10 ms·
Finding Your Soul Mate Online May Be Harder Than the Dating Sites Suggest
- jrs235 11y agoThat's not why finding your soul mate will be difficult using dating sites. It'll be difficult because "successful" dating sites have conflicting interests. http://caseysoftware.com/blog/working-for-a-dating-website http://caseysoftware.com/blog/working-for-a-dating-website
- Overtonwindow 11y agoOnline dating drastically simplifies the idea and practice of courtship. It then overly exaggerates the dating pool, and allows people to superficially skip through everyone that doesn't overwhelmingly appeal to them. As such, two people never really get to know each other, and discover if they are compatible. It has been said elsewhere, and would appreciate the source, that 20 years ago, the majority of people who are married would have never even dated had online dating been around at the time.
- vvvv 11y agoHowever, divorce rates have dropped in recent years and are lower than 20 years ago: http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2010/jan/28/divorce-rates-marriage-ons http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2010/jan/28/divorce... Could it be that by being more picky, we give ourselves a better chance of staying together? EDIT: I found a more recent one with a relative rate vs. marriages: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/12011714/Divorce-rate-at-lowest-level-in-40-years-after-cohabitation-revolution.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/12011714/Divorce-rate... It may be that, as the article suggests, the decrease in % divorce rates has dropped partly due to the increase in social acceptability of cohabitation, allowing couples to try it out before getting married. Nevertheless, taking simply divorce rates into account, the situation has improved from 20 years ago.
- lazyjones 11y ago> However, divorce rates have dropped in recent years and are lower than 20 years ago So have marriage rates - perhaps those who DO get married these days, really mean it.
- janpieterz 11y agoIt could be that, but it could also be because we're marrying so much less [1] which changes the landscape (who marries for what reasons). I'd say that 1000 marriages 20 years ago aren't all that comparable to a 1000 marriages now. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2010/feb/11/marriage-rates-uk-data http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2010/feb/11/marriag... I know the article is a bit old, the trend is still visible though.
- tablewatcher 11y agoI'd argue the same that marriages rates are down, I'd like to see some stats on it. The prospect of marriage has no benefits when you look at it unemotionally. You get marginal tax benefits when you are married but these are completely offset when the cost of divorce is considered. Its quite a risky proposition for a young successful entrepreneur, escpecially the Californian alimony laws.
- meric 11y agoIn Australia, if you're married as an international student, you can bring your spouse, and he or she doesn't have to study and have the right to work full time. That makes it much more easier for both of them financially, individually to make a foothold in the country. It's one part time income and one full time income to support two people and one degree as opposed to, if they were by themselves, one part time income to support themselves studying a full time degree. Then later as they achieve temporary and then permanent residency the marriage can be used to apply for visa for the spouse. I have met a few international student couples who marry at 20 or 21, and one of them drops out, for this advantage. And since they're living pay check to pay check anyway, it's not risky for either of them.
- 11y ago
- jwdunne 11y agoWell, there ARE a number of issues: - the emphasis is predominantly based on looks and sex appeal. - people can take an awfully good looking photo - you are more confident online. You can be a person other than who you really are. With a damn good photo and the mask of the internet, you can be a dream come true. - solid, loving relationships are based on attachment, bonding and openness. The above factors set off a relationship to a start contrary to that. That and I think a lot of women face quite a bit of harassment on these sites or at least used to. That can reduce trust in the platform and perhaps increase the occurrence of the factors above.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y ago> That and I think a lot of women face quite a bit of harassment on these sites or at least used to. Still do, there's plenty of examples online, like: https://www.reddit.com/r/creepyPMs/ https://www.reddit.com/r/creepyPMs/
- jwdunne 11y agoDisgraceful. I think solving that problem is one huge step a dating site can make. Though, the old technical solutions to social problems thing comes up. Perhaps one step is a write up of what you wish to get out of the service. Over time, find patterns with those write ups and that behaviour. Interrsring problem.
- Kenji 11y agoI think Finkel raises many good points, but there is one paragraph that alienated me, which is apparently Finkel's vision: Afterward, you rate your dates. And so does the app’s artificial intelligence, which can recognize signs of compatibility (or incompatibility) that you might have missed. At the end of the night, the app tells you which prospects are worth a second look. Over time, the AI might even learn (via follow-up experiments) which combination of signals predicts the happiest relationships, or the most enduring. Excuse me? I need an algorithm now to figure out who I like and whose relationship I want to deepen? I need an algorithm to detect my love?? Sometimes I feel like this mechanistic mindset is exactly what is wrong with dating today. What happened to good old feelings?
- sokoloff 11y agoI've been with my (now) wife for a little over 10 years, but from what I recall of dating, my early/first reactions to someone were not guided by the same factors with the same weights as my later interactions. (Sexual attraction/lust dominates early and intellectual/moral/lifestyle compatibility increases greatly in importance over time, but not in the first few dates.) There may be a way to optimize that process somewhat, if satisfying and enduring relationship is the goal.
- Avshalom 11y agoIt's the technologist equivalent of having a mutual friend that insists that "no trust me give it a couple more dates"
- Nutmog 11y agoHow do you explain all the single people who've been on many dates and are still single? There's a lot of them who'd rather not be. They evidently don't have this skill that you claim to.
- colmvp 11y agoI was bullish on using dating apps as I went on a good date within a week of signing up to one, amazing since I'm on the lower end of the 1-10 attractiveness scale. Realistically, I'd put myself as 2. However, since then, it's been miss after miss. And it suuuuucks. Nothings more demoralizing than going weeks without a hit, or having women 'accept' to communicate with you, only to give uninteresting, insipid responses.
- danielrhodes 11y agoYou can be ugly as sin, but lucky for you women are not that vapid. Working on self esteem, confidence, and emotional awareness will pratically erase any physical deficits.
- cellularmitosis 11y agobut lucky for you women are not that vapid So I used to believe this. I believed that allowing myself to be a slave to physical attraction was a character flaw, that every time I paid attention to an attractive woman and rejected an unattractive woman that I was a shallow, vapid person. I felt ashamed of it. But have you ever tried dating someone whom you just weren't physically attracted to? I have (twice). It turns out it doesn't work in the long run. Convincing yourself that its the "right thing to do" will work in the short term, but eventually you'll build resentment towards them until the relationship falls apart. I'd encourage you to reconsider this viewpoint, and to stop promulgating it. Be honest with yourself. Anything else is just being reckless with another human being's emotions.
- alashley 11y agoWell said, whenever I hear some one say "I don't care about looks" I think they're trying to put themselves above being superficial, but I think a lot of the time its just lip service. Everyone has their own definition of "good looking" and to that end looks do matter to many people.
- danielrhodes 11y agoEverybody looks different to each other, and there are definitely women who are seen by others to be attractive which I don't find all that attractive (not my type). Likewise, women do not purely look at physical appearance to decide if they find somebody attractive, and neither do men. There are clearly other factors at play. So for somebody to say: I am not physically attractive and therefore not suitable to date is likely not true. Even if you could objectively say that you were physically unattractive, your best bet is to compensate by being better at the other things that form attraction.
- personlurking 11y agoDating sites and apps might benefit from entering the real world - hosting meetups with games, quizes, etc to make them entertaining. One of the problems, however, online or with sponsored offline events, is the low number of results. Unlikely to happen, but I'd like to see data on the number of single individuals in a particular city vs how many of them are on a dating app/site. I'd bet the percentage is really low (barring Tinder in major US cities). Not to mention a comment I made the other week here on HN about there needing to be a "def not looking for a hook up" option on an app like Tinder. Going further, perhaps the solution is an alternative to speed dating - to make dating secondary and having a good time primary. Tinder is "I'll show you the person, you decide what to do next". I'd much rather have a Meetup.com type approach, so to speak. Provide the good time, based on a certain subject, where everyone happens to be single and the male/female ratio isn't skewed. Make the interactions one-on-one, and add to it a comfortable time limit (10-15 min increments) to ensure rotation. With a higher percentage of single people using said apps, and sponsored events like these, I see a win-win. In the end, I don't necessarily expect a soulmate. Just get way more people using Meetup.com and have single people wear a green sticker on their shirt (place + single indicator + subject I'm interested in).
- greggman 11y agoDoesn't match.com do this? At least in major cities they have their "spin" initiative. I went to one that was hosted at the TechStop in SF. Sadly the guys running it were extremely attractive and given they were "in-charge" and leading the classes pretty much made all the women swoon. Another one I went to was party games based. It was early in their event system so there were some rough spots but it was still fun. Another was just a meetup at a bar. I think I prefer organized activities. The hardest part is getting enough people that are likely to be a match. If 100 people come 50/50 men women there's some chance there might be someone you're interested in. If 15 people come the odds are pretty low .
- sakopov 11y agoMeetups where you slap a sticker on your shirt to let others know you're single? Do you not think this is just sad and you're trying too hard? Finding a "soulmate", if you believe in such things, or really just a genuine connection works best when you're not pursuing it out of pure desperation and just enjoy your life. I'd made some of the most amazing connections by pure chance under the most random circumstances when neither I nor they were looking for anyone.
- kirykl 11y agoI think a site like Hotwire for dating could work well. Opposite of tinder. No pictures only a loose physical description + detailed profile that you can search on. Pics come after you choose to share, after a mutual conversation. Have a metric like "95% say pictures reflect description". Award response karma for downvoted personal messages to check quality there. Use data to reduce the clutter of traditional online daring, let emotion choose who you like.
- jeffreyrogers 11y agoI think the problem is that you really need to meet in person to figure out if you're attracted to someone else. One of the main points in the article is that people don't really know what they're attracted to. I know I've been really into someone based on what they seem like on tinder or over text and then had a really flat date with them in person. On the flip side, I've had people I felt kind of ambivalent about who I had a great time with once I met them in person. My strategy now is just to use attractiveness as a screen (since realistically I'm not going to date someone much less attractive than me) and try to meet for a drink as soon as possible. I'm sure I lose out on some people who want to move a bit more slowly, but that doesn't matter since I save tons of time by avoiding people I have no mutual attraction with.
- ldom22 11y agoIn other news, Water may be wet
- shubhamjain 11y agoOne thing I am curious about is can an average guy even have a chance with something like Tinder? From what I have seen from people using the app, men tend to swipe any woman who is not very unattractive. This implies that, whoever woman swipe right will give a match with a very high probability. If I am not wrong, women can be very selective in who they want while same is not the case with men.
- bmay 11y agoDepends on what you mean by "an average guy." Women's taste in men varies a lot so chances are there will be a nontrivial number attracted to each non-homely man. Also, women are probably more selective than men in that they have a lower (swipe-right/total swipes)% but that doesn't necessarily mean their average swipe has a higher physical attractiveness among all women.
- shams93 11y agoYeah I met my soul mate at a previous job the web was only helpful in finding the job. Certain kinds of guys can use these sites but the whole structure of online datong is a jock thing as a nerd i grow on people and the whole swipe left or right doesnt work for slow cooking a relationship.
- duaneb 11y agoIf you are looking for anything but sex on tinder, you're gonna have a bad time. There are very few relevant relationship signals on the app.
- fiatjaf 11y agoYou will not find your soul mate if you're looking for it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- paulcole 11y agoI had little dating experience from high school and college. So when I was in my mid-20s and had a lot of free time, I spent almost a year meeting women on OKCupid. Note that I said, "meeting." I didn't consider initial meetings "dates" which took lots of pressure off. I thought of OKCupid as a way to meet women who seemed interesting and who I might end up being interested in dating. I was able to meet 1-2 women a week, usually for coffee, tea, or a walk in the park. Most of the time it was just a nice conversation and we went our separate ways. A few I became friends with, a few I dated, and in the end I met my partner of going on 5 years now. Here are my tips: 1) Put minimal energy into each message. Say hi, acknowledge you read their profile, and ask a question. 2) Set up a real life meeting quickly. If I got a response, my second message would ask if they wanted to get together for coffee/whatever. 3) Include as little information as possible in your profile. Dont try to be funny or over share. It just a gives people a reason to reject you.
- jim-greer 11y agoI totally agree this is the right approach. It seems like people are figuring this out. 10 years ago I did the Nerve personals (they were syndicated on various sites, I found them on The Onion) A lot of women seemed inclined to send a bunch of messages back and forth, which was mostly a waste of time... You find out much more about actual chemistry in 10 minutes face to face than in days or weeks of exchanging messages. At the time I tended to go back and forth between dates with people I met through friends, at parties etc vs online dating. Overall I'd say the online dating pool back then tended more towards introverted people... Seems less true now that it's become more mainstream. The people I did go on dates with tended to be highly intelligent though, more so than the ones I met in real life. Anyway, I'm happily married now. Good luck out there!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- notaguy 11y agoAs a woman, I like to send several messages to make sure the guy seems safe to meet. Sometimes in the course of those messages, I find the guy creepy and don't meet him. Also even if it's only ten minutes, there's the time involved in getting to the location to meet, etc.
- rsmsky1 11y agoWhen I tried dating apps they showed me people outside my preferences so they were a waste of time. So I gave up on online dating and dating in general, it's just too time consuming. I just resigned myself to being forever alone.
- ams6110 11y agoYou say resigned, so sounds like you're not sure. I do think that some people are happier without the complexity that a relationship adds to life. If you feel that way I don't think that's anything to feel bad about.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- zxcvvcxz 11y agoHere's an uncomfortable thought: an effective 1-to-1 mapping between men and women probably doesn't exist. The fact of the matter is that women are primarily interested in a top smaller percentage of high value men (this is called hypergamy). This smaller group of desirable men would most like to have multiple mates (this is called polygamy). Marriage, and the accompanying culture and customs, 'corrects' this by trying to create a 1-to-1 mapping. Both extreme strategies described are traditionally shamed and discouraged. Why? Because marriage (monogamous long-term bonding) is good for society. It incentivizes the largest amount of people to be productive, and reduces civil unrest by distributing sexual access to women across as many men as possible. For more on sex and society, check out J.D. Unwin: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._D._Unwin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._D._Unwin Now, how this relates to dating difficulties. The fact of the matter is that people become unhappy in a relationship of any kind when they think they are getting the short end of the stick, and could be doing better. They'll rationalize it six ways to Sunday, "my partner doesn't understand me", "my partner smothers me", "they don't do enough chores", "we don't understand ourselves", whatever, but at the end of the day they think they ought to have a better mate, and are fed up with their current one! And oh golly gee, look at the easily accessible options out there. Swiping for a new novel partner is so much easier than building anything substantial. Plus they might be better in bed. This is especially true of women, who, by pure numerical inevitability, largely marry below what they would prefer. We know that women initiate most divorces too, at ~70% (fun fact: among college-eduated couples, that number rises to 90%). A smaller amount of men end up locked to one person too, when they know in another world they could have more mates. Such are the sacrifices for the monogamous society - often referred to as patriarchal, because women are more sexually restricted. So in conclusion, what bothers me about articles like this, who delve deep into rationalizations instead of simple mate value and attractiveness, is the implication of a 1-to-1 mapping between men and women. Is there a 'Soul Mate' for most people? Probably not.
- rustynails 11y agoThanks for a great post. I can see the potential for what you describe. My goal was quite simple: rather than a popularity contest, I wanted someone who was my intellectual equal. This was a novel concept to the women I dated. None of them could cope: dominate or be dominated was the game. I knew my wife as a friend for 10 years before we married. To this day, we see each other as equals, which is unbelievably fulfilling (even after years of marriage). Other than our love of technology (as early geeks) we don't have many hobbies in common. I don't think any dating sites would have helped us find each other because of our different interests. I don't believe in a soul mate and never did. My wife and I both understand our personal needs and our needs as a couple. Find that commonality and you are likely to find great happiness.
- themgt 11y agoThe research itself seems interesting, I just have a hard time understanding the applicability of an app doing this for me. I just went on a couple OKC dates after a recent breakup. First one we had a fair amount in common "on paper" but there was just no chemistry or ability to really click in person, but it was perfectly pleasant. Second date we had arguably less in common but clicked instantly. Maybe an hour in, she asked "so how's this going so far for you?". I smiled and said "seems pretty good! you?" and she laughed and agreed. I guess in the future we'd check an app to tell us how we feel about each other? Next up: try eating this food and ML will tell you whether you enjoyed it!
- Balgair 11y agoI saw a link to the OKCupid blog here earlier, but I think the poster was DV'd out (linking to /r/TheRedPill is not a good idea). OKC was run by some pretty good data folks and they have some very well controlled (if dated) stats on dating. Take a look at this post: http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/your-looks-and-online-dating/ http://blog.okcupid.com/index.php/your-looks-and-online-dati... Essentially, women don't find men very attractive, but that does not stop them from talking to them (last graph). Men tend to go for the 9s and 10s though. Still, your did-I-get-replyed-to rates are comparable regardless of looks. It's only a 3x increase between 1s to 10s, something a little hard-work and typing can overcome if you live in a big city. So, for all the commenters here that are complaining about not getting replies: It's not your fedora or neckbeard, it's your message content. You may or may not be coming off as an asshole or a wet-blanket. remnider: This was from 2009, and the rise of bots (see the AshleyMadison fiasco) has skewed everything, I'd wager.
- stacydeason 11y agovery true, one needs to attain proper skills to do online dating and these skills develop with time, you may not get the desired result in the first attempt, but slowly you will understand the optimal ways of doing it, some tips are there that I would like to share with all those who like to attract their mates online: https://datetingtips.quora.com/Secret-Tricks-to-Attract-Someone-While-Dating-Online https://datetingtips.quora.com/Secret-Tricks-to-Attract-Some..., these tricks can help in getting closer to the one you love.