3 ms·
> Julie Bindel speak there because of her successful campaign to deny trans women access to rape and domestic violence services. [...] > just like they never
by DanBC 11y ago
> Julie Bindel speak there because of her successful campaign to deny trans women access to rape and domestic violence services.
[...]
> just like they never covered the very special exemption added to UK anti-discrimination law to allow this and how exactly it got there,
Rape and domestic violence centres have always been given exclusions in discrimination law, from the 1970s sex discrimination act through all the statutory instruments and duties (eg Gender Equality Duty). But that's not a blanket right to exclude trans-people - a SARC can not just say "no trans people". The exclusion has to be a proportionate response to achieve something reasonable.
The Code of Practice for the act is very clear:
>> “Service providers should be aware that where a transsexual person is visually and for all practical purposes indistinguishable from a non-transsexual person of that gender, they should normally be treated according to their acquired gender, unless there are strong reasons to the contrary.
>> As stated at the beginning of this chapter, any exception to the prohibition of discrimination must be applied as restrictively as possible and the denial of a service to a transsexual person should only occur in exceptional circumstances.”
But most SARCs do not exclude men or transpeople, many on this list specifically mention that men can be the victims of rape and sexual assault and that men are able to use the services.
http://thesurvivorstrust.org/sarc/ http://thesurvivorstrust.org/sarc/
The real problem is the tiny number of SARCs available - if more were available some could specialise on services for transpeople, on services for men, and services for women.
- makomk 11y agoI'm not sure how legal it is to set up a service in the UK that only serves trans people - the legal exemption in question is at least partly one-way. It's definitely not legal to prefer to hire trans women on the basis that other trans women are more likely to be comfortable speaking to them, because the exemption allowing rape counseling services to only hire cis women for the same reason very definitely and specifically does not apply in the other direction. (Requiring that they at least think of trans women as women is probably legal and hopefully wouldn't fall foul of the indirect discrimination provision, maybe.) Also, that Code of Practice is the result of a change of government and a fairly intensive lobbying campaign by trans activists to reduce the damage done by the exemption. It was originally intended to be much broader in application. From the original explanatory notes: "A group counselling session is provided for female victims of sexual assault. The organisers do not allow transsexual people to attend as they judge that the clients who attend the group session are unlikely to do so if a male-to-female transsexual person was also there. This would be lawful." That is, originally it was intended to allow rape and domestic violence services to exclude all trans women as a class because they believe that some cis women wouldn't want to attend if they were there. This is a common belief amongst a certain group of vocal feminist activists who think trans women are men and run government-funded services. Note that there's no requirement that clients are actually unwilling to attend, just that the organizers think they would be. I think they also intended this to apply this to one-on-one counseling on the basis that women would have to share a waiting room. This was also a rollback in protection for some trans women, because the law on Gender Recognition Certificates didn't permit this. Any future Governemnt can trivially change the Code of Practice back too; don't think it'd even require a vote in Parliament. (The reason trans people got added to anti-discrimination law at all is because the European Court of Human Rights ruled they had to be. There was some pretty impressive foot-dragging on implementing that too.)
- DanBC 11y agoI'm not sure I understand the point you're making. Trans-people and men have always been excluded from some rape crisis services. This continues to be the case, but recent legislation and clarification to that legislation made it much harder to apply blanket bans. I disagree about the one-way nature. It would be possible for an organisation offering group counseling to victims of sexual abuse by Catholic church to ban priests and nuns; I believe it's possible for an organisation offering services to trans victims of sexual assault to specify only trans people in some roles. I think we agree that the UK still needs to do much better to protect trans people from harm and to enforce the rights of trans people.