3 ms·
The entire point of that section of the DMCA was to make it easy for rights-holders to get something pulled from a site. While the DMCA definitely puts too much
by pyre 17y ago
The entire point of that section of the DMCA was to make it easy for rights-holders to get something pulled from a site. While the DMCA definitely puts too much power in the hands of rights-holders, the previous method was to sue the infringer and then wait for a court to issue an injunction (which could tend to take a while; the courts aren't really known for their speedy service).
Rights-holders obviously don't like the idea that the infringing material just sits there being distributed to anyone that wants it while all the legal ducks are lined up for filing suit and petitioning a judge to issue the injunction.
> If I was to claim Microsoft infringed my copyright, would they take microsoft.com offline for 10 days?
The big players obviously have the rules bent for them, especially since they have large legal teams. I assume that if you have a large, highly-paid legal team, your hosting provider might also let you leave your content up with the understanding that your legal team will help them out if the DMCA-notice-issuer comes a-knockin'. Either that, or they make enough money off of your account to warrant paying legal fees to defend themselves in order to keep you as a happy customer.
In your example, Microsoft would probably just remove the offending material, then rush the court documents to get a suit underway so that a judge could issue a ruling allowing them to distribute it while the matter was decided.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoThe issue, it seems to me, is that a rights-holder by that definition is anyone who _claims_ to be a rights holder. I would expect there to be some form of plausibility check by an independent person, otherwise there could be completely frivolous denial of service attacks based on this law.