4 ms·
I disagree with the idea that the musical is painting Hamilton as a blameless hero of the people and glossing over his Federalist policies. For an example off t
by mklim 10y ago
I disagree with the idea that the musical is painting Hamilton as a blameless hero of the people and glossing over his Federalist policies. For an example off the top of my head, you've got Jefferson (who is not portrayed as a villainous contrast to Hamilton's "goodness" in the musical--not sure how the author came to that conclusion) directly calling him out as an ambitious man vying for Wall Street power in "Washington on Your Side":
I get no satisfaction witnessing his fits of passion
The way he primps and preens and dresses like the pits of fashion
Our poorest citizens, our farmers, live ration to ration
As Wall Street robs ‘em blind in search of chips to cash in
This prick is askin’ for someone to bring him to task
The same character calls Hamilton out for not wanting to come to France's aid in "Cabinet Battle #2":
He knows nothing of loyalty
Smells like new money, dresses like fake royalty
Desperate to rise above his station
Everything he does betrays the ideals of our nation
[...] do we not fight for freedom?
Have you an ounce of regret?
You accumulate debt, you accumulate power
Yet in their hour of need, you forget
Hamilton is shown as a man who came to power from an immigrant background against the odds. As far as I've been able to read up on him, though, that's historically accurate--and the play goes into the details of his policies and his personality flaws as well. Coming out of it and thinking that Hamilton is a purehearted hero for liberty seems like an overly simplistic and reductive reading of the play to me.
- larsiusprime 10y agoDon't forget the part where it pulls no punches in describing the country's first sex scandal! Not to mention the part where he (in many people's eyes) deliberately put his own career ahead of his family's dignity by outing the whole scandal himself in lurid detail so he could fend off accusations of corruption and maintain his position. Also being a hothead prone to dueling.
- jdoliner 10y agoIf anything I'd say that the play goes above and beyond what I'd expect to make the other characters look good by comparison. For example take the final song which shows Burr being remorseful about the slaying of Hamilton. In reality he never really expressed remorse. He spoke the words "I would have known the world was wide enough for both Hamilton and me." He was being sarcastic, not expressing actual remorse.