4 ms·
I'm not downvoting you because I think you make some good points, however, I completely disagree with your characterization of safe harbor. Safe harbor rules a
by mbreese 17y ago
I'm not downvoting you because I think you make some good points, however, I completely disagree with your characterization of safe harbor.
Safe harbor rules are what makes the internet of today work.
Today, content isn't just generated from large, powerful, corporations... it's generated from us. For example, Hacker News is protected from any liability this comment might have due to safe harbor rules. It's the reason YouTube can exist. It's the reason why blogging services can exist. It's the reason Twitter can exist (you can still argue whether or not it should though... ). The point of safe harbor is to assign the liability for the content to the creator, not the service that publishes it. The company that serves the content is only liable after they've been notified. This is critical for today's internet.
Any company that allows users to post content (messages, comments, videos, anything) must have safe harbor protections to operate. If they didn't, then they would be responsible for any liability for everything, so they'd have to moderate every single comment, every single video, etc... Basically, this would shut down the user-supplied content that rules the modern internet. What we'd be left with is a computerized version of the one-way communications of old-media.
That would be a bad thing.
Also, you're unnecessarily extending safe harbor protections to where they don't exist. For example, Google Maps and privacy. This is Google's content. They created it. They published it. And they are absolutely responsible for making sure that they are compliant with any privacy regulations. This doesn't fall under safe harbor at all.
Sure companies make mistakes with privacy, your example of Google Buzz is a good one. However, don't confuse these issues with safe harbor. In this specific case in Italy, it is safe harbor that is under attack. And that's a bad thing for Italy.
- loup-vaillant 17y agoYou sound like we need YouTube to publish videos or that we need Blogger to publish a blog. We don't. Well we do, but only because we have asymmetric bandwidth, and no low-power, easy[1] to set up home server. The second we have that is the second these platforms become obsolete. For many reasons, I would very much like that. About aggregation sites like Hacker News, you do have a strong point, though. [1] I mean as easy as Facebook, Blogger, YouTube, Twitter… Any harder and it won't work.
- mbreese 17y agoWe don't. Well we do I agree... :) it would be nice for all of us to be able to "publish" ourselves... but for the most part, even if we did have better low-power home servers and enough bandwidth to serve the content, most people won't be able / willing to set it up. So, I think in general, the mass-public will be stuck with the Bloggers and YouTubes of the world.
- loup-vaillant 17y agoCan't you imagine a home server which is already set up?
- jonknee 17y agoYou may not need Blogger or YouTube to publish on the internet, but the masses do.
- loup-vaillant 17y agoI know they do. My point is they shouldn't. Give them an already set up server, and they won't.
- gridspy 17y agoYou might be able to distribute the publishing of content into the house, but can you distribute the failsafe hardware? Redundant connections? UPS? When you buy hosting online, you buy more than space on a hard disk.
- loup-vaillant 17y agoWe need things like distributed, encrypted backups for your data, and backup MX to receive your mail. These already exist. What's left to do is the automation of the set up. I don't think most people really need high availability, so UPS and redundant connections sound like overkill. For fail-safe hardware, we just need something "unplug proof". A Beagle Board (with a few GB of Flash and a small battery) is more than enough. I am aware that such a solution will be a little less convenient than storing everything "in the cloud", no matter how easy it can be. But the cloud has its downsides as well: you hardly have any privacy in the cloud, and they can shut everyone down, for any reason.
- Silhouette 17y agoPerhaps I wasn't clear about one important point: while safe harbour schemes are one example of corporations like Google pushing back the frontiers of what is legal, I did not mean to imply that all such moves rely on the safe harbour principle. It is merely one example. Something like the proposed Google Books settlement would be another. A lack of effective privacy laws is a third. As for the difficulty of running things without safe harbour provisions, people are quick to assume that there are no or only limited alternatives, and that without the current scheme we would somehow "kill the Internet", but I challenge that assumption, based on the argument that follows. Firstly, if there's one thing the Internet has managed to do successfully for a long time, it is evolving creative solutions to large scale problems. The Web started as a small network of pages, with only a few carefully chosen links between them. Then we evolved web rings to help people find related content. After that, ever-improving search engines became the dominant way to find material. Today we have link aggregators, status updates/tweets, etc. There is no reason to believe that removing one form of expression would make things worse; on the contrary, if history is anything to go by, it might well catalyse the development of a better replacement. On which note, I think we are going to move towards "Web 3.0" where user-generated content is balanced with editorial control by real people anyway. Web 2.0 was an interesting experiment, but the signal-to-noise ratio is terrible, the volume of information is overwhelming, and the simple, user-supported voting systems of today are widely abused and not really up to the job. Even the poster child, Wikipedia, now has policies that prevent open contributions to certain articles, internal politics among the volunteer editors about what should be allowed, etc. I think the kind of purely automated content hosting sites with unlimited user generated content are already dead, they just don't know it yet. Next is a key point that I imagine some here may disagree with: I have never believed in absolute freedom of speech (of the kind where you can say whatever you like with no responsibility for any consequences). Words are very powerful things, and in the Internet era that power is magnified many times over. I believe that people should be held responsible for something they say that is unreasonably damaging to others, whether it be betraying a confidence, starting a malicious rumour, giving misleading "expert" advice in a field such as health or finance... This is just common decency and courtesy, and indeed almost nowhere has really had freedom of speech in law for many years, because of issues like defamation, national security, court-ordered anonymity for victims of certain crimes, etc. These things have been part of the law in many jurisdictions since long before the Internet. The difference is that on the Internet, there is no such thing as an off-hand comment quickly forgotten. Society needs to adapt to this new reality, appreciating the benefits of giving everyone the power to speak to millions of others, but imposing suitably harsh penalties for those who use that power irresponsibly. I just don't see how that is compatible with broad measures like absolute freedom of speech or complete safe harbour rules for those republishing material to potentially huge numbers of people. Those are merely convenient blanket laws designed for ease of implementation, not because they reflect the ethical thing to do. So I'm not convinced that a law that imposed responsibility and as a side-effect made it difficult to run unlimited user-generated content sites would cause the loss of something truly valuable. If you want to write a dozen spam comments on a blog about how hot Hayden looked on Heroes last night, you are welcome to do it on your own personal web site, where your deeply-considered and original thoughts will no doubt receive the attention they deserve. And if you say something unfair in your next blog post that destroys someone's career, you can look forward to a personal letter telling you when to turn up in court and defend that action or be held accountable. Meanwhile, I don't see the kinds of rules I'm talking about halting the development of the Web, because I think we're going to move toward more editorial control on the big, popular sites for other reasons anyway. And even if you do believe in absolute freedom of speech, you can still publish what you want on your personal web site, you would just have to take personal responsibility for it accordingly instead of hiding semi-anonymously behind some giant organisation who will republish your material but shield you from being identified and thus held responsible for the consequences. I, for one, don't have a problem with that.