3 ms·
And the article misleads about the state of lobbying today, for example: > lobbyists who take out lawmakers for expensive lunches A lobbyist who buys an expen
by snowwrestler 11y ago
And the article misleads about the state of lobbying today, for example:
> lobbyists who take out lawmakers for expensive lunches
A lobbyist who buys an expensive lunch for a lawmaker (member of Congress) is committing a federal offense under the Honest Leadership and Open Government Act of 2007. The rule is so strict that if a member of Congress is attending a public event with food at a lobbying org, the org cannot provide utensils, unless the member of Congress pays for their food.
Executive Order 13490 also prohibits all executive branch political appointees from receiving gifts of any kind from lobbyists, including lunch.
The 1999 Supreme Court decision was the right one, as it struck down an interpretation that was obviously too broad. The article names Scalia since he wrote the opinion, but the vote was 9-0! (Obviously this was back in the good old days when the Supreme Court still had 9 justices.)
- mirimir 11y agoLobbyists must be doing something to warrant all the money involved, no? Arguably, lawmakers are being persuaded. Could it just be the abstract strength of their arguments? Somehow, I doubt that.
- vkou 11y agoThe most superficial access, combined with the apathy of their constituents on an issue is more then enough to get a politician to support your cause. Alternatively, you can always threaten to fund someone else in the next party primaries/election.
- joshka 11y ago“You as a lobbyist cannot buy me a dinner for $40,” Mr. Ackerman said in an interview, as he nibbled finger food at a recent conference on government ethics in New York. “But if you give a contribution to my campaign, I can take you to dinner, and we can discuss politics or official business. You, the lobbyist, can give my campaign $1,000, and the campaign can pay for our dinner. That’s perfectly legal, and it’s perfectly dumb.” http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/20/washington/20lobby.html http://www.nytimes.com/2008/04/20/washington/20lobby.html
- marcoperaza 11y agoBut they'll never learn. The folly of those who think they can engineer a perfect society is boundless. "If only there was a rule..."
- emn13 11y agoI don't disagree - but this sentiment can easily mislead. While it's folly to think any set of rules will be perfect, it's also folly to conclude that just because a rule has absurd corner cases that it therefore has no value overall. Ironically (given the complaint Mr Ackerman voiced) one way to encourage imperfections in rules is to allow lobbying, which biases the decision making process towards small, focused groups that have a lot to gain by affecting the rules over large, general benefits.
- studentrob 11y ago> Ironically (given the complaint Mr Ackerman voiced) one way to encourage imperfections in rules is to allow lobbying, which biases the decision making process towards small, focused groups that have a lot to gain by affecting the rules over large, general benefits. Yeah, it's difficult to perfectly take advantage of an imperfect system, and that's a good thing.