10 ms·
My go-to story whenever anyone says "money can't buy happiness" is this: A good friend of mine was diagnosed with Liver Cancer around the same time as Steve Jo
by AndrewKemendo 11y ago
My go-to story whenever anyone says "money can't buy happiness" is this:
A good friend of mine was diagnosed with Liver Cancer around the same time as Steve Jobs. Both lived near SF, and both were put on the waiting list for transplants around the same time (+- 2 months). She was young, very sick and otherwise healthy so was a good candidate to be high on the list.
Then I heard about Steve "moving" to Tennessee [1] to get on a different, shorter transplant list - and thus receiving the transplant needed. She died shortly after, never receiving a transplant, while Jobs lived two more years.
This is not a complaint or gripe about fairness, but just a demonstration of how two very different people in a very similar predicament had massively different outcomes based almost entirely on wealth, fame and power. Money buys access, which create options, which enable health, freedom and longevity. It's so simple and obvious I don't know how people can argue otherwise.
[1] http://www.commercialappeal.com/news/southern-transplants-how-apple-ceo-steve-jobs-got-the-liver-he-needed-in-memphis-ep-307208860-329010091.html http://www.commercialappeal.com/news/southern-transplants-ho...
[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=od6Nq_bN_XY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=od6Nq_bN_XY
- nxzero 11y agoAs if someone is able to simply decide to be Steve Jobs, as wealthy he was, etc.
- emodendroket 11y agoWhat does "deciding" have to do with it?
- nxzero 11y agoMy understanding of your comment is that instead of my position that it is illogical to believe everyone can be as wealthy as Jobs, that everyone should get the same medical care regardless of how much money they have to spend. Right? If so, unclear to me how such a position would play out in the real world. Please explain.
- emodendroket 11y agoI'm not sure you mean my comment and not someone else's. All I'm saying is that "deciding" has nothing to do with the question of whether money means you can get better medical care. Who said anything about "everyone being as wealthy as Steve Jobs?" But one way a less blatantly corrupt system could "play out in the real world" is not allowing people to arbitrarily switch states when they find the organ waiting list not to their liking, or just maintaining the whole waiting list at a national level.
- nxzero 11y agoYou're cherry picking medical issues & care, which will not solve an issue as big as this. If you're claiming that everyone should be forced to use the same system, unless you're able to explain how that would happened and why it would be better, I'm not going to speculate on what you believe would fix the issue.
- Roritharr 11y ago> It's so simple and obvious I don't know how people can argue otherwise. Because its terribly depressing for many people to admit it.
- emodendroket 11y agoIt also kind of goes against the national mythos in the case of the US, which compounds the difficulty.
- thrownear 11y agoIt is terribly depressing for many people to admit the reverse also. That money cannot buy happiness...
- mrottenkolber 11y agoWell, not that many people are rich so... who cares?
- qznc 11y agoIt is a consolation for the poor, though. "They might be rich, but I might be happier." Just like "They might be rich, but they are assholes/corrupt/stupid/ugly".
- Retra 11y agoSounds to me like something a preacher would announce just before passing around a collection plate.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoIt's not as simple as that. Consider the difference between people who were born rich and those that have worked hard to become rich. It's quite possible to work yourself into an early grave, even if you end up rich.
- MajorLOL 11y ago
- lr4444lr 11y agoMoney always finds a way. In the case of very limited precious resources, like healthy transplantable organs, what alternative do we have? Is the gift of extended hope via forced random assignment substantially better?
- coldtea 11y agoYes.
- tosseraccount 11y agoAll precious resources should be randomly allocated?
- seren 11y agoFrom my point of view, the issue in buying and thus selling organs is that it creates an incentive to hack someone and sell the body parts piece by piece (like it is rumored to happen in China). So as long as we can't grow organs, I think it is preferable to not create that kind of incentive. On the other hand, you could argue that the fact there is no market will hinder some innovation. But given the scarcity of organs, I am pretty sure than producing mechanical hearts or eyes would find pretty of interested people anyway.
- kamaal 11y agoFor poor people there are always a stack of problems. Access to precious resources is just the problem on the top of the stack. Even if you did solve the problem, other problems in the stack would start popping up. Being rich always helps.
- lr4444lr 11y agoBut it's already illegal to sell organs and yet this harvesting still happens. Anything people will pay enough for to push providers past the fear of getting caught is going to generate a black market. If the money received by the organ registry on a highest-bidder basis were earmarked exclusively to research on synthetic alternatives, I believe would probably get to a better world faster than the current state of affairs.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- thrownear 11y agoSorry, that is nothing new, and it proves nothing. If money could buy happiness, they there would be zero cases of rich people killing themselves. Your argument is like saying a car can buy you happiness because one guy with car was able to reach hospital in case of an emergency, and was saved, while another guy, with a similar emergency died on the way, because he had no car...
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoDidn't say it was new, but I think it does prove that you can increase longevity with money. I'd say being alive is a proxy for happiness (lets say at least 51%). >If money could buy happiness, they there would be zero cases of rich people killing themselves. Man that analysis is just incredibly faulty. As far as you know they killed themselves months or years later than they otherwise would have. I have way more experience with suicide than I would prefer and can tell you that money troubles are a SIGNIFICANT factor for suicidal ideation and attempts [1]. [1] Wang, Y., Sareen, J., Afifi, T. O., Bolton, S. L., Johnson., E. A. (2012). Recent stressful life events and suicide attempt. Psychiatric Annals, 42.3, 101-108.
- thrownear 11y agoMoney cannot buy happiness, if you don't know what you need, or what you need cannot be bought. I am not saying that all cases of human suffering falls into that category, but a lot of them do. >As far as you know they killed themselves months or years later than they otherwise would have... That means, they tried to buy happiness, but failed to do so, right?
- coldtea 11y agoIt might not be able to "buy happiness" but it can alleviate a lot of unhappy stuff forced upon people, like not affording health care, living in a dump, working 2 shitty jobs, etc...
- emodendroket 11y agoMoney alone cannot make you happy, sure. But it does not follow that, therefore, being rich isn't so great, which is often what people are trying to suggest by trotting out that old saw.
- saiya-jin 11y agovery sorry to hear that, I presume many cases of normal person X didn't make it vs Steve did (well...). but let's make it more apples to apples, and compare against one of most wealthy humans ever, that's a tiny category on its own. This "money can't buy happiness" is meant (or should be) somewhere along - give a man earning X dollars 2X (or 10X) instead. Short term boost of happiness will quickly fade away, and what is left? Bigger TV screen, faster car, more stupid partying or 10 bedrooms instead of 2? That's what most people do when they suddenly win/inherit large amounts of cash. Most of them end up as sad stories. If you are not happy, more cash will not change this in 99% of the cases. Long lasting happiness doesn't come from stuff you can actually buy, or if yes they cost a tiny bit (many super intense experiences can be done with little cash, ie backpacker travelling around the world which is superior to any other way including most expensive packaged vacations, outdoor adventuring, extreme sports etc.).
- maxerickson 11y agoYou don't need to be Steve Jobs wealthy to adopt a domicile of convenience. (anyone able to support themselves without working could do it)
- DougWebb 11y agoBut if you give a man earning 0.1X dollars X, you can make a huge and long-lasting impact on the man's happiness, because he didn't have enough money before and now he does. Money doesn't buy happiness directly; it buys security, and security enables happiness.
- LeifCarrotson 11y agoYou cannot use "suddenly win/inherit large amounts of cash" to estimate what would happen if the poor in general had more money than they do. The players of the lotto and the expectations for winners are distorted. Also, we hear and remember the news stories about the flaming fall from fortune more than the person who chose the monthly payments or invested the inheritance wisely and live quietly with secure housing, adequate healthy food, and a retirement plan where they previously were behind on rent and wondering where the next meal would come from.
- chvid 11y agoI always thought that Steve Jobs was a perfect example that even if you were rich, famous, important you can still die very young. I know in Denmark where everything health care is run by the public sector and there is a very egalitarian access; you also have the wealthy living considerable longer than the poor. I think lifestyle factors such as good social life, meaningful professional life matter a lot. Probably more than health care access.
- nxzero 11y agoSteve Jobs died regretting that he had spent so long attempting to treat his cancer with alternative medicine before agreeing to undergo surgery, according to his biographer Walter Isaacson; if he had received treatment as soon as he was aware of the cancer, it's possible he would still be alive today.
- rlanday 11y agoPossible but far from certain.
- overcast 11y agoThe version of pancreatic cancer he had was actually the one that was very curable. For all of his intelligence, he chose poorly, and paid for it with his life.
- downandout 11y agoActually, according to the the story that Isaacson and others familiar with the situation told, it's fairly certain that he would have made a full recovery. Of course it's possible that he would have died by now due to other causes - his plane could have crashed etc - but he would not have died as a result of cancer. In this case, his belief in alternative medicine killed him.
- arethuza 11y ago"meaningful professional life" One thing that I've noticed is that some men I've known (and it seems to be a male problem) don't handle the step change from a high flying career to retirement at all well. Seeing people who have worked hard to enjoy a very comfortable retirement drop dead within a year of retiring is pretty alarming! [NB They weren't in software]
- jazzyk 11y agoMoney is necessary to have a certain quality of life (quality healthcare, etc), but is certainly not sufficient to achieve happiness.
- Retric 11y agoPeople are not created equal, some are predisposed to happiness so you are limited in how much happiness you can buy. However, if money is not buying happiness your not buying the right things. EX1: Sometimes your better off paying down debt or investing than buying stuff. EX2: Sometimes your better off buying stuff for other people than yourself. EX3: Buying experiences tends to have better returns than stuff. EX4: Sometimes the best thing to 'buy' is time by making less money.
- nibs 11y agoI agree most with this way of thinking. Money is downside protection but the upside benefit happiness wise is minimal. I think relationships, meaningful work, healthy diet and exercise, sleeping well, sense of community, etc. matter more for upside happiness.
- bryondowd 11y agoExactly, I always read the saying this way. Money doesn't buy you happiness directly, it buys you the security and comfort that provide a foundation for you to build your happiness on. You can be happy with little or no money, but it takes a much smaller disruption event to make it all collapse, like a house built on a shoddy foundation.
- afarrell 11y agoIt is far easier to have a healthy diet if you can afford: - fridge space for fresh ingredients that you don't have to split with roommates - An apartment a short distance to a grocer - pantry space for cooking tools and dry ingredients that you don't have to split with roommates - the cooking tools themselves - the time and mental energy to teach yourself a new skill - money to spend on take-out when you mess up a recipe
- zanny 11y agoThat doesn't change that even across your entire life, probably only one in ten people need an organ transplant in the first place. Circumstantially some people can need dramatically more or less money. Even if you take an average life in the US, the amount you need to comfortably live in rural Tennessee vs urban New York is enormous. But discussions about money and happiness are not usually about the extreme cases and outliers, but about the average. When you have a case about "average life expectancy" you cannot refute it with the exceptions we know exist to the rule. The principal still remains - on average, the poorer you are, the lower on the Maslow hierarchy you idle, and thus the less happy / healthy you are, simply because you have less fulfillment. Your hierarchy could be dramatically harder to climb, as is the case of a liver cancer patient, but we are not talking about edge cases, we are talking about the average. Once you climb that hierarchy, and have all your base needs fulfilled, and have effective financial security, having more money is not going to make you tangibly happier. IE, buying a yacht instead of renting a traditional boat is not a marked increase in happiness compared to having hot food to eat each night or waking up in the morning without worrying if you are losing your apartment today.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoWhy does the argument always go to Veblen goods (Yachts etc...) in this discussion rather than exactly what I indicate - health, wellness, options, access etc...? Edge cases are the ones that make or break people. Holding aside the argument for socialized or egalitarian healthcare, it's undeniable that major events in someone's life (major illness, accident, death, foreclosure etc...) are a primary factor for decrease in happiness. Since it's also undeniable that money can offset or augment the impact of these events - it is very relevant to take those into account. Said another way, everyone will eventually have an "edge case" irrespective of whether it is liver cancer or otherwise. Having means to ease the troubles related to those cases, have a direct effect on how badly they are felt.
- cryoshon 11y ago>Edge cases are the ones that make or break people. Holding aside the argument for socialized or egalitarian healthcare, it's undeniable that major events in someone's life (major illness, accident, death, foreclosure etc...) are a primary factor for decrease in happiness. Since it's also undeniable that money can offset or augment the impact of these events - it is very relevant to take those into account. Yes. Hence the media's trend of attempting to shift blame to people who have experienced edge events by deriding them as irresponsible or whatever. It's better for the serfs to think that "money can't buy happiness" and ignore that "money can prevent or mitigate common causes of unhappiness". It's also better if the serfs remain jealous of the wealthy, but not actually knowledgeable about the vastness of their wealth. If enough people consciously hold the thought which you detailed in mind, economic revolution is inevitable, and, failing that, violent revolution is probable.
- Gatsky 11y agoI'm very sorry to hear about your friend. Jobs had a metastatic pancreatic neuroendocrine tumour. This is a still ultimately fatal but relatively indolent cancer. It sounds like your friend had a primary liver cancer, which has a more aggressive course.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoYou are correct, however given the prognosis and remedy it would seem that she and Jobs both had an opportunity to remedy some or all of their conditions through the same process.
- kamaal 11y ago>>It's so simple and obvious I don't know how people can argue otherwise. Most people I know are confused between human emotions and happiness. No matter how much money you earn, you will still feel sad at the death of some whom you cared about, you will have all other myriad of human emotions any person on earth rich or poor will have to go through. And this shouldn't be confused with happiness. Also I have a feeling that believing money can buy happiness and to a degree about the brutal fairness in the world in many occasions can destroy many people from inside. People want to believe being mediocre is perfectly ok, they want to believe chance plays a huge role in ones life and that success and failure are always out of ones control.
- id 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illusion_of_control https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illusion_of_control
- alanwatts 11y agoAfter providing for the basic physiological and safety needs (Level 1 & 2 of Maslow's Hierachy of Needs[1]), the "happiness" returns that money can buy quickly diminish. I think when a lot of people say "money can't buy happiness" they are assuming survival is not a problem. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow%27s_hierarchy_of_needs
- XzetaU8 11y ago>the "happiness" returns that money can buy quickly diminish. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hedonic_treadmill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hedonic_treadmill
- AndrewKemendo 11y ago>basic physiological and safety needs I could spend infinite money making myself "safe" - it just depends on what you are trying to be safe from. How much is a personal security detail and motorcade? What about on-call medical staff? A food taster? etc... It's all totally arbitrary - nobody has determined what these physiological and safety needs are comprised of for everyone. Freegans and Preppers certainly have different definitions.
- alanwatts 11y agoOh I completely agree about safety. There really is no security in this universe full of black holes, meteors, exploding stars, and micro organisms. However a simple bar of soap goes a long way to fight those microorganisms. But the basic physiological requirements of having enough food, water, and shelter are not so arbitrary, though the requisite quanitity and type will of course vary.
- pkaye 11y agoI'm on a transplant list for a kidney. The wait in the bay area is around 5 years. What I learned is you can be on multiple transplant lists as long as you can travel to the transplant center in under so many hours. Thus those who are rich enough to afford a private jet on-call can be on multiple transplant center lists.
- gist 11y agoI wonder if there is a business model that can be built whereby transplant recipients buy insurance in order to pay out the cost of the flight by leveraging other recipients. (Spread out the cost in other words so let's call it insurance). So the idea would be in a pool of 500 recipients (arbitrary) you buy private jet time of "x miles" (an average) and/or pay out the jet time over time. Any particular purchaser would pay the average cost (not the cost for the longest jet) and also have the advantage of buying power. And you wouldn't need 500 hours (or whatever the hours you get the point) either is my guess (since some kidneys would be located within driving distance). What do you think (as a recipient?) of that idea? The advantage is if the jet time could cost anywhere from 0 to $10,000 (depending on multiple factors including not needing it) you pay $3000 as a hedge and are willing to take the loss if you don't need it (to help the group).
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoEven though it is life saving, there is more to it than just the transportation cost and believe it or not $3000 is often too much even for how important it is - people just can't afford that. See the youtube link above - you often have to prove that you can pay for anti-rejection drugs, local housing etc... after the procedure.
- Mz 11y agoOh, wow. No. First, people who qualify for a transplant list and are not already wealthy probably cannot afford your insurance. I say this as someone who has a condition that accounts for a very high percentage of lung transplants and as someone who worked in insurance (and still writes insurance articles as a freelancer). Second, please put your creativity towards helping people avoid needing multiple transplant lists to begin with. I find this "we are Borg, resistance is futile" stuff really horrifying. I wish a LOT more effort went into helping people like me keep their own lungs healthy rather than into heroics like better transplant operations where the doctors get good press and high self esteem and high pay and the patient is covered in scars and on anti-rejection drugs for the rest of their life.
- reasonattlm 11y agoSo there should be greater support for working to fix the entire situation, to build organs as needed, and remove the enormous expense and scarcity in the existing system. Decellarization to make more donor organs viable, or enable the use of pig organs. Tissue engineering to build new organs from a patient's own cells. But people spend too much time focused on what is and not enough on how they can help to make a better situation through technological progress. Anyone can help the New Organ project, for example, as it consists of advocacy and research prizes to accelerate progress. You don't have to be a researcher to help make a difference in the matter of organ availability. https://www.neworgan.org/ https://www.neworgan.org/
- camelNotation 11y agoYou're assuming people who are unhealthy, lack options, and live shorter lives are always unhappy. Assuming that "health, freedom, and longevity" lead to happiness is a value statement and entirely subjective. Do not disregard the importance of gratitude in determining happiness. A grateful person can be happy even in the face of death and oppression. Grateful people are the outliers that always seem to confound studies on money and happiness.
- wnevets 11y agoand to make this story even worse, jobs wasted his transparent with his voodoo medicine.
- visarga 11y ago> She died shortly after, never receiving a transplant, while Jobs lived two more years. ... [this is] just a demonstration of how two very different people in a very similar predicament had massively different outcomes based almost entirely on wealth, fame and power So, it would seem being one the of the richest men in the world could only buy him two more years. Two sickly years, not healthy. Kind of disappointing for rich people.