3 ms·
I find that many discussions of AI suffer from a basic confusion of intelligence with the more general notion of computation, which results in a severe overesti
by pron 11y ago
I find that many discussions of AI suffer from a basic confusion of intelligence with the more general notion of computation, which results in a severe overestimation of the power of intelligence and underestimation of the power of non-intelligent computation. General intelligence -- at least as we currently understand it to be -- is no more than a particular algorithm or a class of algorithms, and therefore:
1. Overestimation of intelligence: Computational complexity theory -- in particular the time/space hierarchy theorems, which, IMO, are the most important theorems in all of computer science (and are basically generalizations of the halting theorem) -- tells us that problems form an infinite hierarchy of difficulty, and that some problems require a certain amount of computational resources regardless of the algorithm used. In particular, we know of plenty of very important problems (e.g. NP-complete, or PSPACE-complete) for which intelligence does not seem to help at all, and those problems are faced in many real-world scenarios. Worse, we know that for many of these problems, there can be no efficient approximate solution employing any algorithm. Artificial intelligence, therefore, cannot possibly form an effective way to solve these very real problems.
2. Underestimation of non-intelligent computation: It is unclear that the "general intelligence algorithms" are the best use of computational resources. Humans (and mammals) are far from being the most successful species on Earth by almost any measure of success (we are neither the most plentiful numerically, in biomass, or even in the most capable of shaping the planet). It is therefore a mistake to believe that the "intelligence algorithms" pose either the most severe threat or the most powerful "problem solving" approach.
Artificial intelligence seems to be particularly useful when interacting with other intelligent beings (i.e. humans). For example, there has recently been some success in employing an "intelligent" algorithm for winning the game of Go. However, it is known that the "Go problem" is EXPTIME-complete, and therefore the intelligent algorithm can only be successful when playing against other players who employ a similar algorithm (namely, humans). It is by no means a general solution to the "Go problem". As "disease" is not a human problem, and pathogens employ computation in a very different way than intelligent beings, it is hard to believe that AI would be able to eradicate disease etc., etc..