3 ms·
Central planning, not so much. Not that it can't be, but we are replete with examples of it failing disastrously. Wasn't the Interstate Highway system a boon t
by stcredzero 11y ago
Central planning, not so much. Not that it can't be, but we are replete with examples of it failing disastrously.
Wasn't the Interstate Highway system a boon to the US economy? Wouldn't infrastrucure projects between the meta-urban regions fall into much the same pattern?
- Spivak 11y agoI don't think anyone is saying that the Federal government is without purpose. Interstate highways are exactly the type of project the Federal government should be taking on. That's not the type of central planning described in the article, this is the Federal government correcting a legitimate failing of a confederation. What was in the best interest of each state was opposed to the interests of the country as a whole. It's exactly analogous the position of a classical economist, except the states are the individual actors. Yes, markets sometimes fail, and it ought to be the duty of a central government to correct those failures when they happen but economic intervention should be rare and only when absolutely necessary.
- metaphorm 11y agofair point. I'll clarify my meaning a bit. central planning has a role to play. for certain types of projects it is appropriate and sometimes even necessary. however, the idea that central planning should be the starting point for economic development is wrong-headed in my opinion. it should be considered the exception, used when needed and not otherwise, not the rule. additionally, I challenge the notion that interstate infrastructure projects are actually examples of central planning. they are more like examples of networks of mutual development and collaboration between diverse partners. adoption of shared technical standards, agreement on shared funding models, and legal compacts to ensure shared responsibility for maintenance and upkeep are what drives projects like the interstate highway system.
- randyrand 11y agoWow. The federal government was able to connect some dots. I'm super impressed. What a great example of the power of centralized planning.