4 ms·
Singapore’s Midlife Crisis
- lordleft 11y agoSingapore is such an impressive city-state, but it always struck me as the political equivalent of that guy we all know, who went to a top school and became a highly performant professional but never subjected himself to a serious self-examination of his ultimate purpose in life. Singapore is a stunningly efficient country, but towards what end? Governments and cities should exist for people, not the other way around. I do still admire Singapore, and very much hope to visit some day. Great article.
- notahacker 11y ago> Governments and cities should exist for people, not the other way around To a large extent I saw Singapore - for better and for worse - as a country whose sense of purpose was entirely focused on existing for and achieving the ends of what its people actually want (to be much wealthier, healthier and more secure than their grandparents) without worrying too much about means like political debate, ideology or caring much about heritage, national identity, environmental impact or whether William Gibson thought it was as edgy and cool as Kowloon Walled City. I'm not sure its depoliticised, pragmatic governors whose tenure is secure unless they really screw up are really less "for the people" than the fiat of newly-elected ruling party du jour whose prize for winning competitive elections is the power to decide for people based whether its core ideology is conservative or socially liberal, or indeed systems where popular will is often subordinate to upholding constitutional principles and precedents established some centuries ago. Of course, just because death sentences for drug smugglers or retaining a token unenforced anti-gay law on the statute book are popular with the people doesn't mean they're remotely good ideas, but I'm not sure that the country examining its collective purpose would change them anyway. Government for somewhat culturally conservative people who have ugly memories of political discord and happy memories of getting a flat with actual running water is bound to take a different stance on what the people want than an competitive democracy in a long-developed country with a long-established libertarian streak.
- tixocloud 11y agoWhat a great and interesting article. It's also refreshing to read that a government advisor believes that the old managerial model is outdated. While the ruling party has maintained dominance for many years, it has also brought stability to the country. Neighbouring countries don't enjoy the stability and progress as much as Singapore has. In terms of citizen happiness, which is better? It's inconclusive. People who have nothing will always want something. And people who have something will want something else.
- jessaustin 11y agoHaving lived in Singapore for several years, I have sympathy, but truly the "problems" described in TFA are entirely those of the "first world". Yes, when a nation becomes wealthier than 99% of other nations, its economy will grow more slowly than it did before. It's fine to encourage growth anyway, but one knows at the outset that returns to such efforts are limited. The demographic concerns, too, would be no surprise to e.g. Europeans or the Japanese. Economies in which all the slots have been filled by previous generations, are not encouraging the current generation to procreate. Older generations are concerned, but not enough to do anything. Ultimately, the voters of Singapore seem content with "the deal". That is, the Lee family has ruled for 37 out of the 50 years that Singapore has existed, and as the most recent elections confirmed that's exactly what the voters want. LHL is an impressive man, but are there really no other Singaporeans capable of serving as PM? If his health fails, it seems likely that his wife or brother would step forward as "regent" while one or two of his sons undergo the careful grooming and seasoning required to differentiate this dynasty from e.g. the Kims of North Korea. Any significant change to Singaporean society will only take place after its voters decide they want a change.
- xbmcuser 11y agoI have been living in Singapore for the last 7 years and the peoples discontent has had some effect in the last few years. They have been increasing the requirements for foreign labour every year for the last few years. Very high property prices resulted in a similar curbs on foreigners buying residential properties etc. So people do have the power to bring change even in Singapore as far as changing the ruling party to some other is not going to happen any time soon.
- jessaustin 11y agoThe changes you mention seem pretty limited in scope. I think that's the only sort of change that can occur in such a late stage of the Lee Dynasty. LHL and his heirs would be negligent if they tried to introduce big changes now to how society or industry is organized. Even if they felt they knew what should happen, they are well-practiced in maintaining the status quo, not undermining it. Singapore will go through one or more "Yeltsins" before a new order that effectively governs in a new way is found.