4 ms·
Reaffirming once again that if "nobody can afford to buy them" the actual prices start coming down. A more interesting thing for me however was that owner occup
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Reaffirming once again that if "nobody can afford to buy them" the actual prices start coming down. A more interesting thing for me however was that owner occupied (which is to say the person buying the house lives there) has not been growing[1]. Instead third parties are buying the houses as investments and renting them. That is a really risky strategy in a place like SF with rent controls as the floor can fall out of the market, and you're unable to raise rents to cover your balloon payment (or other over leveraged strategy) and that squeezes the investor to default.
[1] https://www.homeunion.com/blog/investment-home-prices-rising-faster-than-owner-occupied-home-values/ https://www.homeunion.com/blog/investment-home-prices-rising...
- Flammy 11y agoA significant number are bought as investments, but NOT rented out, making the housing situation worse. Investors from more volatile economies (China) really see a few % up or down as incredibly stable compared to their native currency fluctuations.
- nitrogen 11y agoA huge chunk (but not a majority) of urban real estate in my city is also unoccupied most of the time, but I wonder how many are parking cash and how many are just summer vacation homes.
- fludlight 11y agoCurrency fluctuations are peanuts. The real risk in emerging markets is losing everything due to a massive economic downturn, political instability, or corruption.
- Cypher 11y agoEven if houses are flat its still better to put your cash into one than the bank...
- zippy 11y agobank - liquid asset house - illiquid, with maintenance, property tax, and insurance costs
- seanp2k2 11y agoTrue, with the other difference being that you can live in a house, but you can't live in securities or the bank vault. A house has actual utility (well, the first one), hence all the tax benefits (in theory). What I think is kind of ridiculous are all the benefits for second homes and beyond. IMO, if you're wealthy enough to afford a second home, you don't need any more government subsidies; all the benefits should go to people who don't yet have a place to live that they own. I can definitely see how this would be a very unpopular opinion among those with lots of potential money to lose if they could not keep the lower classes of people renting the property which they bought a lifetime++ deed to at a one-time cost.
- thescriptkiddie 11y agoContrary to popular belief, real estate is literally never a good investment. At best, prices go up faster than property tax and you profit modestly from the misfortune of others for a couple of years before the bubble bursts. At worst, your investment is rapidly eaten away by depreciation and maintenance costs.
- gozur88 11y agoIt's true houses aren't a very good investment over the long haul, but for most buyers with the leverage involved you can end up with quite a windfall if you get lucky.
- gozur88 11y agoSpoken like someone who's never owned a house.
- kspaans 11y agoRemember that rent control only applies to buildings built before 1978, so it's not _all_ rent controlled.
- 100k 11y agoAnd rent control doesn't apply to single family homes. That said, if the market falls it is easy to end up with a mortgage that costs more than rent, a fact that I am unfortunately familiar with.
- andersen1488 11y agoIt's scary to think that in 20-30 years nearly the entire available housing stock will not be covered by rent control. My landlord wanted to raise my rent 40% in one year here in Oakland until I pointed out the laws. Eventually the entire middle class will just be landless peasants again, allowed to live wherever the rich say that they can.
- rconti 11y agoIt's only scary if you believe rent control is a net benefit.
- beatpanda 11y agoNo, facing a 40% increase in your rent without an attendant increase in your wages or salary is scary no matter what the macro situation is. Anybody working on or thinking about housing policy needs to keep this in mind -- no matter how right your policy prescriptions may be, you need to keep in mind that they may do massive harm to individuals in the short term. And the failure to even try to ameliorate those harms is one of the reasons why things like getting rid of rent control are politically impossible.
- pjlegato 11y agoAdvocates for the reverse ought to bear in mind that however noble the goal of avoiding harm to individuals in the short term may be, the harm done to individuals in the long term is even more massive, and then much harder to fix. Two case in point examples: Prop 13, and rent control. These are not, as popularly concieved, great ways to protect the poor and disadvantaged. They are simply examples of very short term thinking becoming public policy, which has the unintended and paradoxical effect of harming the poor and disadvantaged much more in the long run.