6 ms·
Although not the OP, I have a fairly strong opinion on this. In order of importance everyone should * Make their own decisions on what to eat. * Understand th
by kristopolous 11y ago
Although not the OP, I have a fairly strong opinion on this. In order of importance everyone should
* Make their own decisions on what to eat.
* Understand the externalities, exogenous, and endogenous process and consequences of their decisions.
* Take full personal, civic, and environmental responsibility for those decisions.
Essentially, as long as people are forthright, honest, and accountable about what they eat, where it comes from, and the ecological footprints their choices implicate, then have at it, eat whatever.
- Retric 11y agoI don't care if people understand the externalities as much as I want them to pay for the externalities.
- Falling3 11y agoIs this really how you feel taken to its logical extremes? Do you think humans should be allowed to eat other humans? Other live humans? Eating is clearly a very personal thing, but it's silly to pretend that morality suddenly ceases applying.
- whitegrape 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donner_Party https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donner_Party These people were not evil. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Butt_Naked https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Butt_Naked probably is evil but at least he's trying to repent. If we're going to try to come up with a system, mine is simply (borrowed[1]): I like beef and broccoli, mind your business. I readily admit this doesn't cover every corner case, but I don't think there can be a satisfactory system that does. Many things have to be determined by context and taste, and usually aren't even worth thinking about if you're not in a position of power and responsibility over the lives of others. [1] http://genius.com/Immortal-technique-beef-and-broccoli-lyrics http://genius.com/Immortal-technique-beef-and-broccoli-lyric...
- kristopolous 11y agoThe third one, "full personal, civic, and environmental responsibility for those decisions" would include criminal charges and jail-time for the decision to eat a human as it would constitute murder. If someone said "I'm comfortable with the legal consequences of cannibalism and murder along with the possibility that the person may actually kill me before I get to them" and they actually are held to those postulations, including say, life-imprisonment AND they still want to do it all just so they can eat human for supper, then sure, go for it!
- Falling3 11y agoIn that case, your first and third statements certainly seem in conflict. You don't actually believe in any practical sense that people should be able to make their own (unhindered) decision on what to eat if you're going to punish them for it and prevent them from doing it again.
- kristopolous 11y agoIt's about understanding the costs of the decisions and accepting them. If you say "Well nobody would be ok with industrial slaughterhouses or a number of other things" I say, "yes, that's kinda the point here."
- Falling3 11y agoWhy would we care if someone accepts the costs or not? I find our justice system to be incredibly flawed, but ultimately we jail people because we (as a society) don't want the action they committed to take place. The mentality you seem to be espousing seems to ignore that for... reasons? So if we're willing to say a specific action is worth jailing someone for the rest of their life, why shouldn't we say "This action is not okay and we're going to do our best to prevent it"?
- kristopolous 11y agoThis is a philosophical difference. I think adults should be at liberty to shoot themselves in the foot.
- brahmwg 11y agoWhat about meat grown in a lab, so no being had to die for it. ...what about human meat grown in a lab...?
- indlebe 11y agoas someone who considers themselves an animal-rights moderate, I am 100% OK with lab meat. No sentient beings suffering = no problem!
- EliRivers 11y agoThat will happen. There will be two aspects to it. Firstly, the wealthy (and then the middle classes) will have meat prepared that is genetically identical to themselves, and will serve it to dinner guests. Secondly, one will be able to buy celebrity meat at the supermarket. The future equivalent of a Tom Cruise burger, or a Scarlett Johansson steak.
- btilly 11y agoWhat if it is the actual wish of the people involved? What if a person whose fantasy was to kill and cook another person met a person who fantasy was to be killed and cooked? Then this happened. What penalty should ensue for the (well-fed) survivor? And lest you think this is some weird hypothetical, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armin_Meiwes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armin_Meiwes may enlighten you otherwise.
- chris_wot 11y agoIn this case it's a mental disorder or illness and I'd consider it manslaughter.
- dorfsmay 11y agoSo eating human is OK? Killing humans in order to eat them is OK? What some people are asking is if we should extend this to some other species, typically other apes (which share 90% of our genes etc...) and now animals with high intelligence (elephant, dolphin, octopus).
- kristopolous 11y agoOur society has decided that there are a number of drastic consequences for cannibalism and murder. If someone honestly was ok with all of them including things like telling the persons' family and spending their life in jail for the cost of a meal, then that's fine. Note that my conditions make people on the hook for everything - the treatment of the workers that prepared the food, the environmental impact of delivering it, the treatment of the animals constituting the food, the health effects of choosing what to eat ... all of that.
- pyre 11y ago> If someone honestly was ok with all of them for the cost of a human feast, then that's fine. Would you sing the same tune if you were the one that they wanted to eat?
- kristopolous 11y agoI would be violently opposed to it of course. As I hypothesize is every other animal to their own demise. Maybe there's a moral necessity to veganism.
- Falling3 11y agoIn what sense is it okay? What does "okay" mean? Responding to an action with a life prison sentence doesn't scream "okay".
- kristopolous 11y agoClearly. The point is nobody would do that. I think that if someone was forced to have a pet pig for a while they'd probably stop eating pork or if they were forced to be a single mother living on minimum wage they'd probably fight on behalf of fast food workers. My supposition is that people shouldn't voluntarily shroud themselves in ignorance for culinary delight but instead, should take full responsibility for all of their actions, at the dinner table and in all aspects of life.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tedks 11y agoI'm sorry, but this >* Make their own decisions on what to eat. is totally unacceptable when you're "making a decision" to enslave, torture, murder, and consume a sentient, feeling creature.
- JadeNB 11y agoI am not trying to be snarky, and honestly don't know what you mean. Does "In order of importance" mean "from most to least important", or "from least to most important"? (Probably it's just my deficiency; I am so used to seeing 'increasing' or 'decreasing' that I don't know which one is implicitly meant.)