6 ms·
So for me the question is why there are still people that enjoy working as if their computers are using a 25 year old developer experience. The GUI paradigm is
by tambourine_man 11y ago
So for me the question is why there are still people that enjoy working as if their computers are using a 25 year old developer experience.
The GUI paradigm is over 30 years old. People still stick to the mouse even though we've had ubiquitous touchscreens for almost a decade.
A good paradigm does not easily die.
- joesmo 11y agoTouch screens are even less efficient and ergonomic than mice which are pretty terrible at both those things. Track balls and pads are only a tiny improvement. All of these input methods are deeply flawed but there are no real alternatives that I know of. There's plenty of us that would move to better, more efficient, more ergonomic input methods were they available.
- illumin8 11y agoI use a magic trackpad and find it very good at giving me the best features of a mouse/pointer interface and a touch interface combined. You can do things like two-finger scroll in any document and 3 finger swipe between desktops minority report style... All kidding aside, it seems very productive, but I still keep a mouse plugged in just in case I need to run Visio inside a Windows 10 VM to do some diagraming... Mouse is much more precise and less fatiguing to use for serious diagramming...
- coldtea 11y ago>The GUI paradigm is over 30 years old. People still stick to the mouse even though we've had ubiquitous touchscreens for almost a decade. Touch screens are not a 100% replacement for mice. They are an alternative, and for desktop/laptop PCs with vertical screens they are a non starter due to human physiology.
- cicero 11y agoMice are not a 100% replacement for keyboards. If you're doing lots of typing, there is something to be said for keeping your hands on the keyboard. Vim and emacs facilitate this much better than GUI-based editors.
- coldtea 11y ago>Mice are not a 100% replacement for keyboards. And they're not used as such. They are used as complimentary to keyboards. On the other hand, mice-based GUIs ARE a 100% replacement for CLIs.
- ubertaco 11y ago>On the other hand, mice-based GUIs ARE a 100% replacement for CLIs. Really? I can automate a pipeline of GUIs? Please show me how I can automatically query a database, take that output, run complex data aggregation over those results combined with past results, send that to a remote server for storage, and email myself the result of the upload, using only a combination of GUIs. (Points deducted for anything that involves instructing the machine to "move mouse to position (x,y)", since screen sizes may vary and where an individual GUI chooses to pop open a dialog/modal may also vary)
- adrianN 11y agoAppleScript can do pretty complex GUI automation tasks.
- ultramancool 11y agoYeah, so can AutoIT or python with pywinauto... you could do it. It just wouldn't be pleasant. Might do it if you had to extract data from some proprietary GUI tool you couldn't tear open.
- Zardoz84 11y agoWindows 3.1 had a macro recorder that allow to automate task over a GUI.
- zeveb 11y agoI think he was saying that a mouse-based GUI can display a terminal window in which one can run a CLI; thus a GUI is a strict superset of a CLI. That's true enough, although honestly I'm at a point in my computing where the G part of the GUI is pretty limited: my windows are all full-screen; the only clicking I regularly do is on links and tabs, and sometimes text (honestly, I'm trying to use the keyboard more for that though); almost all of my command execution is keyboard-driven (there's a reason man developed language rather than pointing and grunting).
- andrepd 11y agoAs if touchscreens were a replacement for mice. Mice input is more precise than touchscreens and suited for different tasks.
- andrepd 11y agoAs if touchscreens were a replacement for mice. Mice input is more precise than touchscreens and suited for different tasks.