3 ms·
Politically I don't see it being any different to progressive taxes which many (most?) countries already implement. Practically I suspect it will need to be qu
by tonyedgecombe 11y ago
Politically I don't see it being any different to progressive taxes which many (most?) countries already implement.
Practically I suspect it will need to be quite low to avoid all sorts of distortions.
- Overtonwindow 11y agoBy politically I'm imagining a politician campaigning on the promise to increase the basic minimum income. Vote for me and I'll get your basic income increased. Don't vote for my opponent because they just want to cut your basic income! It's the tax issue all over again.
- twoodfin 11y agoExactly, and just as likely to be gummed up by complexity. After all, how can you be against teachers and firefighters receiving just a little more BI for their essential, thankless jobs?
- pgeorgi 11y agobut such considerations are what their actual income is for.
- Retric 11y agoYou forget the US is run by the rich, which is why this does not happen with Social Security. It's all about not having the benefit cut instead of increasing benefits or lowering retirement age.
- BurningFrog 11y agoI haven't listened to the episode, but the Basic Income that makes sense is one that replaces all/most welfare programs. The existing programs are very distorting already, often giving poor people 100%+ marginal taxes. Sure, Basic Income would be distorting, but far less than that. It should also save a lot of money since it requires almost no people to administer. This is also the biggest problem with instituting it, since the people holding those jobs will fight to the death to keep them.
- dageshi 11y agoI don't believe it will replace all/most welfare programs. I think it will replace some and then politicians will be elected to top it up for select groups. "Fairness" will come into play, "I am disadvantaged compared to this other person, I should get more, it's only Fair". Plus regional top ups, cost of living in different places is higher than others, I expect there will be a demand for a top up based on cost of living on top of basic BI, again that'll need to be enforced and administered.
- lawlessone 11y agoit doesn't even exist yet and he's trying to distort it.