2 ms·
"Global cooling"/"Global dimming" (small particulates suspended in the upper atmosphere) and an increase in pollution etc. has messed with them [tree rings].
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
"Global cooling"/"Global dimming" (small particulates suspended in the upper atmosphere) and an increase in pollution etc. has messed with them [tree rings].
Actually, we don't know what factor messed up tree rings. If we knew that tree rings were f(warmth, x), we would simply keep tree ring data for the entire calibration period and include x in the calculations. The fact is, factor x might apply in the past. We simply don't know.
I'm curious though; if you are skeptical of our knowledge of past temperatures, how can you not be skeptical of predictions of future temperatures? All the climate models are calibrated to past temperature records, so how can the models give good results if the past records are bad?
A hypothetical: I come to you with a proposed algorithmic trading strategy which I've validated it against historical data. But oops I'm not that great at keeping records, and I actually threw away the market data. I also emailed my employees and told them to delete the data if the SEC ever came asking for it. And I also ignored some historical periods where the numbers didn't work. But I kept some stock charts showing exponential growth!
So, you want to invest in my fund?
- Retric 17y agoI don't trust any complex trading strategy period. On the other hand I am perfectly willing to believe that we can make ITER work to design specifications. And we could scale up the same basic design to a working fusion reactor. The difference is extrapolating to never before seen physical reactions is reasonable, while human psychology is not. As to temperature predictions IMO it's more of the same, I don't trust that we can build a highly accurate forcast of global temperature, but estimating temperature change with a +/- 50% accuracy seems vary reasonable. PS: It's not like we are missing the past 30 years of highly accurate temperature measurements as we have continued to dump mind bogglingly huge quantities of CO2 into the air. IMO, predicting 50 years into the future vs 200 years in the past involves far more unknowns, but extrapolating 1,000 years into the past even worse.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]