3 ms·
What's this crowd think of this idea for solving this problem? 1) Offer an option to opt-out of all automated account recovery. If set, no more email resets, s
by koolba 11y ago
What's this crowd think of this idea for solving this problem?
1) Offer an option to opt-out of all automated account recovery. If set, no more email resets, support PINs, or similar. This would be targeted at people truly care about security and have no issue with "forgetting passwords" (i.e. you use a password manager and you're not an idiot about backups).
2) Offer in-person, manual recovery. To participate in this you'd need to pre-register with full contact details (name/address/etc) of the valid people who could use this feature. The person would have to physically come to the office of the company, present two (or more) forms of identification. To add further security, you could add a mandatory wait period between initiating a reset and it taking effect (ex: min 7 days). That way a combination of fake ids and social engineering could (in theory) be stopped by getting an alert that "You initiated a manual reset of your XYZ account. Did you actually do this??"
EDIT: For #2 you could also add a non-trivial fee (say $500) that would need to be charged and cleared in advance of the person showing up.
- StavrosK 11y agoWe do something similar at Silent Circle. In your recovery options, there's a page with a high-entropy secret key and a QR code that you can print out to use if you ever forget your password. There's also a checkbox that says "don't ever recover this account" (i.e. the "I have a password database on Dropbox") checkbox. Checking that box actually disables password resets on the admin interface, so your account is pretty much dead if you lose the password.
- jontas 11y agoOT question about Silent Circle: I was just looking at your website, and I noticed that you cannot ship to PO Boxes. Is this a security feature (eg, no government knowledge of the recipient) or a logistics issue (eg, FedEx/UPS can't deliver to PO Boxes). I would imagine it is pretty hard to get service for your SIM card without revealing your identity to degree.
- StavrosK 11y agoI'm not actually sure about that (I assume you're referring to shipping a Blackphone?). The Blackphones are a semi-separate division that I don't have much contact with, unfortunately.
- detaro 11y agoweaker form of #2 would be a "send a registered letter" reset mode, in various forms (e.g. here in Germany there is a type of letter where you have to go to the post office and show matching ID to send it). Or require a (possibly named) notary to validate the request, or something along those lines. If you announce sending the reset letter there is also time for the account owner to prevent the reset unless an attacker manages to isolate them from all notification channels.
- roywiggins 11y agoThis is more or less how NearlyFreeSpeech works. You can set what level of identity proof you need to reset your password, or disable reset entirely. They seem pretty serious about it!