4 ms·
Even without getting into Free Software territory, there are reasonable expectations about what open source means. It's not just "you are free to read the code"
by the_af 11y ago
Even without getting into Free Software territory, there are reasonable expectations about what open source means. It's not just "you are free to read the code". See:
- https://opensource.org/osd-annotated https://opensource.org/osd-annotated
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-source_software https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-source_software
- chris_wot 11y agoIndeed - "open" means open to modification.
- arcticfox 11y agoWhat do you call source that is open to read then? It's definitely not closed-source. I have always thought of source as either open (with many flavors of licensing) or closed.
- bobbyi_settv 11y ago> What do you call source that is open to read then? "Closed source" is the standard term. Since you seen to not like that term, you could go with "proprietary".
- twr 11y ago> "Closed source" is the standard term. Since you seen to not like that term, you could go with "proprietary". Your definitions go contrary to the understandings and usages of every non-F/OSS person on the Internet. For example, both "closed source" and "proprietary" are used to mean source-code-not-available in gaming circles. Perhaps the open source movements should seek intuitive definitions of terms rather than invent vague nomenclature that only makes them unable to communicate with normal users.
- the_af 11y agoThe definitions of open source are actually quite technical. They are not vague like you suggest. It's unavoidable that people will be confused about terms outside their area of expertise. Since you mentioned gamers: I shudder at the vast multitude of confusing terms the various gamer communities use, like for example in WoW. However, I think you're overstating your case: I suspect few gamers, if any, will confuse leaked source code or code which you're not allowed to use in any way as "open source". I don't expect them to undestand every nuance, but surely even they understand source code you're not allowed to run or modify is not "open" in any meaningful interpretation of the term :)
- twr 11y ago> but surely even they understand source code you're not allowed to run or modify is not "open" in any meaningful interpretation of the term :) "Run" or "modify" are not requisites in the common understanding of "open source"; legality of viewing is. "Open" to them usually means it can be distributed (to them) and read without breaking the law.
- CamperBob2 11y agoThe definitions of open source are actually quite technical. Says who? The Pope? Richard Stallman? Bernie Sanders? Some random self-appointed authority figure who goes by the name "the_af" on Hacker News? Whose name is on the trademark application?
- the_af 11y agoI'm not sure what you mean. I was replying to user twr who said: > Perhaps the open source movements should seek intuitive definitions of terms rather than invent vague nomenclature that only makes them unable to communicate with normal users. The "open source movements" he/she mentioned have very technical definitions of what open source means (of varying degree, of course, but have you tried reading the GPL? Do you think it's non-technical?). Of all the valid criticisms you could throw at them, "vague nomenclature" is not one. Their definitions of open source may be difficult to communicate precisely because they are very technical, not because they are "vague". I think "who" was quite clear in this context. Do you disagree?
- wonderlust 11y agoYou are literally the first person on the internet I've ever seen to believe this. Everyone either doesn't know the concept at all, or knows it to be more or less exactly what open source people say it is. Its been well defined since my beginnings in the AOL cd era, pay per hour 28k modem days. Its not just Foss people, its common knowledge among technical people.
- zaroth 11y agoIf free open source meant the same as open source, then wouldn't they be called "oss people" and not "foss people"? I've heard the term "published source" used when trying hard not to step in this particular pile.
- arcticfox 11y agoFrom an article on gnu.org discussing related issues, here's a quote from author Neal Stephenson: > Linux is “open source” software meaning, simply, that anyone can get copies of its source code files. And the state of Kansas: > Make use of open-source software (OSS). OSS is software for which the source code is freely and publicly available, though the specific licensing agreements vary as to what one is allowed to do with that code. For me, the reason for the confusion comes from (1) the ambiguous use of the word "open" (visible) vs "closed" (hidden) and (2) the fact that I've personally never seen until now a project that was "source available" but not open to modify under some license, so I haven't had to deal with the distinction. (And since I'm a little insulted by your incredulity that a technical person could believe that to be true, FWIW, it's common knowledge among English speakers when to use "its" and "it's".)
- arcticfox 11y agoAnd here, even Richard Stallman admits the obvious meaning of the expression: > However, the obvious meaning for the expression “open source software”—and the one most people seem to think it means—is “You can look at the source code.” http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point.h...
- Nursie 11y ago"Shared Source"
- brobinson 11y agoI've also heard "source available" used.
- arcticfox 11y agoThanks, this seems to be the best nomenclature. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-source_software#Open-source_vs._source-available https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open-source_software#Open-sour...
- CamperBob2 11y agoThere are many opinions regarding what constitutes "open source" (capitalized or not.) Those are two of them.
- the_af 11y agoYes, there are many opinions, but the most reasonable expectations are spelled out by the above links. These expectations are so common that anyone who uses "open source" to mean something different is being purposefully disingenuous. "Open source" is no longer an obscure concept, so fringe definitions are less acceptable. Note this is unrelated to the many incompatibilities between the various open source licenses. Also see: Microsoft's "Shared Source", an example of something that may look like open source but (with some exceptions) isn't. Disclaimer: no idea if this still exists, now that Microsoft seems to be truly embracing open source for some of its software.
- Retric 11y agoEnglish is not defined by any specific authority. All common usages are accepted, and open source as in visible source is a common usage, though perhaps not by people you spend time around.
- Retric 11y agoPeople tried to redefine the term. Originally Open Source simply meant you had the source code and hey if you have it you can edit it because well you physically can edit it. This of course did not kill the original meaning it just added a new one. Because, English is happy to have a single terms mean multiple things.