9 ms·
It's tricky because a lot of customers really DO lock themselves out of a service, and forget their password reset code. Fun story time. I use to play MTGO, t
by brianwawok 11y ago
It's tricky because a lot of customers really DO lock themselves out of a service, and forget their password reset code.
Fun story time. I use to play MTGO, the online Magic the Gathering game. Played it from beta for a few years say 2002-2004. Wanted to check it out in 2014 to see how it changed. Failed password reset online, had to call in to support.
The support guy was like chortle what was your security passcode? I had no idea. He tried giving some hints. I said it has literally been 10 years, I am never going to remember. So he went ahead and rest my password. He told me for the record my security code was "I am the nacho king", but I would be prompted to change it at next login.
So could I have social engineered a 10 year old MTGO account? Yes. But without it, I would have been locked out. I was NOT going to remember some stupid passcode kid me set on a game account.
And apparently I am the nacho King.
- pilom 11y agoThe answer to "I don't know my password and I don't know my security question/answer" is, "Sorry, for security reasons we can't help you access this account, you'll need to create a new account." This isn't a problem for banks, why is it a problem for tech companies?
- bearcobra 11y agoProbably because your bank (generally) has a physical location you can visit and complete some other verification process to unlock your account.
- modoc 11y agoWith a bank you go into a branch, and show them your driver's license/other official ID, and don't lose access to all your money... It's harder online when you don't have the same ability to interact face to face.
- williamscales 11y agoWhen you are locked out of AWS you must sign an affidavit and provide photo ID. Seems similar to me.
- enraged_camel 11y agoAmazon has the resources to go through intensive identity verification processes. And so do banks. Most tech companies (especially startups) don't.
- nrb 11y agoDoesn't this sound like something a startup can come in and alleviate? Anyone have any recommendations for identity verification as a service?
- DasIch 11y agoThere are at least two such services in Germany WebID[1] and PostID[1] (not to be confused with the older PostIdent that requires identification at a post office). I haven't used PostID yet but with WebID you basically have a Skype video call where you show them your ID. [1]: https://www.webid-solutions.de/en/ https://www.webid-solutions.de/en/ [2]: https://www.deutschepost.de/de/p/postid.html https://www.deutschepost.de/de/p/postid.html
- bostik 11y agoOh, there's nothing new about that. Startups have identified and entered the space long ago, and the survivors have grown. So KYC as a service is certainly a thing, and I know of two: Tracesmart & Onfido.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoI have a few bank accounts with banks that don't have branches. To "verify" your Id they ask you questions from your credit report - which can be problematic. "What was the payment and term on a loan you had 5 years ago?" Fuck if I ever knew what the payment or term was, I didn't care when I took out the loan, I had my own payment schedule (I think if you can't pay back a loan [with the exception of a mortgage] in a year or two you really can't afford the loan...). Some of the stuff I just plain can't remember! The best was when they asked me which model of car I had owned... and listed two cars that I had owned... I could only select one. These records can be flat out wrong too. The DMV associates a car with my address that I don't own, for example. I think this happened because the owner never changed their address with the DMV. Or someone could have just fat fingered something which gets populated to other databases with data sharing.
- raverbashing 11y agoWell you can go to the bank with your ID if everything else fails Of course that might not be even necessary as there have been reports of people withdrawing money or wiring it somewhere with not even that (but the bank has legal responsibility)
- intrasight 11y agoI agree. With banks, if you need to prove identity remotely, you need to get a medallion signature and a notary. Takes time and money. I assume that web businesses would be happy to have to do that in return for robust security not easily broke via social engineering. I think it would even be a competitive advantage. If you want cheap and easy (and insecure) then you can use a competitors offering.
- brianwawok 11y agoWith MTGO above I had maybe $500 in virtual stuff on my account. As the gatekeeper I'm not sure that would go over well. With servers a similar thing. Say my only copy of a database is on my VPS. May have a business value of $50k. Can't really just say no unconditionally. Need some process to unlock..
- dspillett 11y ago> This isn't a problem for banks, why is it a problem for tech companies? Banks have the option of you physically going into the branch and identifying yourself with relevant legally backed forms of ID. That would not really work for most online companies. Other methods which involve sending in copies of ID and/or letters signed by appropriate notaries would fail due to human engineering too because your average tech company isn't going to have people sat ready who are capable of accurately verifying this information. The other problem is PR: due to the lack of another option the average person who is locked out of their account will instantly turn to twitter/facebook/any-where-else-they-can-post and scream as loud as they can that they've been mistreated by company X. Many other average persons will take this at face value without checking the fats and start avoiding company X, or worse bombarding them with communication in support of the inconvenienced user.
- hrktb 11y agoBanks don't try that hard. One of my bank is happy to resend me a password by snail mail with an account ID reset by phone. Also, rechecking the ID of a user can be as simple as asking for a new token payment by the same credit card as used by the account. It's not infailable, the CC can be compromised as well, but it should be way better than what we have now.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> One of my bank is happy to resend me a password by snail mail with an account ID reset by phone. This is excellent security, as long as they're not sending it to an address you provided over the phone when you requested a reset.
- metasean 11y ago> Banks have the option of you physically going into the branch and identifying yourself with relevant legally backed forms of ID. Not always true! Less than a month ago I needed to login to my Wells Fargo account. Unbeknownst to me, they had been doing some 'upgrades' and there were some glitches. After a frustrating period, I decide I'd just go to the physical branch 1/4 mile from my house and get this fixed! On site, the bank personnel have access to exactly the same system that I did. (At least they knew there were glitches and sorta how to work around them.) I had two accounts, one for a credit card that I rarely used and my mortgage. Turns out, if you have a credit card then the new system requires a piece of information only found on the physical card - the onsite employees couldn't get around and neither could their call-in tech support!!!! Point is - for log-in purposes - don't assume going to a physical branch will be any more helpful! Since I didn't have the credit card with me ('cause rarely used) I canceled the rarely used credit card and was able to login shortly thereafter.
- rev_null 11y agoI once tried to log into a site only to discover that the security question I left for myself was "What is blue?". I never figured it out.
- brianwawok 11y agoThe sky!!!
- oaktowner 11y agoAT&T has a security code which is "What is your favorite restaurant?" that we set a decade ago when signing up for internet service. My wife and I have made, I don't know, 10 guesses over the years and have never been able to figure out what our response was back then. Questions with fact-based answers are much better. But...I once had a site ask me for my best man's first name (Good! This probably won't change over time!). I filled in "Dave" ... and the site gave me an error "Your answer must be at least 6 characters." Doh!
- ashitlerferad 11y agoSecurity questions should be treated as secondary password fields, since they are that. Use Diceware for a good tradeoff between entropy and memorability/pronounceability or more complex random passwords and store them in a safe place.
- mundo 11y agoThis works well until you get to the "Our site is so secure that we need you to answer three security questions from our canned list, and they can't all be the same string" geniuses. Such an antipattern.
- philsnow 11y agoFor every site that does this, I have a blob of text in my password manager where I write down Q: what was your childhood best friend's last name? A: pathway-titian-slowly-quiver-kodiak-hue etc., even for fact-based things like "what city were you born in?" or "what street did you live on in 1995?".
- ksml 11y agoOne option is to look at when the user last logged in. I would be a lot less pissed if an account that I've never touched in 10 years got compromised... I'm probably going to remember my info for recent accounts and want it to be difficult to social engineering those
- blowski 11y agoThis is an excellent point. > "You forgot the password that you've logged in with multiple times... including 20 minutes ago." That should raise a flag.
- tamar 11y agoNamecheap has security notifications that inform you of login attempts. https://www.namecheap.com/support/knowledgebase/article.aspx/486/45/how-can-i-adjust-security-settings-for-my-account https://www.namecheap.com/support/knowledgebase/article.aspx...
- pyre 11y agoThis is more about preventing the social engineering attacks. The example you're replying to is where the actual user logged in 20 minutes ago, while the attacker is trying to claim to customer service that they forgot the password. If customer service were looking at login attempts, they would see that it doesn't make sense for the user to not know their password, when clearly they provided it to the site just 20 minutes ago.
- tamar 11y agoI'm aware. This is an isolated comment about other security mechanisms that are in place for the user (not for the support staff).
- judemelancon 11y agoOne of the most frustrating things for support or customer service personnel to do is respond to something other than what was said.
- ramm110 11y agoI had a similar thing happen with my Battle.net account. I forgot to transfer over my authenticator backup code when I switched password managers last time. I had to send them a photo of my driver's license next to my face and another one of it next to a physical newspaper with the date on it. This seems like a much better process for recovering accounts that matter.
- philsnow 11y agoSo what do you think happened to those photos? Some people would be happy to pay for a leaked copy of those photos, for use with any other company that would accept only the "face/license" photo as sufficient proof.
- ramm110 11y agoI think having a recent date on the newspaper prevents reuse of the images. I'm not a Photoshop expert, so maybe that's trivial to change. When I look at my support ticket history on the website, the ticket attachments are gone, so hopefully they're shredded after the support person views them.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoThis seems very easy to bypass.
- Falcon9 11y agoVery easy? I'd say "possible" at best. And now you've got access to a battle.net account. Took a heck of a lot more work than asking someone for username/pass in a live chat, and what you gained access to is worth a heck of a lot less. Plus Blizzard actually does keep backups and records and will be able to fix the situation for the account owner. I'd be surprised if ever a Blizzard account was compromised by someone sending in a false picture.
- nommm-nommm 11y agoI don't know what battle.net is so I was speaking generally. Since pictures don't have security features on them it wouldn't be too difficult to photocopy your own id, change the name/address, print it out and glue it on a plastic card. You now have an Id that looks good enough for photo verification. It's a lot of work but if the steaks are high then it will be done. There's also the case when these pictures get leaked, there's a lot of people who have scans of my id. Or just photoshop the pic after its taken. There's services on the darknet where you can buy these fake Id picture/scans as well.
- Tzunamitom 11y agoVery much this. As a long-time Namecheap customer, this thread caught my attention, but my layman's conclusion is that it doesn't really sound like they did anything worse than any other host would have done. As someone who forgets his passwords on a regular basis, I'm kind of glad that there's no such thing as perfect security...
- ultramancool 11y agoThis is why I think a manual disable is the best bet. I backup my 2FA tokens using TiBu (encrypted locally and uploaded straight to cloud services). I'm 99.9% sure I'm never going to lose them. I want an option in my panel that says "do not let me use support without providing a 2fa token".
- djsumdog 11y agoTo be fair, that's a game account. I realize some MMOs can have really real-money valuable characters/items, so this argument can break down, but the security should be different from an MMO and a VPS solution or a bank. All of my security questions are passwords. I once had someone at a bank ask "Wait, your mother's maiden's name has a number in it?" "Wait, you actually answer security questions that any of your friends can guess honestly?"
- kbenson 11y ago> To be fair, that's a game account. I realize some MMOs can have really real-money valuable characters/items, so this argument can break down You want to know how bad it can break down? I imagine the worst case scenario, for so many reasons, actually happened and was mtgox.com. It started out as a Magic: The Gathering Online Exchange (from what I understand) before it became the now infamous Bitcoin exchange that was hacked[1] and massive amounts of money was stolen. I don't know for a fact that old accounts before the pivot to Bitcoin still existed and worked, but it's not inconceivable that they would. One hopes they adopted much better security compared to when they were a trading card exchange (if it wasn't already exceptional at that time), but there could very well have been a time when it was gaining traction for financial type services but didn't have good account safeguards. 1: Or whatever. From what I remember that's a story convoluted and with enough conspiracy theories it's worth a movie.
- cdr 11y agoMTGOX was purchased as a domain name for a possible MTG exchange, but it never went further than a domain name. There was never even a site.
- kbenson 11y agoAre you sure? Wikipedia[1] seems to indicate it at least got into a beta, but it also implies that the domain was what was reused for the bitcoin exchange, not the code base. That said, the references on wikipedia point to the Internet Archive, which shows a placeholder page that says it's in beta, but there's little there to indicate there was ever anything working. It also says it was used to advertise another card game later, but that was just a link to another domain. I guess that's a long-winded way of saying you are probably right. Then again, bitcoins were worth so little in 2010 that I could imagine the account security on exchanges back then being comparable to hobbiest exchange sites, so the spirit of the comment may be valid even if the specific example falls down. :/ 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mt._Gox#Founding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mt._Gox#Founding
- thwarted 11y agoSo could I have social engineered a 10 year old MTGO account? Yes. But without it, I would have been locked out. I was NOT going to remember some stupid passcode kid me set on a game account. And apparently I am the nacho King. What are the chances that you'll remember it in the future? You're already two years into remembering it for the next decade after you found it out again.
- gst 11y agoI would prefer being stuck without being able to login to my server, compared to potentially having customer support allow someone else to access my server.
- hvindin 11y agoI recently changed my phone support password at work to "aaah, f*, I'm not sure is it.." after listening to all my previous support calls and realising that was what I answered with 9/10 times. I suspect its only a matter of time before someone else accidentally guesses it. Its only for my regular user account, for my admin accounts I need to get another domain admin to reset the password, there is no process for anyone to exploit, just an audit every month.
- pyritschard 11y agoThis is something we struggled with at Exoscale, I took the time to do a small write-up of how we approach reset requests here: https://www.exoscale.ch/syslog/2016/04/13/i-lost-my-2-factor-tokens-now-what/ https://www.exoscale.ch/syslog/2016/04/13/i-lost-my-2-factor...