7 ms·
I take issue with the account of Fukushima. Yes, a natural disaster kicked off the chain of events, but it was not completely unforeseeable and stronger safegu
by emodendroket 11y ago
I take issue with the account of Fukushima. Yes, a natural disaster kicked off the chain of events, but it was not completely unforeseeable and stronger safeguards and maintenance would have mitigated the disaster.
The big problem in my mind is not that nuclear power can't be safe but that I don't see anything to give me confidence that it can regulated to ensure that it actually is in practice.
- dsfyu404ed 11y agoThe only appreciable release of radiation was a result of the Soviets playing fast and loose with shoddy infrastructure followed by higher ups attempting to rectify the situation by burying their heads in the sand is good enough for me. Compared to oil spills ("oops, we grounded our tanker") and dam failures ("maintenance, lolwut?") a lot of different things needed to come together for the Chernobyl disaster to happen and the runners up, (3-mile, Fukushima) are downright benign by comparison. As long as we don't get complacent and half-ass things I have no problem with nuclear power.
- adrianN 11y agoI'm a strong supporter of nuclear power, but calling Fukushima benign is counter productive. Thousands have lost their homes and there are dangerous amounts of radiation leaking into the ground. The site will remain a money sinkhole of ongoing mitigation measures for a long time. But besides these direct effects, the handling of disaster showed that the responsible parties were trying very hard to cover everything up and thus permanently destroyed any confidence you might have had in them, proving the "human factors make nuclear unsafe" crowd right.
- adsfqwop 11y agoUnfortunately the human factor is exactly the problem with these types of systems. I don't think humans can ever be considered to be safe stewards of anything where a seemingly remote cascade event can wipe out life on the planet. Look at the disaster of Long-Term Capital Management from the financial industry as an example, where a presumed ten sigma event almost wiped out the whole western financial system. http://epicureandealmaker.blogspot.fi/2007/05/11000000000000000000000000.html http://epicureandealmaker.blogspot.fi/2007/05/11000000000000... These nuclear reactors are built with the same underlying principles and risk-management profiles. There's always the element of human error; you can't over-engineer something you did not foresee. In addition to that you have the enormous profit incentives from running nuclear power. These incentives can overwhelm the incentives for safety, or lead to disregard of warnings where profit potential would be compromised if warnings were attended to. It's human, therefore it's hard to ever sleep completely sound knowing that these constructions are running on the planet. Fukushima didn't just happen because one mistake was made either. It happened because a long string of mistakes and disregard of safety happened. Want to bet it doesn't happen again? It's hard to bet against human nature... http://carnegieendowment.org/files/fukushima.pdf http://carnegieendowment.org/files/fukushima.pdf
- adrianN 11y agoNo single plant failure can wipe out life on the planet. Not even if all plants fail simultaneously and dump their entire cores into the atmosphere you'd wipe out all life on the planet. So please don't overstate the risks. Now, obviously no catastrophic event in a nuclear power plant (or any other system engineered for safety) happens because of a single mistake. If it did that would be a huge error in the systems design. For a catastrophe to happen, several layers of safety systems need to fail at the same time. I think its possible to engineer systems that are safe enough even in the presence of human factors. Modern reactor designs for example are a lot safer than what we had in Fukushima. But convincing you of this would probably take a lot more text than fits in HN discussion, so let's just disagree on this point.
- MichaelGG 11y ago>presumed ten sigma event How are financial people even calculating that kind of rarity? I remember seeing a recent article here on HN about a guy that lost a ton of (someone else's) money playing with oil contracts. He went on about how he diligently planned for "huge" failures, such as a drop of up to 30 percent in the price of oil. I don't think it's fair to bring in finance. Natural disasters and nuclear reactors are far more well behaved and understood.
- this_user 11y ago> How are financial people even calculating that kind of rarity? They don't properly, and that is the problem. A lot of it had to do with creating models that do not reflect reality. They worked fine until extraordinary circumstances occur under which they break down. A well known mistake is assuming a normal distribution for financial returns. In reality this greatly underestimates the likelihood and magnitude of extreme moves that can cause catastrophic losses. Nassim Nicholas Taleb's book "The Black Swan" discusses this in great detail. The bottom line is essentially that a move more extreme than what you anticipated is going to happen eventually. LTCM made the mistake of neglecting the impact of changing correlations. The thought they had outsmarted the market by eliminating risk from their portfolio. But in times of financial turmoil, correlations of risky assets tend to increase. If your carefully constructed and hedged portfolio does not take this into account, you may be exposed to much more risk than you intended. This is precisely what happend to them. The fund was bailed out by a group of large banks, and their bets did eventually pay off, but the temporary losses were far beyond what their models had anticipated.
- wstrange 11y agoLet's put this in perspective. 15,894 people died as a result of the earthquake and tsunami. By all accounts, Fukushima was a relatively benign event.
- danneu 11y agoWell, that's not by all accounts. That's by one account: direct deaths, which isn't the worst part of a nuclear catastrophe. Only 31 people died during the Chernobyl meltdown, according to its wiki page. The nice thing about an earthquake or tsunami is that they kill and then go away.
- jahewson 11y agoChernobyl was much, much worse than Fukishima. Chernobly rained down radiation on many hundreds of thousands of people. Parts of the surrounding area are intensely radioactive to this day. Fukishima is nothing like that. Total deaths from Chernobly, including cancers is expected to be around 4000. That represents approximately a 3% increase in cancer risk to some 600,000 people.
- vonmoltke 11y ago> Parts of the surrounding area are intensely radioactive to this day. Fukishima is nothing like that. Outside of the capped reactor building itself, nothing around Chernobyl is "intensely radioactive".
- catawbasam 11y ago"The Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster has no confirmed casualties from radiation exposure, though six workers died due to various reasons, including cardiovascular disease, during the containment efforts or work to stabilize the Earthquake and Tsunami damage to the site.[15]" source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_and_radiation_accidents_by_death_toll https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nuclear_and_radiation_...
- ptaipale 11y ago> direct deaths, which isn't the worst part of a nuclear catastrophe. And the definitely largest impact in indirect deaths with Fukushima came from the emotion-based decision to shut down other nuclear reactors, even if there was nothing wrong with them. This lead to electricity shortage and lack of air conditioning, which killed dozens or hundreds (mostly elderly people in hospitals or similar care, who suffered heart attacks in the summer heat). http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2011-07-12/heatstroke-deaths-quadruple-as-japan-shuns-ac http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2011-07-12/heatstroke...
- creshal 11y ago> As long as we don't get complacent You and, going by Chernobyl's fallout distribution, everyone else within a radius of roughly 2000 km. Looking on a map, for me this includes Chernobyl itself, the fallout of which is still measurable around here and contaminates dozens of forests to the point that mushrooms and game from there is considered inedible, and everything else between such stable, wealthy nations as Estonia, Tunisia and Syria. No, I can't really say I'm confident in peoples' abilities to keep nuclear reactors out of harm's way.
- rconti 11y ago"Considered inedible" is not the same thing as "actually unsafe".
- vonmoltke 11y ago> the fallout of which is still measurable around here The radioactivity of granite mined decades ago and used to build buildings is still measurable using modern sensing devices. "Measurable" is a pretty bad threshold to use. > contaminates dozens of forests to the point that mushrooms and game from there is considered inedible "Considered" by whom? What are the actual levels? How do they compare to the radioactivity of other foods? From what I can tell, the vast majority of the damage from nuclear accidents is not caused by the accident itself but the radiation-paranoid overreaction to it.
- creshal 11y ago> "Considered" by whom? German and EU authorities. > What are the actual levels? How do they compare to the radioactivity of other foods? http://www.sueddeutsche.de/bayern/hohe-radioaktive-werte-wildschweine-sind-weiterhin-verstrahlt-1.1621865 http://www.sueddeutsche.de/bayern/hohe-radioaktive-werte-wil... Legal levels are <400 Bq/kg for baby food and 600 Bq/kg for other foods; contamination in these cases ranges from 1000 to 10000 Bq/kg.
- Avshalom 11y agoA banana hangs out at ~30000 Bq/kg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_equivalent_dose https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_equivalent_dose
- kafkaesq 11y agoAs long as we don't get complacent and half-ass things I have no problem with nuclear power. As if that will ever stop happening. On a less snarky level: in a complex system (like basically any large-scale power generation scheme) we can't separate the underlying technology from the petty failings and foibles of the luckless human beings (quite often largely or entirely non-technical) saddled with the awful responsibility of having to manage it. And most especially not their time-tested propensity to sweep things under the rug and cover one's ass at the first sign of trouble (or even undue complication). That's why we need to choose technologies which are resilient to human failure - not, implicitly, reliant and utterly dependent on human perfection to keep them from tipping over.
- tajen 11y agoHave we ever trid asking a private insurance for a coverage? We often have the problem that the state tries to play the insurance role, whereas if every damage were to be paid for by an insurance, they'd "gide us" through respecting the procedures. Like we personally press charges and bankrupt you for life if you don't shut down the plant for every indicator that goes mildly not-green on this panel. Then we'd know the real cost of insuring for nuclear. Our problem is that the state is trying to make the nuclear investment itself.
- josho 11y agoI think the reason we don't have private insurance is the worst case risk is too significant for a single enterprise to absorb. Which is why the state is involved. Your point remains valid, I just wish our governments were better at avoiding regulatory capture so we could trust them to do their job at this.
- guscost 11y agoThe panic around every non-Chernobyl nuclear incident is insane. I've mentioned before that if Japan would legally allow it I'd immediately move next to the Fukushima reactor as a kind of publicity stunt. It's probably worth pursuing further.
- cgh 11y agoIt would be a great way to buy a house in a very private setting for a trivial sum. It's kind of like buying a house near high-tension power lines. Enough people with kooky beliefs will lower real estate prices.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- return0 11y agoWell if the japanese could not foresee it, i can imagine what would have happened in a less developed country. I fully agree that we should be switching to nuclear already, but everyone who agrees should be willign to sign a petition to build a nuclear plant 10km from their home. I suspect a large reason it's not being promoted is the fear of developing nuclear weapon tech.
- DanBC 11y agoI would gladly have a nuclear power station in my back garden. Show me where I can signup to have eg Toshiba 4s in my back yard and I'll sign today. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toshiba_4S https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toshiba_4S FWIW I have written to my MP and said this.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoJust go buy a bunch of solar panels. Even if you signed up for a Toshiba 4s, it won't be cost competitive with solar by the time its installed. Wind is already cheaper than nuclear in the US, and our fleet will probably start being turned down over the next decade due to it [1] It's also evident in Europe [2]. [1] http://midwestenergynews.com/2015/05/01/exelon-we-have-to-have-an-answer-on-nuclear-plants/ http://midwestenergynews.com/2015/05/01/exelon-we-have-to-ha... [2] http://cleantechnica.com/2013/11/05/nuclear-prices-market-graph/ http://cleantechnica.com/2013/11/05/nuclear-prices-market-gr...
- DanBC 11y agoI'd happily have both - solar panels on roof and nuclear in the neigbourhood.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI'd too live next to a nuclear power plant. Free heat! But it doesn't look like the economics work anymore.
- chc 11y ago
- mcv 11y agoThat's really the problem here, as well as in other industries: perhaps it can be safe in theory, but when exploited by profit-driven companies, corners will be cut. This is not only true for nuclear power, but also for oil spills. The Deepwater Horizon disaster happened because BP cut corners. Fukushima happened because the company ignored warnings. Maybe we just can't leave these kind of things in the hands of big corporations.
- vonmoltke 11y agoChernobyl happened because a government bureaucracy was lax and cocky. Love Canal happened because multiple government bureaucracies were lazy and didn't give a shit. Maybe we just can't leave these kind of things in the hands of big, disconnected bureaucracies at all.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoBig corporations and big government bureaucracies are very similar to each other. In both cases you have tons of formalisms required by law, and lots of people jockeying for status and money.
- mcv 11y agoTrue, but a well functioning company strives to maximize profits and reduce costs, whereas a well functioning government strives to maximize public benefit. A well functioning company might still decide to cut corners. Although I suppose that could be prevented with really tight regulation and harsh punishment for companies that still mess up. But if there's really no organization capable of handling this responsibility, then maybe we shouldn't use these technologies on this scale at all.
- kazinator 11y agoAll kinds of potentially dangerous technology is safe and regulated in practice. Broad categories: aviation, medicine, automotive, electrical power, ... Speaking of the latter, no matter how you generate electricity, the electricity itself is dangerous; if that isn't made safe and regulated, you have problems. Explosions, fires, electrocutions.
- blakeyrat 11y agoIn the US, we have thousands of Navy and ex-Navy personnel perfectly qualified to safely maintain nuclear reactors, and who (as a group) have an extremely impressive safety record. But we're not utilizing this resource for civilian purposes. Not even slightly.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoOur country as a whole woefully underutilizes our military. It was the Army Corps of Engineers after all that built the roads and bridges which laid the foundation for America's breakneck growth in the 19th century. We should reinstate the draft. Not everybody has to fight, but everyone should serve their country. And, for example, perhaps a few years doing cyber defense for the Air Force will be seen as a more efficient pipeline into tech jobs than college or coding boot camps.
- emodendroket 11y agoRealistically the big reason the draft went away is it engenders serious resistance to foreign wars
- __jal 11y agoYep. It makes it harder to convince the rubes to die for someone else's private gain when you enslave them outright. Works much better if they're desperate due to "austerity" measures, so they choose to sign up.
- icebraining 11y agoRicher neighbourhoods are actually over-represented in the US military compared to the general population, especially since 9/11.
- mikestew 11y agoWe should reinstate the draft. Not everybody has to fight, but everyone should serve their country. We have a word for it: conscription. Along with that comes a bunch of people making a bunch of money, little of which goes into my pocket. I'm going to pass on that generous offer, thanks.
- wrsh07 11y agoDo you take issue with this sentence? "...the reality is that five years later, radiobiological consequences of Fukushima are practically negligible - no one has died from the event, and is it extraordinarily unlikely that anyone will do so in future." Because if not, it doesn't seem like Fukushima is really a disaster you can point to and say, "This is why nuclear is bad."
- emodendroket 11y agoIt's rendered a rather wide section of Japan a ghost town and I'm not really convinced it is so "extraordinarily unlikely" or that the numbers aren't being fudged considering the scandals about lead in geiger meters of cleanup workers and so on.
- wrsh07 11y agoYour point would have been better made with a link: http://news.nationalgeographic.com/2016/03/160310-fukushima-anniversary-photos/ http://news.nationalgeographic.com/2016/03/160310-fukushima-... I'd love to have numbers, like is it 100km^2? I looked but couldn't find any sources backing up your claim about geiger counter scandals, so my only advice is to be skeptical of things you read on both sides. Of course it's dumb to ignore warnings that nuclear power plants can cause massive amounts of damage, but there are also over 400 active nuclear reactors.
- emodendroket 11y agoAmong other accusations: " The workers’ dosimeter badges, meanwhile, used to measure an individual’s exposure to radiation, could be easily manipulated to give false readings. According to Suzuki, tricks like pinning a badge on backwards, or putting it in your sock, were commonplace. Regular workers were given dosimeters which would sound an alarm when radiation exceeded safe levels, but it made such a racket that, says Suzuki, “people just turned them off or over and kept working.”" http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/japan/japan-earthquake-and-tsunami-in/9084151/How-the-Yakuza-went-nuclear.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/japan/japan-e...