3 ms·
"Most earnings for the top 1 percent come from investment proceeds; the stock market has risen steadily since mid-2011." There's no particular reason that middl
by sp332 11y ago
"Most earnings for the top 1 percent come from investment proceeds; the stock market has risen steadily since mid-2011." There's no particular reason that middle-class people couldn't make the exact same investments in the stock market. The only difference is a lower amount of capital to invest. "Created" is not the word I'd use to describe investing your wealth and sitting around waiting for a return.
- Randgalt 11y agoWhen I buy a stock or invest in some company, I'm taking a risk. That risk is a type of production - it requires me to think and make decisions. Obviously, I can lose in an investment. So, yes, it is a productive activity.
- sp332 11y agoAnd yet, it's much less risky that what everyone else has been doing, since mean and median incomes have declined.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoThey have not declined. They just have not kept up.
- sp332 11y agoFrom the article: "Average adjusted gross income for filers in the second-highest fifth dropped by about 1 percent.... Adjusted gross income in the second-lowest fifth declined the most, 9 percent".
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoOn an adjusted basis, sure. I was speaking in absolute terms. What's happening is that people are leaving the second quintile. About 1/3 move down, 2/3 move up. The sort of thing people in the second quintile used to do has evaporated.
- ryandrake 11y agoThe same could be said about gambling. Are roulette players "creating wealth"?
- throwbot 11y agoThat exact statement applies to the work of stealing a painting. If you want to defend investment as productive activity, you're going to have to be a little more thorough than that.
- jcoffland 11y agoIf you think anyone can make the same investments then you don't know finance very well. The highest earning investments require huge amounts of cash to participate in and they are not a matter of simply holding some stocks.
- sp332 11y agoEither way, the difference is how much capital you start with.
- nugget 11y agoI don't think this is true any more. If you buy and hold index ETFs you'll outperform the majority of professional investors due to the very low expense ratios. Some people with lots of influence like Warren Buffett or David Swensen @ Yale have access to slightly better risk-reward adjusted opportunities but that's a very small group of folks. Even Warren Buffett has instructed his estate to keep its assets in SPY the S&P 500 index fund after his death. Every time you hear about wealthy people earning a huge return on an investment just remind yourself that risk-reward is baked into almost everything in the markets and what you're not seeing is the many other investors who chased similar investments but lost.
- grahamburger 11y agoIsn't investing the definitive way to use money to create wealth? The companies they're investing in have obviously been able to use that money to grow, right? And growing usually means providing more jobs and creating wealth.