4 ms·
It's even worse than that. If your house has appreciated more than $250k (or $500k if you're married) then you have to pay capital gains tax on the rest. And
by lisper 11y ago
It's even worse than that. If your house has appreciated more than $250k (or $500k if you're married) then you have to pay capital gains tax on the rest. And this is a fixed amount regardless of how long you've owned your home, so the longer you stay, and the more your house appreciates, the greater the penalty when you ultimately sell.
- kspaans 11y ago"Penalty", yeah because people have put in sooo much hard work to make their house values go up. (Sure, some people will spend money on renovations, and there could be tax credits for that. But I don't think that sitting on an asset and letting it appreciate should be a free lunch.)
- lisper 11y ago"Penalty" because someone who sells their house and buys a new one every time it appreciates $250k pays zero tax whereas someone who buys and holds pays significant tax despite having the same net gain over the same time period.
- kspaans 11y agoOK, fair point. I think you're right, it should be all or nothing.
- guelo 11y agoIf someone actually tried to execute that sell and buy strategy the large transaction costs would eat up any possible tax savings.
- dice 11y agoThere's a two year minimum that you must hold the home to qualify for the exclusion. So it's not "every time" it appreciates, but it is "once every two years". https://www.irs.gov/publications/p523/ar02.html#en_US_2015_publink1000200611 https://www.irs.gov/publications/p523/ar02.html#en_US_2015_p...
- lisper 11y agoSure, but that's just another manifestation of the same problem: someone who sells after 23 months and 29 days pays tax. Someone who sells three days later doesn't.
- SapphireSun 11y agoSeems simple to apply the tax rate pro-rata rather than on a cliff. Then the rule works more fairly and gaming is somewhat limited. Government seems to love rule cliffs for some reason.
- ethbro 11y agoArtifact of a pre-digital tax/legal system?
- bufordsharkley 11y agoCould one make the case that the liquidity this adds to the housing market justifies the tax savings?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- throwaway6497 11y agoI am not a tax expert but I have heard that as long you put the appreciation money back into a house purchase, you can keep all the appreciation upto 500K tax free.
- gigawhat 11y agoYup, if married and you've been there a couple of years. $250k if single. Still, almost anyone who bought a house a few years ago in the area is sitting on at least $500k in gains. So even if taxes on the remainder are arguably fair from a revenue perspective, they are another constraint on housing market liquidity.
- anxman 11y agoThere's two scenarios in which one can avoid or delay taxation when his home has appreciated: 1) $250k deduction if single ($500k deduction if married) during the year in which the capital gains has occurred. 2) Convert the property to a business and use a 1031 Like Kind Exchange in which 100% of the profits can be rolled into a new property and deferred until that property is liquidated or the gains are realized.
- Domenic_S 11y agoFor 1), you must have owned the home for 2+ year to qualify. If you're moving under 2 years for a "qualified reason" (death, birth of multiples, 50+ miles closer to work) you can take a pro-rated deduction. For 2), you cannot do a like-kind exchange for residential property that you live in as your primary home.
- anxman 11y agoYes, thanks for the clarifying points. For (2), if you convert the residential property into a business by renting it out, at what point can you do a 1031?
- troisx 11y agoI believe there's a two year minimum to get that capital gains exception, so you'd have to flip every two years.