2 ms·
I am not convinced by The Guardian's methodology. Their criterion for an abusive comment is that it was moderated. That's fine and dandy, but then they go and m
by YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago
I am not convinced by The Guardian's methodology. Their criterion for an abusive
comment is that it was moderated. That's fine and dandy, but then they go and
make the assumption that if:
a) a comment was abusive
b) AND it was posted under a given article
c) THEN it was abusive towards the author of the article
Based on this assumption they find a correlation with articles being written by
women and minorities, and high rates of abuse (a.k.a. moderated comments). The
assumption is a very big one to make. People in comments may just be
hurling abuse at each other. They might be trolling each other rather than the
author of the article, so their abuse may have nothing to do with the sex or
minority status of the author.
Did they check that this is not the case? They report that they did check that
the correlation was, to their opinion, statistically significant [1] but they don't
give any details of their test for this.
In general, it's true that The Guardian has a big problem with comments.
Eyballing it, most of their comments are dross that doesn't contribute anything
to any conversation, even if they're not abusive. They need to attract a better
class of commenter. They'd do well to take a page out of HN's book and implement
a self-moderation system.
Also, allowing editing of comments for a brief period might help improve their quality. Sometimes people might regret pressing "post" but have no way to retract their own comment.
[1] https://discussion.theguardian.com/comment-permalink/72218686 https://discussion.theguardian.com/comment-permalink/7221868...