3 ms·
Ireland works this way; there are about 25k voters per representative. What happens is clientilism: representatives become very concerned with local issues and
by barrkel 11y ago
Ireland works this way; there are about 25k voters per representative. What happens is clientilism: representatives become very concerned with local issues and neglect national issues. Corruption of a different, more local kind, is encouraged.
- danieltillett 11y agoIrish political corruption is a different kind of corruption. I don't think it is due to the size of the electorate, but more a reflection of history. Whatever the cause it is not due to the need for the representatives to raise truckloads of cash to buy advertising to get elected.
- specialist 11y agoCorruption of a different, more local kind, is encouraged. I'd love some of that where I live. I now fully embrace transactional politics. Quid pro quo.
- tacone 11y agoThat's how democracy is meant to work.
- gozur88 11y agoI disagree. I think that exactly the opposite of how democracy is supposed to work. In the US, anyway.
- riprowan 11y agoObviously, since the US is not a democracy, but a representative republic.
- brownbat 11y agodemocracy \di-ˈmä-krə-sē\ a form of government in which people choose leaders by voting - Merriam Webster, first definition democracy (dĭ-mŏkˈrə-sē) Government by the people, exercised either directly or through elected representatives - American Heritage dictionary, first definition With apologies to Plato, the word "democracy" most commonly refers to nearly any political system that involves voting. The only time anyone uses the word democracy to mean "direct democracy," with every citizen voting on every issue, is when they're criticizing someone else for using the word democracy in exactly the way almost everyone does all the time. See my companion rant: Hitler's National Socialism was a form of fascism in the way we use that word today, even though he and Mussolini had distinct political ideas.
- lambertsimnel 11y agoI attended a lecture by an Irish psephologist which covered the neglect of national issues in Irish politics. His view was that the cause of this "chronic localism" was a lack of effective local democracy. (I'd like to see this dealt with, because in some important respects the rest of the world has something to learn from the Irish constitution. Only Austria, Germany and Switzerland have more institutionalised checks on executive power, and all three use forms of proportional representation that I consider inferior to Ireland's.)