6 ms·
The Guardian wants to engage with readers, but how we do it needs to evolve
- ColinWright 11y agoRelated story, different content: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11478361 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11478361
- blakesterz 11y agoGood on them for trying. I feel like we've been trying to do this on the web since the 1990s though. Somehow it just never works. >>And we are working to make our comment spaces more welcoming and more connected with our editorial work Are there any sites that have really good comment spaces? How did they do it? Seems like moderation works, to a point, with a large enough user base. What else is there? (I'll add other than HN, this is the one place I come to actually read the comments)
- jahnu 11y agoArs Technica has the best model, imo. Promote excellent comments to the article page and have the discussion on a separate one.
- Karunamon 11y agoArs unfortunately suffers from the hivemind problem. They attached voting buttons a few years back, and unpopular enough opinions will be buried under a torrent of votes and be hidden. But the idea of promoting useful comments is a good one, so long as the promotion is a mark of insight, not agreement with the author's politics. Ars doesn't suffer much from this, but given some of the polemic I've read on Guardian, I believe they may
- andy_ppp 11y agoYes comments with lots of up votes and downvoted should be highlighted as provoctresting.
- caractacus 11y agoMetafilter. Which works by charging a one-time only $5 membership and a one-week waiting period before you can post. Small enough for someone interested not to worry, large enough to make the trolls go bye-bye.
- eterm 11y agoThe guardian comment section used to be excellent (10 or so years ago), there was a community of admittedly left-leaning commenters and the odd article would get ridicule but there was more discussion. It started to go downhill when they changed their commenting software so that you saw far fewer comments (about 10 per page rather than 50) and for a time would only sort most-recent or least-recent. It was then very hard to actually have a discussion.
- basch 11y agoSlashdot created their moderation (funny, insightful), metamoderation and tagging and karma and thresholds and filters how long ago? https://slashdot.org/faq/ https://slashdot.org/faq/ https://slashdot.org/faq/metamod.shtml https://slashdot.org/faq/metamod.shtml Everyone just ignores their accomplishments. Sites consider the solution too complicated to implement. You end up with reddit style up/down/report/gold and best/top/hot/controversial which isnt rich enough metadata to let users sort comments in powerful ways. The answers to these problems have been around for long over a decade. Yet no one has even come close to one upping slashdots system.
- mapgrep 11y agoYou're very right that Slashdot developed an underappreciated system for community moderation. Too many people treat this like a new problem when it's one of the oldest out there (see, for example, http://www.shirky.com/writings/herecomeseverybody/group_enemy.html http://www.shirky.com/writings/herecomeseverybody/group_enem... ) That said, I've always assumed the Slashdot system was too elaborate and hard to understand for anything other than the highly technical, highly dedicated (in its heyday) Slashdot community. Maybe I'm wrong.
- basch 11y agoI think tagging your upvote/downvote with metadata describing WHY you voted that way is not complicated. Upvote - important Upvote - funny Upvote - informative Upvote - consensus Downvote - spam Downvote - rude Downvote - inaccurate Downvote - disagree Randomly assigned metamoderation as civic duty is not too much to ask of readers and contributors. I also think the complication should reside in the algorithm and not be handed to the userbase. If metamoderation algorithms can figure out which moderators I agree and disagree with, let me favor the data those moderators i prefer contribute to the system. A well written algorithm will be able to figure out when a person is polluting the system with noise and trying to watch the world burn. Disagreeing with consensus moderation is different than being disruptive. That is a challenging and complicated prospect, but that complexity lies on the backend, not the user facing interface.
- Wintamute 11y agoThe UK and world news writing in the Guardian is world class, but its social commentary and feature sections are rather left-leaning/progressive (or whatever words we use these days), to put it mildly. I don't think it's unreasonable to suggest that their output is pretty politically polarised. They have a target audience that enjoy their politics, and indeed that's who they sell to. But of course people from other political camps are obviously going to be clickbaited and take issue from time to time, so comments on divisive articles are going to get heated and fraught. If the Guardian ran news and commentary that took ideas from the left and the right of the political divide based on merit rather than bias they might find things simmer down. The way the paper is describing the current situation is that they only print virtuously correct articles, and then get mobbed by angry trolls. I look at it slightly differently ... they publish heavily politically biased articles that appeal to their readership, and in doing so troll differently politically minded folk. They reap what they sow, and either way they get clicks and sell ads. Fretting about online harassment is all part of the performance.
- k-mcgrady 11y ago>> "If the Guardian ran news and commentary that took ideas from the left and the right of the political divide based on merit rather than bias they might find things simmer down." I think it would just get worse. Currently you have liberal articles that conservative trolls attack in the comments. Balance that with conservative leaning articles and now the liberals have a comment section to troll in. The solution in my opinion is to do away with the comments. I have never seen anything useful in the comments on The Guardian and I read it quite often.
- Wintamute 11y agoI don't know that it would, I have more faith in humanity than that. If the ideas the Guardian championed were blind to overt politicisation and consistently based on objective merit, rather than ideology I think the strength of those ideas would be plain for people to see.
- striking 11y agoI find the coincidence of complaining about a comment section on the internet in a comment section on the internet delicious.
- ajsgarage 11y ago>Building a community is a difficult endeavour even under perfect conditions, and changing the way a community works once it has been established is even more difficult. Very interesting - a friend forwarded me a piece about another online community, The AV Club, which is quite relevant to this discussion. It looks at the nature of Community, Cliques, and Cesspool behavior. Might be a good companion, informal study to consider: https://medium.com/@LongTimeLurker1stTimePoster/the-av-club-comment-section-community-clique-or-cesspool-f9c2e3295786#.z9a2uycp1 https://medium.com/@LongTimeLurker1stTimePoster/the-av-club-...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- chris_wot 11y agoMy experience with The Guardian has been very positive. There was a user "ChangingWorld" who was a complete anti-vaxxer and no matter what you said ignored all reasoned discussion and reverted to personal attacks. After a fair bit of discussion, I got sick of the personal attacks on anyone who tried to engage with her and who didn't hold her view, so I started flagging her abusive comments. The Guardian moderators, to my great surprise, took notice and actually started deleting posts that violated their policies. The tone of debate, needless to say, took a turn for the better! No longer were participants held to ransom by manipulative and personal attacks and no longer were articles about vaccinations derailed. She eventually stopped commenting after I posted the following: http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/may/14/california-senate-approves-bill-to-make-vaccinations-mandatory#comment-52300593 http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/may/14/california-se...
- lhnz 11y agoWhenever I read an article on the Guardian and think "wow, this is an extremely one-sided perspective" I can almost guarantee the comments will have been disabled. In fact, the presence of comments against an article has begun to act as a signal of quality. I assume that on some level the writers realise that well-argued articles backed with facts and figures mostly dissuade idiots and trolls even when comments are switched on. While the quality of comments on the Guardian and many other news websites are generally low, if an article gets 100s of comments the top voted comments will often be decent rebuttals or positions overlooked by the main article. A relatively decent way of reading the news is to understand the gist of an article and then head straight to the comments to see if there is a punchline. The value of comments on major media sites is to keep you open-minded and to help you spot naturally-occuring biases.
- adaml_623 11y agoPlease provide some examples of this behaviour.
- tomp 11y agoAlmost every second article written by Jessica Valenti, or many others that argue regressive (anti-free speech) leftist (pro-social justice) viewpoints.
- yedava 11y agoI checked out Jessica Valenti's posts[1] on The Guardian. All of them have comments. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/profile/jessicavalenti http://www.theguardian.com/profile/jessicavalenti
- striking 11y agoY'know, I don't entirely disagree with your opinion, but "leftist" doesn't equate with "pro-social justice".
- tomp 11y ago
- dingaling 11y ago> we want to create spaces on the Guardian for particular conversations and particular groups to speak - with each other and with us. It would be interesting if they'd expand on why they want to create these 'spaces'. There are two things I want from a news organisation: 1. Accurate and insightful news, even if it's a bit later than the BBC 2. A channel to make corrections to the published articles by those with first-hand or expert knowledge. I don't want to 'engage' any more than I engage with my ISP or electricity company. Just give me a good, reliable product and a way to let you know when you're not delivering that. From my experience, comments pointing-out corrections don't feed back into the article ( the editors and journalists are busy working on the next story ) so it ends-up like Usenet with people arguing at each other and the story sitting like an immutable monolith at the top of the page. What does the Guardian gain from this? More ad views?
- User2048 11y ago>we want to create spaces on the Guardian for particular conversations and particular groups to speak - with each other and with us. Sounds like they just want an echo chamber.
- Saad_M 11y agoI wonder if it’s worth having any media organisation run a comments section. With so many commenting platforms that are available for the masses (Twitter, Medium, Reddit, etc.), I wonder if a comments section is more or less a relic of days when there wasn’t a plethora ways of getting your opinion across.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- alva 11y agoSlightly modified cross post from another thread. If you really want to understand the Guardians motivation, look at when they realised that the vast majority of their left-leaning readers strongly disagreed with them regarding Islamic terrorism and the refugee crisis. Closed comments on certain articles due to “a change in mainstream public opinion and language that we do not wish to see reflected or supported on the site”.[0] At least they didn't even pretend that it wasn't because the majority of their readership disagreed with them. It seems like they are trying to change their approach to convince people censorship is the right path. Perhaps straight out telling the majority of their loyal readership that their opinions are wrong/bad/racist/evil wasn't the best approach. [0]http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/jan/31/readers-editor-on-readers-comments-below-the-line http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/jan/31/readers...