6 ms·
A design from the 50s-60s era of nuclear design should not still be in service for this reason. We can do way better now. Our process, materials, and engineeri
by exabrial 11y ago
A design from the 50s-60s era of nuclear design should not still be in service for this reason.
We can do way better now. Our process, materials, and engineering have advanced orders of magnitude.
- noir_lord 11y agoAll of those and reactor designs for safe(r) generation of civil power are very different to reactor designs for breeding weapons grade material/based on similar designs. We can build clean, efficient reactors that fail entirely safe.
- Retric 11y agoGood designs can't fix faulty construction and poor maintenance. France has a long history of success with nuclear power, but using the exact same designs in Afghanistan would be begging for problems. Further, we really don't have a good solution for nuclear waste. PS: Most importantly they cost more than renewable power even including energy storage.
- noir_lord 11y agoPossibly so I've not look recently but the cost of reactors is historically high because of the way they where built. Newer cheaper safer reactors built in volume would be cheaper than old designs, when the french went on their reactor building spree the cost per reactor was massively less than what Hinkley is costing. Tooling, scale, been able to lots of the same thing, experience etc all drive the cost down.
- Retric 11y agoConstruction costs are only part of the story. Construction, Mining/fuel processing, Operation, Decommissioning, Fuel Storage / reprocessing, Disaster Insurance. Sure, we can hand wave R&D as a sunk cost, but many of these costs only show up after the fact.
- noir_lord 11y agoAll of that stuff is debatable of course but given the massive environmental damage done mining Lithium I doubt there is much in it from the point of view of that one way or the other. As for fuel storage/reprocessing with modern reactor designs the waste products are much smaller and we do have sensible sane ways to deal with them. I'd absolutely love it if renewables dominated the percentage for generation but I think the future is more likely to be nuclear for baseload and renewables for the rest barring some huge breakthroughs in battery technology. Pumped hydro is still the most efficient way of storing huge amounts of potential energy but it's simply not a possibility for most places (and is hardly kind to the environment either since it often requires damaging lakes and rivers). Nuclear isn't perfect but it looks like the least worst option to me if implemented properly.
- Retric 11y agoYou can send electricity 1,000 miles with minimal losses. So there are some areas outside of reasonable pumped hydro but far fewer than you might think. PS: One way One way ~2,385km is viable. http://www.power-technology.com/features/featurethe-worlds-longest-power-transmission-lines-4167964/ http://www.power-technology.com/features/featurethe-worlds-l... And the world is not really all that big once you subtract oceans.
- Retric 11y agoOn the other hand we know where 60s era nuclear designs can fail. New stuff can fail in new and interesting ways.
- DanHulton 11y agoThankfully, we understand the physics a lot better now. The failure states for modern reactors are safe states. We've basically planned things so that if they do fail, they turn off.
- Retric 11y agoIn theory I might agree with you. In practice a lot of 'safe' designs for a wide range of things have failed. For a single reactor in a single location the odds might be very good. But, build a few thousand and the odds get worse. What happens if there is no power for months. What happens if an earthquake causes a reactor end up on it's side? What happens if there is a mistake while refueling? What about active sabotage? What if someone messes up in construction? How about a dam breaking causing massive wave? What about a combo of all of the above?
- Etzos 11y agoThere are risks associated with all kinds of power generation. Most of the things you list would apply to a lot of them. However, I'll attempt to address most of the ones you listed (and I'm assuming a boiling water reactor, there are alternatives that may be naturally more stable): Modern reactors have passive cooling systems[1] which will only require an outside pool to be refilled every 72 hours (easy to automate or just drop a pipe from another location) so it could be left without power for a very long time. Huge earthquakes which would shake a reactor apart would be strong enough to take down entire cities. A reactor going supercritical, while bad, is still less likely to kill. Furthermore, as long as the passive systems aren't completely destroyed they will still function. Refueling is done by shutting down the reactor, so the risk is low. Active sabotage would be difficult to accomplish because there are multiple layers of redundancy and control systems and people that would all have to be bypassed. Construction mistakes could happen to anything, although again with multiple redundancies it doesn't matter quite as much. Most of these issues are really boiling down to one-off incidents. Modern nuclear facilities have tons of redundancy and checks in place. Things can go south with any system, but modern nuclear facilities have a lot of layers to prevent catastrophic failure in all but the most extreme situations (situations which would cause plenty of death and destruction in general). I just think it's a little flippant to discount modern nuclear power generation because of the failings in the past when the field was still in its infancy. [1] https://nuclear.gepower.com/build-a-plant/products/nuclear-power-plants-overview/esbwr.html https://nuclear.gepower.com/build-a-plant/products/nuclear-p...
- Tepix 11y agoThere is no terrorism-proof reactor design. We may have new tech but we also have new problems. Besides, we haven't solved the ultimate disposal place issue. It's highly irresponsible to produce waste that is dangerous for thousands of years where noone has figured out how to handle it. Especially considering terrorism, corruption, states collapsing and natural disasters.
- VLM 11y ago>It's highly irresponsible to produce waste that is dangerous for thousands of years where noone has figured out how to handle it. The best part about nuclear waste is rapidly it becomes harmless, unlike every other kind of waste we produce. Unfortunately most of our waste is not nuclear, and therefore will contaminate the biosphere, basically forever.
- dannypgh 11y agoCitation? I thought a lot of the waste products, and what they decay into, are chemically toxic. Hardly "harmless"
- mcv 11y agoI think you may have that backwards. A lot of waste can be broken down, and will definitely be broken down on the timescale that some nuclear waste needs before it's harmless.
- jefurii 11y agoIt's also highly irresponsible to base our economy on carbon-based fuel that we know for a fact is in the process of making our planet unlivable. Sounds like a good idea to switch from enery sources that are in fact killing people to energy sources that only might kill people.
- adrianN 11y agoBreeder reactors reduce what we now call "waste" by >95%. That makes storage a lot easier, especially since the isotopes with long half-times get used up.
- TorKlingberg 11y agoWhat portion of current nuclear power generation is from these 50s-60s era designs?