9 ms·
No More Religion, More Tactics for Civilization V
- pragmatic 17y agoThis may date me, but I've played all 4 previous Civ games. Although the games have improved graphically and added interesting concepts. However, the games have become VERY long. I used to be able to sit down and crank out a game in an afternoon or 2. Now it seems to take days to complete a normal game. Time I just don't have. I think there's an opportunity for someone to make a turn based strategy game with the original CIV concepts. Just make it playable in one sitting. There isn't much else out there in the turn based strategy genre. Seems like wide open category.
- rms 17y agoYou might want to check out Rise of Nations -- it's an RTS but it incorporated Civilization like gameplay better than any other game of its type that I have played. If anyone knows of a more recent similar strategy game, I'd like to hear about it.
- GHFigs 17y agoSeconded. The lead designer of Rise of Nations was Brian Reynolds, who also designed "Sid Meier's" Civilization II and Alpha Centauri, and it shows. Just make sure you don't have anything important planned for the next six months.
- whatusername 17y agoHave you tried Civ Revolutions? I've got the iPhone version, haven't touched it on a console. It's a weak and terrible imitation on so many levels - BUT - it feels like a cross between Civ IV and Civ I. And it is certainly shorter than Civ IV.
- zokier 17y agoWhy should one game finish in one sitting? Some players even play "longturn" games where one turn could take a day, and games would last for months.
- pragmatic 17y agoI'm not saying it has to, but I would like something of the old Civ. Maybe I'm old but I don't have the time/patience for a game that last months. If you prefer a marathon game that's fine, I'm not arguing that. Conquering the world in a marathon 6 hour session was pretty fun. I think there's an opportunity for a game that strips away some of the complexity of the new Civ while keeping the fun elements. Multiplayer isn't that important to me. WoW destroyed the last interest I had in playing with random people on the internet (too many 12 year olds doing stupid things with their Avatars). Felt like I was wasting time rather than having an fun immersive experience. My time is more valuable now then it was in high school/college. I have 3 hours to conquer the world, not 3 days. YMMV.
- lionhearted 17y agoEdit: Wow, this turned out to be a long comment. tl;dr - you can change playstyle to cut 50-80% of the time off your Civ IV games and play them quickly. It's my favorite game, so here's a long comment that'll really only make complete sense for Civ players. Civ IV is one of my favorite games, and I used to have the same problem - games took forever. But, you can drastically speed up games by changing settings and playstyle. Generally: 1. Less land 2. Less ocean 3. Less civs 4. Less space 5. Higher difficulties are conducive to a faster game. Yes, higher difficulties, because you'll lose early fairly often, and the games where you don't lose stay very stimulating and exciting. Mid/lower settings mean you'll win more often, but it's slow and boring at the end after you've got a dominating lead. Playing out the endgame becomes rote. Also, the way you play changes it. Later wars and offensive wars take more time. If you war early and wipe out the nearest Civ or two near you between axes, swords, elephants, and catapults - the pre longbow wars - they go pretty fast, then with the extra space you can build out without fearing war very much for the rest of the game. Alternatively, defensive wars where you use defensive units and let yourself be attacked go faster. Finally, smaller, better utilized empires can mean less playtime. In Civ IV you have a big tradeoff with the exponential growth cost of cities. That means you can choose between trying to aim for a 9-12 city late-game before you go on a rampage, or the "as many cities as possible" way. But really, 9-12 very good cities and razing the rest of the enemy cities plays a lot faster. There's a lot of mediocre cities that "break even" on their contributions to research/production of their cost. You can simply not take them at all, just don't found them, or burn them down if you capture them. That said, this is conducive to different buildings, civics, and playstyle. Bureaucracy becomes much more powerful, State Property is weakened. Courthouses go from first priority with a larger empire to a nice "if we've got free time" sort of thing. If you're playing a smaller empire, you have less frontier/border cities, so it's easier to build walls and castles to fight a defensive war if/when you get invaded. Etc, etc. My Civ IV games used to run 30+ hours. With a different playstyle, I can now usually see if I've got a reasonable chance to win within 2-6 hours, and then I'm looking at maybe 4-5 more hours of pretty exciting endgame if so. And I micromanage my production and wars quite a bit - if you don't mind using the "optimize xyz" options that get things 90% right, you can bang out a pretty good game in 3-4 hours. Compare that to my old way where the game was decided after 10-15 hours, and then you're looking at 10-20 hours of boring "cleanup" where you slog along to victory and... yeah, I like it much better this way. Edit: A good way to learn to play fast games that teach you a lot is to go Duel-sized map, one random opponent, opponent, Deity difficult, and be one of the Civs with a good early war unit like Persia or Mongolia. Make 1 or 2 cities, hook up horses/copper/iron, and try to take the other side out. It's harder than it sounds, and it'll be a one to two hour game. You'll learn more about higher difficulties, early build priorities for fast wars, and using terrain and prioritizing in combat. The computer has such a production edge that you need to play the tactics very well to slow them down, put choke points in their land so they can't hook up metal for the counter to your unit, and so on. Similarly small map/high difficulties/gear towards winning or losing early makes fun games while teaching specific skills.
- GeneralMaximus 17y agoTried FreeCiv? You can even send them patches that enable "lightening-mode" or something :)
- adamc 17y agoThe changes sound to me like Civilization is evolving into a completely different game. A big part of the appeal of the original Civ was the simplified combat. I think this may open that niche to other competitors.
- andrewvc 17y agoI've been a huge fan of Civ, I started playing it with Civ I, but have never liked any of the combat models. The notion of an artillery unit attacking a city all by itself makes no sense, even with the notion of withdrawing. Units need to be grouped, and combat should be executed in multiple phases ( ranged weapons, then melee ). Additionally, if a single marine attacks a tile with 20 marines on it, the 20 marines should take it out with no losses 99.9% of the time. The one on one model makes no sense.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoStacked units should fight one at a time, so Thermopylae can still happen. It adds a lot of depth to the game--particularly at higher levels--when a single unit can can drastically slow down a large group of units, just by staying on defensible terrain in an isthmus.
- mynameishere 17y agoThe biggest problem with Civ I and II was the combat system. (Not really because it was simple, but because it was broken in every way.) Modern armored units attacking Greek Phalanxes and losing? Modern riflemen being defeated by chariots? Routinely.
- byrneseyeview 17y agoCiv II basically fixed that. But I'm not even sure it's possible to have a balanced game and a historically accurate game, unless you have some kind of "Zeitgeist" function that keeps one player from getting a big technology lead over another. If the game mechanics let you discover gunpowder in 0 AD, they turn the entire thing into a race to get good technology. Alternatively, they could make technologically advanced units prohibitively expensive if you're the only player with the technology, and very cheap when everyone has it.
- InclinedPlane 17y agoFor those who are interested, Civilization 1 is abandonware and now (mostly)legally downloadable and playable for free: http://www.abandonia.com/en/games/14/Civilization.html http://www.abandonia.com/en/games/14/Civilization.html It's a 16-bit DOS app so there's a pretty high chance you'll need dosbox to play it.
- btilly 17y agoI must have missed the memo where copyright law had changed so that abandonware was legally downloadable and playable for free before the absurdly long copyright term (thanks, Disney) expired. The rules may not be actively enforced, but they still exist and there is always the possibility that someone could wake up to the fact that they now own the copyright, and they could create grief for you. An admittedly unlikely scenario, but still possible.
- frederickcook 17y agoTough not to draw a comparison here with illegal music. Is there any reasonable expectation that the gaming industry will take the route the RIAA took and start going after people? It seems like these old games are quite different from old music: both make most of their money immediately upon release, but games lose their appeal much faster as newer games come out, while the appeal of music may last an order of magnitude longer, and isn't necessarily replaceable. Also, while music may continue to make money on the radio or in commercials or movies or other media, games pretty much lose the revenue stream after the first few months. I recall a few weeks ago another game (C&C maybe?) made news here for releasing an early version in promotion of a new version. You don't see Metallica giving away old tunes in promotion of a new album, do you?
- btilly 17y agoI am not a prophet, but I doubt that will happen. However there are a lot of people with nostalgia. If someone, somewhere, could put together a legal product that made it easy for a lot of people to take a walk down memory lane, they could find a good market. Such a vendor would have a strong incentive to acquire copyright to abandoned titles then enforce said copyright. This would cause backlash, but it isn't impossible that someone with money and energy could take this step. Of course the first barrier that such a company would have is getting copyright permission to the core operating system they need to emulate. Those copyrights are owned by companies like Apple and Microsoft which are aware of the issue and show no desire to bother themselves by getting involved.
- Ernestas 17y agoIt is interesting how their social game play will be developed. [http://www.facebook.com/civnetwork?v=info http://www.facebook.com/civnetwork?v=info]
- nazgulnarsil 17y agoCan anyone explain the appeal of "strategy" games? every one I've ever played seems like excel with a GUI. figure out what parameters affect income, optimize. I had some fun with Sins of a Solar Empire, but more just for the spectacle of big fleets than anything else. This will come off as pompous but whenever my friends convince me to try a new one I play for a little while and then basically go "I could be playing chess or go right now" and that's the end of it. Is it mostly just the fun of commanding armies? Do people find exploring the optimization process fun?
- frederickcook 17y agoLife is Excel with a GUI. (Figure out what parameters affect income, optimize.)
- nazgulnarsil 17y agoright, but people choose to spend their leisure time playing computer strategy games as stress relief from "life".
- allenp 17y agoWhile the "math" of strategy games are typically exposed (and with it the ability to optimize) - the fun of strategy games is to balance competing demands by making decisions with long-term consequences. The difficulty with creating strategy games is to make something replayable that isn't formulaic. I think the Civ series has succeeded so far because of its ability to introduce enough chaos that no single pattern of game play will always win no matter what. (Though unfortunately I don't feel there is much variation in the harder difficulty levels which does produce a stagnant experience).
- ramchip 17y agoIt's not all about optimization. Take Starcraft: I like the characters, the gradual development. Japanese strategy games sometimes even have more content than actual novels (for example, the Galaxy Angel series are all visual novels with Homeworld-style space combat interspersed in the story). I like discovering the new buildings, seeing new units, watching a volley of missiles being shot, feeling like the armchair commander as reports from other characters come in :) Although I like chess as well, after a long day, I find it much more relaxing to watch the tank driver take position and blow up a bunch of zergs, than to think about abstract units like a rook. I must say I don't like most modern strategy games however... I'd much rather play Settlers III than Settlers 7, the original Stronghold over Stronghold 2, or civ 2 over civ 3. Somehow the transition from isometric to full 3D made the game much harder to control for me, and I prefer good drawings to 3D renderings. Japanese games are still very 2D-based though so I play a lot of them. YMMV.
- allenp 17y agoFor anyone that is getting a 404, more info is here: http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=354036 http://forums.civfanatics.com/showthread.php?t=354036 And screenshots: http://www.civfanatics.com/gallery/browseimages.php?c=36 http://www.civfanatics.com/gallery/browseimages.php?c=36 Looks shiny :)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]