4 ms·
While this doesn't sound like a good ruling and will presumably be overturned later, I can't say I'm full of sympathy. There has been an increasing trend in la
by Silhouette 17y ago
While this doesn't sound like a good ruling and will presumably be overturned later, I can't say I'm full of sympathy.
There has been an increasing trend in law to rely on blanket "safe harbour" conditions when it comes to on-line activities. Those conditions act as a get out of jail free card for big organisations, and I'm not sure that is healthy. If you set up a service that can host content provided by others, and that service is successful in large part because it enables people to break some law (copyright, privacy, whatever), why should you get a free pass? What you are doing is not then the same as a post office or phone provider, because you are directly profiting and your business model is based in part on illegal activities.
An extension of this idea is that several powerful corporations, Google among them, have been pushing back the boundaries of the law concerning privacy, personal data protection, intellectual property rights, defamation and so on, as hard as they can. I am quite sure that that is not a healthy trend. Services like Google Groups and Google News are based on leeching the work of others. Google Maps and Google Street View have serious privacy concerns, to the extent that both have been partially blocked in several nations either by law or just by large numbers of people turning out to physically block the camera car from entering their village. Google Video/YouTube established themselves based substantially on blatant copyright infringement. And then you get things like the Buzz fiasco a few days ago.
All of this is done from behind a virtual shield where it is almost impossible for anyone who is damaged by such actions to contact Google about it short of filing a court action. The latter is prohibitively expensive in some jurisdictions, notably including the US, in cases where the damage is not a substantial direct financial cost that a court can award back, which basically means the little guy can't stand up to the mighty corporation even in cases where the corporation's behaviour is clearly unethical and/or illegal.
While I would certainly prefer to have robust laws implemented to protect personal privacy and the like, and to see Google forced to comply with those like anyone else, until that happens I half-welcome just about any non-violent effort to check the Powers That Be and make them reconsider whether some of the things they are trying to achieve are a step too far. Legal shenanigans are a game Google likes, and turnabout is fair play.
- mbreese 17y agoI'm not downvoting you because I think you make some good points, however, I completely disagree with your characterization of safe harbor. Safe harbor rules are what makes the internet of today work. Today, content isn't just generated from large, powerful, corporations... it's generated from us. For example, Hacker News is protected from any liability this comment might have due to safe harbor rules. It's the reason YouTube can exist. It's the reason why blogging services can exist. It's the reason Twitter can exist (you can still argue whether or not it should though... ). The point of safe harbor is to assign the liability for the content to the creator, not the service that publishes it. The company that serves the content is only liable after they've been notified. This is critical for today's internet. Any company that allows users to post content (messages, comments, videos, anything) must have safe harbor protections to operate. If they didn't, then they would be responsible for any liability for everything, so they'd have to moderate every single comment, every single video, etc... Basically, this would shut down the user-supplied content that rules the modern internet. What we'd be left with is a computerized version of the one-way communications of old-media. That would be a bad thing. Also, you're unnecessarily extending safe harbor protections to where they don't exist. For example, Google Maps and privacy. This is Google's content. They created it. They published it. And they are absolutely responsible for making sure that they are compliant with any privacy regulations. This doesn't fall under safe harbor at all. Sure companies make mistakes with privacy, your example of Google Buzz is a good one. However, don't confuse these issues with safe harbor. In this specific case in Italy, it is safe harbor that is under attack. And that's a bad thing for Italy.
- loup-vaillant 17y agoYou sound like we need YouTube to publish videos or that we need Blogger to publish a blog. We don't. Well we do, but only because we have asymmetric bandwidth, and no low-power, easy[1] to set up home server. The second we have that is the second these platforms become obsolete. For many reasons, I would very much like that. About aggregation sites like Hacker News, you do have a strong point, though. [1] I mean as easy as Facebook, Blogger, YouTube, Twitter… Any harder and it won't work.
- 17y ago
- loup-vaillant 17y agoThe problem with YouTube and Blogger is that you don't publish on YouTube or Blogger. Google does. This is especially obvious in Blogger, where they have a link on the top of the page to "flag abuse". They have power over these publications, so assuming they should have equivalent responsibilities is reasonable. If we carry out this reasoning to its ultimate conclusion, platforms like YouTube or Blogger won't last long. It would indeed end the web as we know it. It will not end free speech on the internet, though. Not by a long shot. Free speech can be achieved through two means: the out of jail free card, or a way for people to publish themselves. Self publication is possible: we just need personal web servers, symmetric bandwidth, and the promise that we won't sue any ISP for moving bits (we need that safe harbour). Of course, companies like Google or Facebook prefer the out of jail free card (for many reasons, they prefer your data to be on their servers rather than on your own). I think the people will rather take the self publication route, given the choice.
- Groxx 17y agoAnd what happens when someone tries to search for something on this self-published web? It's gotta be indexed somewhere. Oops! The search provider indexed it, and is serving it out to the world in the form of results. By duplicating your data without reading it, they're responsible. Jail for them. Youtube and Blogger are a miniscule step beyond indexing. They're duplicating data you wrote on your computer, and serving it out to the world. Content hosts cannot logically be responsible for user-submitted content. This leaves two outs: safe harbor, or only commercial content on the internet, so the buck can be passed (note that this is identical to a TOS). Remind me again where free speech fits in there? edit: as I said in another comment: you don't put the papermakers in jail because someone wrote something mean on it.
- loup-vaillant 17y agoYou missed the part about control. If they have the power, they should have the responsibility. And maybe the accountability as well. A publishing platform can choose to be neutral (no power), or it can choose not to be. Of course safe harbour should apply to neutral media. For those that are not, however, I am not so sure. Almost, but not totally. About the paper makers, you missed another point: anonymity. It should be very easy to reach the actual author of a paper, so this makes no sense to sue the paper maker. If the paper maker published all this stuff anonymously, and can't (or refuse to) disclose the author's name, however, that's a different story.