5 ms·
The most interesting thing to me is that Cruise went through YC, several funding rounds and most of a massive public acquisition - apparently before anyone did
by AndrewKemendo 11y ago
The most interesting thing to me is that Cruise went through YC, several funding rounds and most of a massive public acquisition - apparently before anyone did enough due diligence to find out about this being even a potential problem (if the claimant has any grounds - which it seems there are at least some amount) and heading it off at the pass.
That alone speaks volumes.
- hendzen 11y agoAgreed, this is a massive fuck-up by everyone involved (Altman, Cruise Board of Directors, Spark Capital, etc). Even if the claim has no merit it should have been dealt with long ago, before the company got to this stage. Now all the employees might get screwed as a result.
- proksoup 11y agoThey did fail to identify the problem .... But if there's any anger from screwed employees, it should be directed at the criminals who did the bullshit crime instead of the detectives who failed to identify the crime sooner, no?
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoIn this case there is a fiduciary duty from the investors (detectives in your metaphor) to make sure that the company is free from these kinds of things. So while they aren't to blame - they aren't really off the hook either - it's more of a sin of omission. And yes, in many cases when detectives or investigators in law enforcement are lazy with their work and miss something obvious, they often pay for it with their jobs.
- hashkb 11y agoThere will be enough anger for everyone.
- proksoup 11y agoThat's pretty crazy to me.
- migep 11y agoI don't think it's fair to blame all of the investors. The later investors were almost certainly misled, and not informed of this risk. YC on the other hand was clearly informed that there was an individual who was considered a founder at some point in time. Despite knowledge of this risk, they invested and they facilitated follow-on financing. Now there's a big, dumb, expensive problem. YC dropped the ball, big-time. The fact that Sam Altman is turning this into a public spectacle is further evidence that he knows YC fucked up badly, and probably doesn't have a legal case. The only reason to write what he wrote is if you're out of actual ammo.
- hendzen 11y agoVC firms are sophisticated investors and are supposed to conduct due diligence on behalf of their L.P's. Part of what the big management fees they charge are supposed to go to is ensuring that each investment is legally sound - i.e. having their people verify the incorporation documents, cap table, etc. So yes, the fact that this situation has become known at this terribly late stage reflects badly on all the investors in previous rounds.
- migep 11y agoI'm familiar with due diligence processes. They're why I believe the later stage VCs are likely the victims of fraud on the part of Cruise's D&Os. All of those investors would've demanded a clean separation agreement if they had any information regarding the co-founder.
- davemel37 11y ago> The only reason to write what he wrote is if you're out of actual ammo. This is really astute. In my experience, more often than not, when someone becomes angry at someone else, deep down they are really angry at themselves for letting something happen.
- rpgmaker 11y ago> The fact that Sam Altman is turning this into a public spectacle is further evidence that he knows YC fucked up badly, and probably doesn't have a legal case. The only reason to write what he wrote is if you're out of actual ammo. This. That post was a huge red flag and after reading the claim it's very clear why he posted it.
- imron 11y ago> That alone speaks volumes. Move fast, break things. I bet this is one thing that will be fixed for all future applications.
- jboydyhacker 11y agoIf you had a partner who left after a month - then do a financing right thereafter with vesting schedules and the like it's easy to assume that those same schedules apply to everyone. If it were to be caught- it would have been at the Series A but it sounds like so much time passed and his involvement was so short people just forgot about the guy. If Jeremy never said a word about it since it would never come up. If I owned 50% of a company and it did a financing- I'd certainly inquire about my shares. Sounds like he never even did that. Kyle probably feels like shit I am sure- it's a sickening case to read but to be honest I could see it going down exactly like that.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- forgetsusername 11y ago>That alone speaks volumes. It's also pretty scary that YC are willing to railroad a co-founder in favour of a SV insider.