4 ms·
We should go back in the other direction and repeal the 17th amendment. The argument goes that if we do that the Senate appointments will be highly politicized
by maxerickson 11y ago
We should go back in the other direction and repeal the 17th amendment.
The argument goes that if we do that the Senate appointments will be highly politicized and so on, but uh, that's the way the elections are.
Having the Senate represent the interests of the state governments was a useful check on centralization of government at the federal level.
- AnimalMuppet 11y ago> Having the Senate represent the interests of the state governments was a useful check on centralization of government at the federal level. Confirming evidence: Shortly after the 17th amendment was passed, the federal government began growing dramatically.
- gohrt 11y ago>was a useful check on centralization of government at the federal level. Why? Those Senators were accountable to the people of their state, same as state legislatures.
- twoodfin 11y agoI am sympathetic to this idea, but I don't think it would work out the way you suppose. Rather than push the interests of state governments up into Washington, I think it would push Federal political debates down into state elections. Do we really want every state senate election to be fought over national issues rather than local ones?