8 ms·
The way student loans were before... No. Tuition went up to compensate for the removal of state subsidizing tuition. Almost 1:1. In fact, with the removal of
by specialist 11y ago
The way student loans were before...
No.
Tuition went up to compensate for the removal of state subsidizing tuition. Almost 1:1. In fact, with the removal of state support, we're merely seeing the true costs of school for the first time.
Loans got nutty because of unnecessary privatization and deregulation. But rent seeking, so it was inevitable, right?
Once tuitions were nutty, parents demanded value for their dollar, begatting grade inflation and transmuting dorms into resort hotels, fueling continued rising costs.
Source: Worked in higher ed. This is common knowledge.
(I don't know enough to explain the textbook racket. Collusion?)
--
mortgage interest deductions have a similarly terrible effect on housing...
No.
Scarcity caused by NIMBY land use policy is driving up housing costs. The fix is aggressive upzoning.
Source: Help friends who work on affordable housing policy. This is common knowledge.
--
In conclusion, yes, simplistic Freedom Markets (tm) explanations are seductive. But they're also mostly wrong. Tuition and loans went bonkers when government pulled out of the business, allowing the predators to take over.
- hardcandy 11y agoYou're missing the forest for the trees. What are ''the true costs of school''? Someone who loves to teach sitting in a classroom teaching. It can be dirt cheap or it can be very expensive. Supply and demand sorts out the details. As more money flowed into the system, administration bloated and became its own entrenched interest group, with very little connection to actual education.[1] Does the UC system need 500 administrators making >$500k year each?[2] As it stands, college for most of my friends was a 4 year social safari interrupted by infrequent periods of intense cramming in between high school and joining the work force. Do you think the average 18-21 year old at a state school is a scholar passionately indulging their love of learning? Almost all education is self education at the end of the day. As soon as we solve for the credentialing/pedigree/signaling problem, online education will destroy a huge amount of offline education and rightly so. As for the mortgage interest deduction, how wouldn't it boost housing prices? It effectively lowers the mortage rate by your marginal tax bracket which is close to 50% in California. So instead of a 3.5% 30 year rate I'm now below 2%. Cheaper money stimulates borrowing. It doesn't matter how low NIMBYism pushes supply in the face of overwhelming demand, each individual still has a maximum price they can pay, and subsidized interest rates raise that price point. [1] http://reclaimuc.blogspot.com/2011/09/senior-administrators-now-officially.html http://reclaimuc.blogspot.com/2011/09/senior-administrators-... [2] http://www.latimes.com/local/education/la-me-uc-spending-20151011-story.html http://www.latimes.com/local/education/la-me-uc-spending-201...
- derefr 11y ago> As it stands, college for most of my friends was a 4 year social safari And that's what costs money, insofar as it raises people's social class and gives them connections. Learning is a trivial cost in comparison, and can be ignored in the calculation; it's something you effectively get "for free" with the price of admission to the social-class-higher-than-yours practicum that is university. Note that community colleges, which have just as much "learning" but no potential for class-raising, don't have spiralling costs. Community college costs what learning costs.
- GauntletWizard 11y agoAnd yet, despite more and more people getting an education, class stratification getting worse in one of the common talking points. How do you explain that?
- derefr 11y agoThe people who are now "getting a [university] education" who previously weren't, are people already in the social upper-middle class, going to upper-middle class universities where they just end up enculturating further to the class they're already in. People in the upper-middle class will only experience social-class mobility by going to an upper-class university (e.g. one of the Ivies, and even then only certain programs that haven't already been flooded by other upper-middle class entrants.) Meanwhile, very few people in the lower-middle class go to university; they "get an education" by going to a trade-school or to community college, thus also avoiding enculturation. And people truly in the lower class (e.g. immigrant agricultural workers) don't even consider higher education to be an option, despite government student loan programs being aimed at them (with the explicit goal of enculturation!) more than anyone else. Generally, though, mobility between any two classes becomes more difficult as the size-ratio between the source and destination class increases, because every place an individual could go to attempt to immerse themselves in the destination class, is already full of other people of the source class attempting the same thing. The previous mobility from lower-middle to upper-middle class has created a bulging upper-middle, which has killed the ability for people to become upper class. (Though it's easier than ever to enculturate to the upper-middle class, this being basically what happens by default when anyone with a lower-middle-class background finds themselves spending a lot of time on the internet—the internet [outside of own-class-reflecting echo chambers like Facebook] being a universally-accessible upper-middle-class microcosm.)
- readams 11y agoWhat about private tuition? Also, every other source, other than your common sense, seems to find the opposite of what you think. https://fee.org/articles/student-loan-subsidies-cause-almost-all-of-the-increase-in-tuition/ https://fee.org/articles/student-loan-subsidies-cause-almost... http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2015/05/the-real-cost-of-college/393086/ http://www.theatlantic.com/education/archive/2015/05/the-rea... http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2015/08/03/increased-tuition-subsidies-increase-the-price-of-college-tuition/#539b4a182b88 http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2015/08/03/increased... I agree that land use decisions are also an important contributor to the problems in the mortgage market, especially in places like the peninsula. But without federal loan support, the market could not have reached the heights that is has since ultimately people can only afford to pay so much per month. If interest rates are much lower, then you can afford a higher principle amount for the same monthly payment. In a housing market with shortages, this allows prices to be bid higher. But of course those land use policies are also exactly the kind of first-order thinking about government policy that I decried in my post above.
- specialist 11y agore The Real Cost of College Scanned article, will parse it later. From the hip: Direct != indirect subsidizes and shouldn't be conflated. Direct subsidizes lowers the retail cost. Outsiders need to understand that, just like business, higher ed has been reducing costs aggressively. Most faculty and staff have been taking it in the teeth. Meanwhile, admins and coaches and select faculty have been getting outsized compensation. No different than any where else. Edit: If I had to guess, tuition at private institutions went up because it could. Charge what the market will bear. Maintain appearance of a premium quality product. Differentiate oneself from the plebes. Edit 2: Chewed on the other two articles. Tim Worstall confuses cause and effect. Both he and Alex Tabarrok ignore that tuition costs were just fine before state subsidies (to the institutions) were removed. Drives me nuts. Further, why the American-centric exceptionalism? There are plenty of other nations with a variety of systems. A god-given natural experiment. So we can compare and contrast. Why are their costs and outcomes ignored? If interest rates are much lower... Changing access and cost of capital won't free up land to be redeveloped, therefore increasing supply.
- lfjmfkekdk 11y agoYour post is economically illiterate and no economist in their right mind would claim that school tuition spike is the result of privatization and deregulation. Car loans are privatized too. That didn't drive up the prices for cars because the "predators" control the industry. In fact, economists show that government backed loans have driven up tuition prices[1] [1] http://www.nber.org/chapters/c13711.pdf http://www.nber.org/chapters/c13711.pdf "As column 4 demonstrates, the demand shocks- which consist mostly of changes in nancial aid-account for the lion's share of the higher tuition. Specifically, with demand shocks alone, equilibrium tuition rises by 102%, almost fully matching the 106% from the benchmark. By contrast, with all factors present except the demand shocks (column 7), net tuition only rises by 16%."
- ohnomrbill 11y ago"mortgage interest deductions have a similarly terrible effect on housing... No. Scarcity caused by NIMBY land use policy is driving up housing costs. The fix is aggressive upzoning. Source: Help friends who work on affordable housing policy. This is common knowledge." Genuine question - do you mean for this to apply to municipalities that are not San Fransisco? While downtowns are getting more dense across the U.S., not every city is quite so opposed to new construction. San Fransisco is a weird corner-case in terms of housing.
- specialist 11y agoCA State Legislature thought the problem common enough to make a comprehensive report. Seattle and Vancouver BC are similarly afflicted. I just read an opinion piece, which now I can't find (grrr), that argued the land-use issue needs to be solved at the state level. Their tweak to the law, which I guess is common, is to permit multi-family redevelopment every where, thereby letting the (re)developers (and the fabled market) decide. If I find the article, I'll update this comment. As for me, I'm content with everyone properly identifying cause and effect, then acting accordingly. I don't care if SF or Seattle fixes their messes. Because if it gets too bad, people and companies will go somewhere else. So ultimately its a self-correcting problem. Alas, the lag in adjustment is painful. For instance, finding suitable housing for so many homeless. Well, okay, I guess I'm conflicted. I know I'll be fine. I have options. But for those less fortunate, ya, aggressive upzoning everywhere as needed, so should be fast tracked.
- marcoperaza 11y agoInteresting that you want blame everything except the actual major source of expanding costs at colleges: an explosion in the number of administrators and administrative departments. Rising tuition is being spent on bringing more and more aspects of students' lives under the control of college administrators. Scandalously, almost none of the new money has gone to hiring more professors. Something is rotten in the state of higher education and it's the bureaucrats running the colleges, set free from financial reality by heavily-subsidized student loans.
- teacup50 11y ago> Scarcity caused by NIMBY land use policy is driving up housing costs. The fix is aggressive upzoning. > Source: Help friends who work on affordable housing policy. This is common knowledge. Affordable housing policy advocates are not an unbiased source for this "common knowledge". There are piles of cash to be made in affordable housing, in the form of outright grants, tax credits, zoning variances, etc, all in exchange for the creation of a small percentage of permanent rental units that the developer will turn a profit on, indefinitely. Any loss is mitigated by increasing the price of non-affordable units. This incentivizes government-backed arbitrage opportunities, e.g., by allowing developers to buy land for a lower price based on current zoning, and then (in partnership with the local housing authority) appeal to local planning authorities for variances. This unsurprisingly a revolving door between government housing entities, local planning boards, development companies, affordable housing tax credit brokerages, and the lobbyists for the above. Here, for example, the local housing authority is trying to push through a high-density upzoning variance, for a project represented by a former housing authority executive, financially backed by an out-of-state firm specializing in tax credit financing that is one of the primary lobbyists against tax credit reforms that would eliminate their value extracting brokerage position in Missouri: http://www.stltoday.com/business/local/is-missouri-s-costly-housing-tax-credit-untouchable-because-of/article_0e46846e-fa2a-55aa-ad07-7409cc0a64d6.html http://www.stltoday.com/business/local/is-missouri-s-costly-... Upzoning in high-demand areas increases land value. Period. This raises market entrance costs to a level in which only large development companies can build. They build rental units. The government provides them grants and variances that private home buyers could only dream of. Housing becomes less affordable, not more, and fewer people are able to build up equity.
- specialist 11y agoNo contest. I've met my share of wishful thinkers still pushing for set asides and subsidies. And we also have our share of cheaters. The irony is when those well intentioned set asides get perverted for profit. But I like to think we're seeing a sea change on the topic. Better data. Broad coalitions. Commitment to finding win/win solutions. Let's check back together in two years. See if my optimism was rewarded.
- jordanb 11y agoYeah I'd also add that the mortgage system has been in existence since the New Deal and housing prices across America tracked inflation until recently. With both education and housing there's a fear of missing out involved, where people see the door to the traditional definition of middle class America slamming shut. So demand ends up being incredibly inelastic because if you don't get in now you're Literally Fucked Forever. When my boomer parents where young you went to college if you wanted to be an academic or a professional, and if you didn't you'd get a job and buy a reasonably-priced house with a 15 year mortgage in one of the thousands of economically successful towns that dotted this country.
- quickpost 11y agoSo what do you think is the solution to bringing prices back down to reasonable amounts?
- ovi256 11y agoDoesn't matter, the objective of bringing prices back down is politically untenable in most developed countries, so the means to accomplish it are never discussed. If it happens by market crash, well, it's another matter. This requires no planned political action, just continuation of status quo.
- Ericson2314 11y agoSimilar skepticism of the "Freedom Markets (tm)" (Can I license your trademark :)). That said, can't one make the argument that the government providing lots of financing without adequately using the leverage that financing gave to bargain down prices distorted things?
- specialist 11y agoBelated response. US Govt forfeited their leverage. They made two big changes. First, they subsidized higher ed, tuition was set mostly by fiat. Second, they stopped handling student loans, allowed banks to raise interest rates, excluded student loans from bankruptcy, moving all the risks of lending onto the borrower. Said another way, we used to treat education as a public good and mostly paid for it. Now its a racket for Wall St to bind students in usury. There are so many other examples in our society. Privatizing prisons. The school to prison pipeline. Privatizing water. War profiteering. It's just goofball Reaganomics run amok, aka Freedom Markets (tm).
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> Source: Worked in higher ed. This is common knowledge. > Source: Help friends who work on affordable housing policy. This is common knowledge. You might be surprised how much of what's common knowledge isn't even vaguely related to the truth.
- Shivetya 11y agoThe tuition rise is no where even closely explained by states providing less funding. the simplest explanation is that the near freedom of money allows many unqualified people to enter college with no hope of completing the courses and colleges are not held to any standard with regards to them actually getting the degree. The simplest solution. Treat it like the government treats medicade and medicare. Pay a set amount of dollars per course hour determined by course. Higher rates are set based on the needs of the course and degree, meaning you are likely to have an easier time getting a loan to be a teacher than if you wanted to study art. Set maximum costs on course materials as well. I am quite certain a very large number of colleges would come up with degree programs to fit under the rules to continue to be able to accept students with federal loans.