3 ms·
It's not a new law, and in response to this incident Merkel has said she wants to get rid of this law, so how is it getting worse?
by vidarh 11y ago
It's not a new law, and in response to this incident Merkel has said she wants to get rid of this law, so how is it getting worse?
- Retric 11y agoThe right to grant a federal pardon lies in the office of the President of Germany, but he or she can transfer this power to other persons, such as the chancellor or the minister of justice. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pardon#Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pardon#Germany Pardons are a vital check on the justice system. I don't know all the details, and this might be a lower level judgment. But, if she had the power and said no, then that's a terrible sign regardless of the words out of her mouth. On the other hand if the government gave up the right to pardon that's also terrible.
- germanier 11y agoThis has absolutely nothing to do with a pardon (which would happen after a verdict anyway). For this particular law the prosecution needs the approval of the federal government to go forward. That is all that happened.
- Retric 11y agoAnd the government said Yep, go ahead. At which point he suffers even if not convicted. Remember, right now today he is being penalized for saying something people in power did not want said. That's a bad thing.
- germanier 11y agoNobody is being penalized or suffering right now. He has great support and this decision didn't change anything. Merkel even specifically said that they want to abolish that law. They didn't decide based on the merit of the claim but only based on principle (no matter what that law says, independent courts should decide).
- Retric 11y agoClearly, going in front of judge to plead your case is a day in the park free from any downsides what so ever! Wait no, that's not true at all. Being forced to go to a trial is being deprived of your liberty while your there. Even just waiting for that day is highly stressful.
- germanier 11y agoThe prosecution could still decide to throw the case out if they don't think it has any merit. Just the same as with any other law where the government isn't even asked for their opinion. He would have been prosecuted anyway. If the government hadn't greenlight it under that law it would run under the label of the general insult law. In practice this decision shouldn't have changed anything for him. It just sent a message: "In Germany the courts are independent. We won't interfere, even if we could."
- Retric 11y ago"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing." This is someone not taking a stand for justice when they could. They had the power and option to make the right choice and they chose the politically expedient one. This is worse than "I was only following orders" this is actively choosing the wrong thing.
- notahacker 11y agoThis rather depends on whether you believe that allowing the independent judicial system to decide whether satirists get a day in court they more or less literally asked for (whilst announcing you intend to abolish the law and the criminal penalties associated with it anyway) is really "the triumph of evil". I think that argument's quite hard to sustain. There's even an argument that in this instance the less just course of action might be a powerful politician stepping into thwart the usual judicial process and signalling to the wider world that Western democrats, like Turkish autocrats, don't see anything wrong with subordinating the judiciary to executive fiat when a particular case allows them to step in.
- vidarh 11y agoPardons require that there be a court decision first. The point of a pardon is to decide that someone has somehow paid their debt to society, but you can't reasonably make such a decision without first having a decision whether or not a crime occurred, and if so, what the legal punishment should be. If these people are convicted, then it might be reasonable for her to pardon them after the facts have been documented by the court. In this case it is not about a pardon, but about an archaic law that requires consent from the government before prosecution, allowing the government to prevent someone from having their case heard based on political considerations.
- Retric 11y agoNot in the US, you can be pardoned before trial. Germany might be different, but it's a common setup, and the law requires the government to say OK. EX: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pardon_of_Richard_Nixon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pardon_of_Richard_Nixon