5 ms·
What a great PR piece for Warren... but unfortunately this is just smoke and mirrors. This does +absolutely nothing+ to simplify the tax code, this is solely a
by Alupis 11y ago
What a great PR piece for Warren... but unfortunately this is just smoke and mirrors.
This does +absolutely nothing+ to simplify the tax code, this is solely about "simplifying" tax preparation and filing.
It makes it easier to file online for free, and makes it so the IRS can't get in bed with Intuit, HR Block, etc.
We need real tax reform - not smoke and mirrors.
- davidw 11y ago> It makes it easier to file online for free That's not a bad thing in and of itself.
- Alupis 11y ago> > It makes it easier to file online for free > That's not a bad thing in and of itself. You're absolutely right. However, this is being touted as tax [code] reform... which it's definitely not. Your tax preparation expenses are already tax deductible, so making it "cheaper" doesn't really help anyone. We need a simpler and more fair tax code - but we're not getting any of that with this bill. This is a distraction, and good PR for someone potentially poised for a VP ticket...
- dmix 11y agoThe question is not whether the end goal is good, or whether their intentions are in the right place, it's whether it's the best use of government resources to focus on this vs other things. Could they be spending their limited time/resources on more valuable things? This would be an expensive endeavour for the government to develop. They aren't great at building usable software or web services as the health insurance site demonstrated. I'd rather they invested time doing what their good at, which is managing policy. Investing time in this instead of simplifying the existing policy is of questionable economic cost. Private industry is more than capable of building software to make filing taxes easier. But there are limitations on their ability to do so if the tax code is so complex. Additionally, simpler software is cheaper than one managing endlessly complex requirements. That's win-win as far as I'm concerned.
- jonathankoren 11y agoWhile it's not solve the problem close to your heart, preventing monopolies and encouraging open access and competition is undoubtly good thing.
- Alupis 11y ago> preventing monopolies and encouraging open access and competition Sadly, this bill doesn't even do any of these things... It's essentially going to have the government make tax preparation software... and we already know they aren't good at making software. As another comment already suggested, private industry is far, far better at software than the government will ever be, and they are already capable of making simpler software - but the current incredibly complex tax code doesn't allow it. The software has to be complicated because it's dealing with a complicated tax code. But, anyone who's used TurboTax or HR Block et al, recently will attest to the simplicity of these programs already. Sure, it takes a long while to complete everything, but the most difficult part is gathering your affairs before sitting down. You essentially type data into the boxes the software tells you to. I recon no human being is capable of hand-filing taxes these days -- even the professional tax filing services are using this (and similar) software! The only way to make it less of a hassle, is to simplify the tax code.