3 ms·
But that too is as it should be. Extra tax on the wealthy means they have to settle for the Citation Jet instead of the Gulfstream. Extra tax on the poor mean
by lisper 11y ago
But that too is as it should be. Extra tax on the wealthy means they have to settle for the Citation Jet instead of the Gulfstream. Extra tax on the poor means they have to choose whether to pay for food or rent this month.
- mc32 11y agoRight but that goes against the narrative which permeates indie media where the 1% are freeloading devils with offshore accounts who are running the state into the ground because they are not paying their fair share of taxes. Mind you I'm not a 1%er. Not that that should have any bearing. But indie media have their dead horse they like to climb on and it wears thin.
- matthewmacleod 11y agoI'd point out though that the oft-cited '1%' is often shorthand for '0.1%' – that maybe lazy, but a different figure.
- philangist 11y agoIt also generally refers to the top '1%' with regards to wealth, not income.
- lisper 11y ago> the 1% are freeloading devils Some are. Some aren't.
- blazespin 11y agoYou don't understand. 45% of 1 million means nothing. Maybe skimp on the next vacation to Paris. 20% income tax on 60k means someone might never be able to retire or help pay for his kids college degree.
- bdcravens 11y agoAs long as we can poke fun at what they spend their money on, and dehumanize them, we can justify any tax level. Maybe that extra 17% could have gone into angel investments. Perhaps the idea that those that earn 28% of the income need to be taxed at 45% is an indictment on California's spending.
- fredrik-j 11y agoIf you look beyond the fun poking and focus on the facts, you'll still find that the trickle down economic policy your argument imply simply doesn't work. https://psmag.com/the-imf-confirms-that-trickle-down-economics-is-indeed-a-joke-207d7ca469b https://psmag.com/the-imf-confirms-that-trickle-down-economi... http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/cat/longres.aspx?sk=42986.0 http://www.imf.org/external/pubs/cat/longres.aspx?sk=42986.0
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoSo change the 1% to the 99% "takers" and you have the other indie media ( which appears to be in rapid decline ).
- basch 11y agowho has more to lose if order and the fabric of society break down, those with or those without? if you already have nothing, and live in uncivilized territorty, the breakdown of order will make things worse, but marginally less so than for those isolated from the ills of poverty. lets call a spade a spade and treat tax like what it is, a protection racket. you are protecting yourself from two things: alien invaders and zombie hoards. health care, food, housing, and, entertainment keep the hoards from destroying your logistics infrastructures and disrupting transportation routes. it also keeps them just alive enough to keep buying what you are selling. defense, police forces, and tough crime laws reduce your risk of having your factories and warehouses bombed or burned to the ground. in short, you are paying for muscle and placation, keeping the peace. (edit: forgot, you are also paying for intellectual property protection, so your inventiveness cant be cloned or repackaged.) why should the 'rich' pay the majority of the taxes? because it benefits them the most to have low crime healthy consumers. whose problem does it end up being if the 99% are unemployed, homeless, starving, diseased, and unable to consume. whose house slash bunker is going to get broken into, the person with nothing, or the person with years of survival stockpile? why should the 'rich' pay the majority of the taxes? because they are the ones with something to lose (a business, a family, a lifestyle), worth paying to protect. all that said, im not defending the current tax code or federal government as an efficient or effective way to put that "protection/socialorder" tax to good use.
- prostoalex 11y agoConsidering most of the rich can move at a moment's notice, aren't you over-estimating their reliance on "low crime healthy consumers"? There's an entire cottage industry in places like Monaco, Panama or St Kitts & Nevis built on rejecting that thesis. Additionally, is California with its high income tax rates significantly safer and healthier than states with no such tax, like Washington or Nevada?
- humanrebar 11y agoWhy not tax consumption if your concern is consumption? Tax (NET_INCOME-(NET_SAVINGS+POVERTY_LEVEL)) or something. EDIT: The responses are all assuming the tax is regressive. Note the POVERTY_LEVEL constant in there. And the tax rate itself could be progressive. 0% under 20k (if that's the poverty level), 15% on the next 30k, 25% on the next 50k, etc.
- ecnal 11y agoProgressive consumption taxes based around this enjoy a great deal of support among economists and very little support among politicians, unfortunately.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoConsumption taxes are quite regressive. The wealthy have the means to define consumption down.
- lisper 11y agoBecause taxing consumption is regressive. The real problem is the positive feedback loop where money buys political influence, which then results in laws that favor the already-rich at the expense of everyone else. Taxing consumption won't fix that. Taxing political contributions might fix it, but you can't do that because political contributions (a.k.a. bribes) are now protected under the First Amendment thanks to Citizens United. High marginal income tax rates or a wealth tax (or reversing Citizens United) are the only ways to fix the problem AFAICT.
- prostoalex 11y ago> Because taxing consumption is regressive. How come? There are entire categories of consumption that open up with significant wealth? Private aviation, yachts, fine arts are all categories with spending heavily concentrated up top - a poor person is unlikely to own a proportional 1/1000th share of a Gulfstream jet or a Picasso.
- lisper 11y ago
- cmdrfred 11y agoReminds me of this: http://southpark.cc.com/clips/103759/not-a-big-deal http://southpark.cc.com/clips/103759/not-a-big-deal
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]