4 ms·
There is no terrorism-proof reactor design. We may have new tech but we also have new problems. Besides, we haven't solved the ultimate disposal place issue. It
by Tepix 11y ago
There is no terrorism-proof reactor design.
We may have new tech but we also have new problems.
Besides, we haven't solved the ultimate disposal place issue.
It's highly irresponsible to produce waste that is dangerous for thousands of years where noone has figured out how to handle it. Especially considering terrorism, corruption, states collapsing and natural disasters.
- VLM 11y ago>It's highly irresponsible to produce waste that is dangerous for thousands of years where noone has figured out how to handle it. The best part about nuclear waste is rapidly it becomes harmless, unlike every other kind of waste we produce. Unfortunately most of our waste is not nuclear, and therefore will contaminate the biosphere, basically forever.
- dannypgh 11y agoCitation? I thought a lot of the waste products, and what they decay into, are chemically toxic. Hardly "harmless"
- mcv 11y agoI think you may have that backwards. A lot of waste can be broken down, and will definitely be broken down on the timescale that some nuclear waste needs before it's harmless.
- jefurii 11y agoIt's also highly irresponsible to base our economy on carbon-based fuel that we know for a fact is in the process of making our planet unlivable. Sounds like a good idea to switch from enery sources that are in fact killing people to energy sources that only might kill people.
- adrianN 11y agoBreeder reactors reduce what we now call "waste" by >95%. That makes storage a lot easier, especially since the isotopes with long half-times get used up.
- AstralStorm 11y agoSadly, breeders are also quite usable for reprocessing fuel into weapons grade plutonium. This is the main reason they aren't used at any scale.
- phkahler 11y ago>> There is no terrorism-proof reactor design. We may have new tech but we also have new problems. Besides, we haven't solved the ultimate disposal place issue. Those problems are closely related. We know what to do about the disposal problem: build a reactor that consumes that material as fuel. The problem is allegedly that such a reactor increases the risk of rogue weapons production. I'm starting to think all that spent fuel sitting around in pools of water (requiring active cooling) is a bigger danger than building a reactor that doesn't produce all that waste.
- avn2109 11y ago>> "no terrorism-proof reactor design" I notice that not one of the American Navy's many nuclear reactors has ever been successfully targeted by terrorists. Which suggests that we have a well-understood design for terrorism-proof reactors: Build a reactor, and then cover it with fancy sensors, big guns, and a bunch of soldiers.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Recurecur 11y agoActually there is a quite terrorism proof reactor design. Thorcon's approach is to site the reactor itself 100 feet underground. Physical security for that type of setup is straightforward. Waste from the next generation of nuclear reactors (LFRs) is only dangerous for a few hundreds of years. Much less than the lifetime of CO2 in the atmosphere...
- cellularmitosis 11y agoBy straightforward, do you mean "blast the access tunnel in case of emergency and bury it under 100 ft of rock"?
- eximius 11y agoThorium reactors are always being touted as safe (run away reactions shut down the reactor by design) and produces relatively little waste (with comparatively short half lives). And they don't produce anything remotely related to weapons capabilities. I cannot verify that myself, but my friend who is a nuclear engineer is a fan, and it doesnt contradict what i've read about it.
- protomyth 11y agoThorium produces Plutonium-238 which is NOT bomb-making material but used in space probes. Thorium advocates should make sure to not have the word "nuclear" or "reactor" in any press and emphasize that the waste is "space fuel".
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> There is no terrorism-proof reactor design. There is no terrorism-proof anything. Whatever system a human devises, another can outsmart if they put their heart to it. You could use the same argument against building airplanes, airports, shopping malls, bus stops, power lines, schools... pretty much everything. Also consider that blowing up a hydro plant can result in much more direct fatalities than blowing up a nuclear reactor. Not to mention that any attack on power transmission infrastructure will likely kill even more people.