2 ms·
It is a surprisingly common fallacy to believe that income is generated in a way that is not deeply coupled to the system in which it was generated. This is ju
by ska 11y ago
It is a surprisingly common fallacy to believe that income is generated in a way that is not deeply coupled to the system in which it was generated. This is just muddy thinking if you are talking about the "1%" or your own IRS bill.
I think that the comment you were responding to was suggesting that the tax load should be directly proportional to the income fraction, which I suppose you could make a cogent argument of.
- Mikeb85 11y agoYup. As one of my economics professors likes to say (paraphrasing): There is no 'natural' equilibrium. The economy develops based on the set of laws already in place. People earn money based on the 'system' already in place. So the idea of 'fairness' is already an artificial construct. It's far easier to make a billion in a society like the US, than say, Vietnam, or Argentina, or Romania. So in a very real way, US billionaires do 'owe' something to the system that allowed them to attain that wealth in the first place (and that 'something' is pretty much 'everything'). If wealth could be attained completely independently of the 'system', then the distribution of billionaires would be completely different than it is right now.