8 ms·
I'm by no means anti-nuclear, though watching Fukushima unfold showed me a reality I hadn't fully thought out. A few days after it all went bad, there was basi
by grecy 11y ago
I'm by no means anti-nuclear, though watching Fukushima unfold showed me a reality I hadn't fully thought out.
A few days after it all went bad, there was basically nothing we could do to stop it, which is terrifying. No humans could go in there, and there were no robots capable of doing the job.
So we as humans have the ability to build a machine of enormous power and (possibly) radiation, but when things inevitably go bad from time to time, our only course of action is to stand back and say "well, damn".
- noxToken 11y agoI believe the issue with Fukushima was that the early warning signs were ignored. If you ignore those warning signs with something that has the potential to be catastrophic, this is the result.
- maxerickson 11y agoThe seawall was shorter than it should have been, that is a planning and design failure, not just ignoring warning signs. There also doesn't seem to have been any planning for a situation where the seawall failed (the inundation rendered the on site backup power inoperative). Adding a second layer of protection to such an important system would not be particularly aggressive.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- matthewmcg 11y agoI agree. But watching BP's contractors repeatedly fail to plug the Deepwater Horizon gusher made me realize that these catastrophic possibilities are not limited to nuclear power. With non-renewable energy production, the situation is literally "pick your poison."
- jbattle 11y agoAlso the Aliso Canyon natural gas leak - something like 100+ days of the thing uncontrollably spewing gas
- atemerev 11y agoHydro is renewable, and dangerous. So is silicon production for solar panels. Life is a risky business.
- zeveb 11y ago> With non-renewable energy production, the situation is literally "pick your poison." Isn't that true of renewable energy production at scale, too? Solar panels require some very nasty industrial processes to produce, wind more than decimates bird populations, tidal affects sealife and the seafloor, hydroelectric affects fish (and poorly-maintained dams can destroy cities and regions …). I think it might actually be unavoidable: any process which generates the amount of energy required to sustain human life at scale will … be responsible for handling a huge amount of energy at scale. edit: I'm unaware of issues with goethermal, but a) it's not possible most places; b) the fact that I'm unaware of them doesn't imply that they don't exist.
- patall 11y agoWell, another big issue with (current?) solar panels is that they are highly problematic in case of fire (fire brigade with the waterhose closes the electric circuit with the grounded panel) And geothermal has more than once been suspected to be responsible for more or less immidiate earth-quakes. Choose your risks on yourself...
- mcv 11y agoThe decimation of bird populations by wind turbines is somewhat exaggerated. Wind turbines do kill birds, but not remotely as many as powerlines, windows, cats or cars do: http://science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/green-science/wind-turbine-kill-birds.htm http://science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/green-science... So while it is an issue, it's not remotely as much of an issue as other technologies that everybody takes for granted and nobody complains about. I wonder if the same might be true for tidal: that existing sea traffic and fishing might have a far bigger impact on sea life than energy generation would have.
- blakeyrat 11y agoSimilarly, coal-burning power plants put more radioactive materials into the atmosphere in a year than nuclear power plants have in their entire history, but nobody worries about that because coal power is old and we're all used to it. Ironically, the people opposing the construction of new nuclear plants are implicitly encouraging the construction/refurbishment of coal plants, and thus increasing the amount of radiation in the atmosphere.
- exabrial 11y agoA design from the 50s-60s era of nuclear design should not still be in service for this reason. We can do way better now. Our process, materials, and engineering have advanced orders of magnitude.
- noir_lord 11y agoAll of those and reactor designs for safe(r) generation of civil power are very different to reactor designs for breeding weapons grade material/based on similar designs. We can build clean, efficient reactors that fail entirely safe.
- Retric 11y agoGood designs can't fix faulty construction and poor maintenance. France has a long history of success with nuclear power, but using the exact same designs in Afghanistan would be begging for problems. Further, we really don't have a good solution for nuclear waste. PS: Most importantly they cost more than renewable power even including energy storage.
- noir_lord 11y agoPossibly so I've not look recently but the cost of reactors is historically high because of the way they where built. Newer cheaper safer reactors built in volume would be cheaper than old designs, when the french went on their reactor building spree the cost per reactor was massively less than what Hinkley is costing. Tooling, scale, been able to lots of the same thing, experience etc all drive the cost down.
- Retric 11y agoConstruction costs are only part of the story. Construction, Mining/fuel processing, Operation, Decommissioning, Fuel Storage / reprocessing, Disaster Insurance. Sure, we can hand wave R&D as a sunk cost, but many of these costs only show up after the fact.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 11y ago>I'm by no means anti-nuclear, though watching Fukushima unfold showed me a reality I hadn't fully thought out. The even worse reality is the government, contractors and everybody else involved repeatedly caught lying about it -- plus all the human errors in judgment and engineering involved leading to this. And it's a huge industry which can employ a lot of researchers to lie with selective statistics, and sell the evergreen "newer models will be different this time, really".
- Symmetry 11y agoAnd yet, given the amount of power it generated Fukushima still didn't kill any more people than a typical coal power plant.
- jhanschoo 11y agoHi, I'm inclined to believe you, but can you quote some numbers to back your assertion?
- arm85 11y agoI don't know where he got his reference from, but, renewable energy without the hot air, has something similar, it calculates the number of deaths per GWy, for different sources[0]. Coal is certainly near the top (second to oil)[0]. Although I believe it was published after fukushima, and people might be suffering illness not accounted for in the book, I imagine that fukushima won't have dented the stats very much. [0] http://www.withouthotair.com/c24/page_168.shtml http://www.withouthotair.com/c24/page_168.shtml
- overdrivetg 11y agoHere's a simple chart, with what look like credible sources: http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-deathprint-a-price-always-paid/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-de...
- Symmetry 11y agoSorry, should have included a link with that. http://hopefullyintersting.blogspot.com/2013/12/fukushima-vs-coal.html http://hopefullyintersting.blogspot.com/2013/12/fukushima-vs...
- tobltobs 11y ago"So it was a disaster that killed roughly 180 people." Just if somebody don't want to read all the glorification of nuclear power of this guy but want to know which numbers he used for his theory. "Over it's lifetime Fukushima generated 877,692 Gigawatt-Hours of electricity .." Subtracting the energy required to build, maintain, dismantle a nuclear reactor and store the waste for the next few thousand years would be nitpicking.
- rurounijones 11y agoHave a read of this as a counterpoint to fukusho.a http://thebulletin.org/onagawa-japanese-nuclear-power-plant-didn%E2%80%99t-melt-down-311 http://thebulletin.org/onagawa-japanese-nuclear-power-plant-...