a bigger tax base and more money to fund infrastructure improvements. I don't know a single pro-construction person who doesn't also vigorously support improving urban infrastructure.
- bhickey 11y agoWith Prop 13 in place, cities and towns can't adjust taxes to cover their budgets. It behooves a Bay Area municipality to seek out commercial investment and drive away residential.
- simoncion 11y ago> It behooves a Bay Area municipality to seek out commercial investment and drive away residential. AIUI, (and I might not understand correctly) that's not quite right. If you make significant improvements [0] to a piece of land the value of just those improvements are assessed and added to the assessed value of that land. So -IIRC- if the owner of a two-story multi-family dwelling demolishes the building and builds a fifty-story building in its place, his assessed property value would be the same as it would if he had purchased that property with the new construction on it. [0] Like -for instance- adding on a new room to a house.
- bhickey 11y agoWhat you've said is true, but misses the point. Office buildings don't require schools in the same way houses do. Look at the development in Palo Alto over the last ten years. It's largely commercial and this isn't an accident.
- swagv1 11y agoBut this is old news. The vilified industry is different, but they were saying many of the same things in the 1990s. Then as now, not everyone is entitled to a nice two-bedroom San Francisco flat for $2000/month. Tokyo has figured that out. Moscow has figured that out. London has figured that out. Why are San Franciscans so slow to catch on?
- brianwawok 11y agoThe people already owning in SF have a different and arguably better life than the current people in Tokyo or Moscow. Classic argument where people on the inside would prefer to keep it exclusive.
- RodericDay 11y agoLondon has figured it out? Last time I read about rent in London it was a politically explosive topic.
- anarazel 11y agoBerlin? Denser than San Francisco? Huh? I just moved from the former to the latter, and I'm pretty sure that that's not the case, and Wikipedia backs me up (~4,000/km2 vs 7,124/km2).
- rconti 11y agoThanks -- Cannot find my original source but perhaps it was a difference in how they measured land area.
- anarazel 11y agoBerlin used to have a lot more inhabitants, about 1 million more around around 1940 than now. Not all of the living areas from back then still exist, but it means there are some reserves. In addition to that, while there's obviously some pressure against just moving outward, it's in the middle of flat, mostly unused, land. Not comparable to SF's space constrained situation. (Oh, and I do miss Berlin)
- rconti 11y agoI visited once, and loved it. Of course, my expectation was that it was more dense than SF, so when I found a source that confirmed it, I was all too willing to trust it. But in retrospect (based on your protest on the matter), the housing itself was quite dense in many areas, but there were many parks and large spaces of open areas between the housing blocks.
- christianmann 11y agoWikipedia very unhelpfully tells me that SF has 17k/mi^2 and Berlin has 4k/km^2, which works out to about 10k/mi^2.
- disbelief 11y agoDensity isn't really the problem in San Francisco. The problem is available housing. Relatively speaking San Francisco is far less dense than many other cities. But these other cities don't have housing shortages.
- spiffage 11y agoIf you go to a city council meeting on the peninsula, 80% of the residents speaking say things like this. In my experience, even most tech workers speaking are the ones who bought property in the 90's and want to lift the drawbridge now that they've got theirs. The sentiment that the Bay Area can't allow more homes to be built offends me, and it hurts even more that people who feel this way are the vast majority of voices that reach city councils, and that they're far more organized during elections.
- canoebuilder 11y agoYuppies being pushed out? 'Yuppy' mean young urban professional. If you live in SF, working in the tech profession, you're likely some value of 'young,' and therefore a yuppy.
- meddlepal 11y agoSan Francisco is going to eventually collapse under its own weight. It's already extremely expensive to run a business there but if VC's get tighter with their purses going forward then it's going to be hard to start a new business there when your employee costs are so ridiculously high that you're burning at a 2x rate compared to your competitors in NYC, Boston, Chicago, Austin, Seattle etc (And yes I know some of those are closer than others to SF prices).
- Balgair 11y agoAs a 3rd generation San Fransiscan, San Fransisco is a dirty two-fisted drinking town, full stop. We are the descendants of the leftover dregs of society, the junk drawer of mankind. We are used batteries, bent paperclips, lint, and stripped out rusty screws. Any illusions to art havens are from the last batch of transplants. Romanticism is borne of a head injury to your hippocampus. This city is for the losers and weirdos, the people that can't fit in; hence the gays. That's not a paen to some crappy apple ad about being different. We are not liked by society, we are scoundrels and assholes, drunks and drug runners, we are the fags and chinks and every other horrible name. We are left alone. And now the transplants from the last wave of the hippies and the techys think this place is theirs now. Nice try. You aren't reviled enough yet. When everyone else turns you down, then you come to SF and can talk about your new home. Hell, have a beer.