3 ms·
I'm drawing my conclusions from the visualizations here: http://zesty.ca/voting/sim/ http://zesty.ca/voting/sim/ (search for "nonmonotonicity"). Maybe I should
by nitrogen 11y ago
I'm drawing my conclusions from the visualizations here: http://zesty.ca/voting/sim/ http://zesty.ca/voting/sim/ (search for "nonmonotonicity"). Maybe I should have said public opinion. Shifting public opinion closer to your position can make you lose in IRV; I'm not sure if there's an actual vote count increase as well.
From those visualizations and my reading elsewhere it looks like approval voting is the closest to a Voronoi-style partitioning of the opinion space without being subject to strategic voting.
- edraferi 11y agoThat's a great article, thanks! I feel like I understand the tradeoffs between voting methods much better now.
- danieltillett 11y agoThere is no perfect electrol system, just systems of more or less degrees of badness. Any system chosen is always a balance between simplicity and correctness.
- aninhumer 11y agoHonestly, I've yet to be convinced of a serious problem with Approval/Range Voting. They even survive Arrow's Theorem by not being ranked systems. And there's obviously some variance of complexity between them, but even fine grained Range Voting isn't that hard to understand.
- ClayShentrup 11y agoScore Voting and Approval Voting are clearly the best alternative systems for single-winner elections (for multi-winner elections, many people support some form of Proportional Representation). The problem is that FairVote, which advocates IRV (apparently because it's a useful steeping stone to the their REAL goal of STV), is run by a professional liar named Rob Richie, and he disseminates a massive amount of false and misleading information about voting systems. E.g. https://sites.google.com/a/electology.org/www/fact-check https://sites.google.com/a/electology.org/www/fact-check
- nitrogen 11y agoIndeed. Approval voting seems a bit simpler to me than instant runoff, but instant runoff is better than simple plurality. If a location is considering changing voting systems though, IMO they would be best served by skipping IRV and going for approval. After that we can try to fix party line voting in the US.
- ClayShentrup 11y agoBut there's an objective measure of that degree of badness. Bayesian Regret. http://scorevoting.net/BayRegsFig.html http://scorevoting.net/BayRegsFig.html
- ClayShentrup 11y agoYou seem to be making a common logical fallacy about tactical voting, explained in the graph here. http://www.electology.org/topic/tactical-voting http://www.electology.org/topic/tactical-voting In short, tactical voting isn't all that important. For instance, Score Voting and Approval Voting perform better with 100% strategic voters (in which case they are identical) than IRV does with 100% honest voting. So even if IRV magically encouraged all voters to be honest (which it doesn't), Score/Approval would still be superior. Score Voting is definitively superior to Approval Voting in terms of producing the right electoral outcome (ignoring practical concerns around complexity and the cost of adoption, upgrading voting machines, etc.). That's because, for tactical voters, both systems are the same. But for honest voters, Score Voting adds less noise/loss/distortion, because it doesn't force you to round your 7 up to a 10, or your 3 down to a 0. Hence better outcomes overall, as seen in this graph of Bayesian Regret figures. http://scorevoting.net/BayRegsFig.html http://scorevoting.net/BayRegsFig.html
- specialist 11y agoFor future discussions: I advocate Approval because it's both "good enough" and easy to administrate, tabulate. Balancing concerns from the election integrity viewpoint.
- ClayShentrup 11y agoAgreed.
- ClayShentrup 11y agoIncidentally, the guy behind Zesty.ca lives across the street from me in Berkeley. I co-founded the Center for Election Science. It was a complete coincidence. We moved here from SF a few years ago, and one day I was walking by his house and recognized him sitting on the steps, from a picture on his site. From like 20 feet away. It's a small world.