4 ms·
I'd give money to a VPS, or what have you, that had a stated policy along the lines of, "here is a recovery key, here is the 2FA setup, here's how you recover y
by mikestew 11y ago
I'd give money to a VPS, or what have you, that had a stated policy along the lines of, "here is a recovery key, here is the 2FA setup, here's how you recover your password with those items if you forget. If you call about account recovery and you do not have $REQUIRED_ITEMS, our service reps have been instructed to hang up on you. If you lose access to your account without $REQUIRED_ITEMS, you have lost access to your account permanently because we have set procedures from which we do not, under any circumstances, deviate. With a name like Ft. Knox VPS, our customers value the security of their accounts. As security is our priority, we have chosen to trade convenience and possible loss of data for the elimination of a large threat surface. If you regularly lose your car keys, don't use a password manager, or get angry when companies won't just email you your password instead of making you reset it, we're probably not the right choice for your VPS needs."
- matheweis 11y agoI don't know... Apple did this for a while, and it backfired on them. The average user (even technically savvy user) simply wasn't competent enough to understand that they really truly would be locked out forever. From 2014: http://thenextweb.com/apple/2014/12/08/lost-apple-id-learnt-hard-way-careful-two-factor-authentication/ http://thenextweb.com/apple/2014/12/08/lost-apple-id-learnt-... They no longer do this: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204921 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT204921
- mikestew 11y agoI by no means intend such a system be sold to average consumers. As you point out, it would be doomed to failure. More for the hard-core "I'd rather lose my customer DB than watch it walk off in the hands of someone with a good sob story" crowd. And I'm not 100% sure that there is large enough, bold enough type to forestall some customer saying, "but I didn't think you meant it!"
- PhantomGremlin 11y agowe have set procedures from which we do not, under any circumstances, deviate Fair enough. There's a subset of people who want that and would agree to that beforehand. But, and here's an important "but", do not just display a checkbox and an Agree button. Instead display a sentence something like this: I UNDERSTAND THAT I WILL PERMANENTLY LOSE ALL ACCESS IF I FORGET MY PASSWORD AND MY RECOVERY KEY In order to agree to the terms, make the customer type out: I UNDERSTAND THAT I WILL PERMANENTLY LOSE ALL ACCESS IF I FORGET MY PASSWORD AND MY RECOVERY KEY BTW, don't allow "paste" into the reply field, try to enforce actual typing of characters. After you've done that, if a customer is later locked out, that customer will STILL be mad at you. It will be the providers fault that the customer can't get access. No matter how explicitly the customer agreed to the terms. That's human nature. I don't care how explicit you make it, you simply can't win this one.