3 ms·
Let's see if I understand this correctly. Scientist A finds fault with the majority view on a certain issue. So he publishes a book for popular consumption tha
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Let's see if I understand this correctly.
Scientist A finds fault with the majority view on a certain issue. So he publishes a book for popular consumption that takes to task various points of the majority's opinion. In response, some other scientist writes a book that takes to task Scientist A. Scientist A writes a rebuttal to the critique.
Newsweek comes along, cherry-picks a couple of arguments, resolves them by appeal to authority, doesn't look at the rebuttal, and seems to conclude that Scientist A is a shoddy charlatan unworthy of our trust.
As I understand this discussion, there are a bout five hoops we need to jump through from positing a theory (Earth's climate is changing) to advocating action (We must do something). I won't list them all here -- they're all just common sense. Attack along any of these lines is fair game and should be encouraged -- especially with such a serious topic.
Instead of impeaching the scientist and basically trying to impugn any work he does in the future, why not list each claim, critique, and rebuttal? Heck, you could do it in chart format with sources. Then we could be talking ideas instead of generalizations and personalities.
I'd much rather have the scientific discussion than the political one. Lumborg may abuse puppies when he goes home from work, but his ideas deserve our attention because bad ideas can come from good people and good ideas can come from bad people We're all grown-ups: show us the claims, counter-claims and citations and we can have a much higher-quality conversation.
- Tichy 17y ago"Instead of impeaching the scientist and basically trying to impugn any work he does in the future, why not list each claim, critique, and rebuttal?" Problem is, we still wouldn't be any wiser - how would we know whether to trust the claim, the critique, or the rebuttal? And wouldn't it be more fair to also allow a rebuttal to the rebuttal? Why should Lumborg have the last word?