3 ms·
This article is idealism that's not grounded in anything close to reality. The real problem is the demand side of the equation ensures things like Facebook and
by nickpsecurity 11y ago
This article is idealism that's not grounded in anything close to reality. The real problem is the demand side of the equation ensures things like Facebook and Comcast are more likely to succeed to point they drown out everything else with network, legacy, and development pace effects. Anything they build must consider and conquer that problem in its design/implementation to succeed. A better, centralized offering that respects users rights down to the company's charter and license agreement is an easier start.
Funny they mentioned Diaspora. I predicted very accurately what would happen to them sometime around 2011 on Schneier's blog:
"Diaspora is a joke. The thing is being designed, analyzed and implemented primarily by amateurs. A truly safe social network must be designed by people with expertise in cryptography, protocol analysis, secure software design, and low-defect implementation. Throw some testing and UI people in there to boot. I like that there's people trying on this, but I wouldn't trust anything that project produces. The independent reviews we've gotten so far confirmed my suspicions.
As for secure/private social networking, I don't know if there's really a way to do it that would take off. Non-paid internet services depend mainly on ad revenue. An advantage of current social networking sites is that analysis allows targeted advertising & brings in lots of revenue. Take that away & you get very little revenue in comparison. This is a problem if you are running a secure web service with tons of cryptography in it, which takes MUCH more resources to achieve performance of something like FB."
People want these independent, private, secure spaces but are unwilling to pay for them. Most of their friends and family probably are both unwilling to pay and unwilling to use them. Plus, you have to recreate most of the usefulness of modern web platforms. You have to do all that... very expensively to develop and run I'll add... while making almost no money on almost no users. Good luck.