5 ms·
I don't think those are very good examples. > Most email is spam. ... runs a mail server If your mail server is an open relay and sends a lot of spam, you mig
by kbenson 11y ago
I don't think those are very good examples.
> Most email is spam. ... runs a mail server
If your mail server is an open relay and sends a lot of spam, you might expect it to get blocked at a minimum, and possibly to see some legal problems.
> Most cash contains traces of drugs. ... pays in cash
If you run an ATM and the money you put out has a higher proportion of drugs on it than the average currency, you might expect some inquiries.
> Most BitTorrent content infringes copyright. ... torrents a Debian ISO
This isn't even hard to disambiguate like the others. Is the torrent being downloaded/served infringing in some manner? If it's not, you're fine, if it is, you might have a problem. BitTorrent isn't a single system, it's bunch of loose networks.
There's a useful discussion to be had over whether someone running a Tor exit node should expect some increased risk of inconvenience and/or exposure to mistaken legal action, but I don't think these really advance that conversation at all.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> If your mail server is an open relay and sends a lot of spam, you might expect it to get blocked at a minimum, and possibly to see some legal problems. But it isn't an open relay. It's just a normal mail server. It's cash with the typical trace amount of drugs on it. That's the whole point -- just because a lot of X is bad and you did X that doesn't mean that you did something bad. It's even possible, as is the case for Tor, that percent-of-thing and percent-of-people-who-do-thing have completely different numbers, because it's possible for a small number of bad actors to generate a disproportionately large amount of traffic. > This isn't even hard to disambiguate like the others. Is the torrent being downloaded/served infringing in some manner? If it's not, you're fine, if it is, you might have a problem. BitTorrent isn't a single system, it's bunch of loose networks. That's the point. "Is using BitTorrent" is not a useful metric for badness because the false positive rate is extremely high. If you sit on my internet connection and see me download encrypted data via BitTorrent, you don't know if it's a legal copy of Debian Testing or a pirated copy of Windows 7. Which means you should have to do more work before you can send a fracking SWAT team to my house.
- kbenson 11y ago> But it isn't an open relay. It's just a normal mail server. It's cash with the typical trace amount of drugs on it. That's the whole point See, I think the "typical" usage would be your own usage. I don't think the typical person happens to have a certain small percentage of traffic that happens to by child pornography pass through their connection, even if the internet as a whole does. Once you run a Tor exit node and you are proxying something closer to the statistical average of types of internet traffic (even though there's probably more illegal traffic on average on Tor than on the Internet, whether it's 1% more or significantly more), and you are doing it from home and mixing your own traffic with it, I think it's not out of the question for the Police to investigate. That doesn't mean every time, but I'm not going to immediately condemn them for looking into a crime. I also think how the police handle it has to do with the entity they are interacting with. If it's a multi-person business in good standing, I would expect a subpoena. If it's an individual, it might be a raid, because I think the chance and capability of an individual to destroy evidence is higher. I equate this to tracking the source of a gun that was used in a crime. If the last known source is a business, a subpoena may or may not suffice. If it's a guy selling out of his house (legally), a raid may be warranted. Now, all that said, the police should be doing their part and providing the relevant info to the judge. The judge should be making this call, not you or I, and only when he has all the relevant info, which includes whether the suspect is running a Tor exit node (and as others have stated, it's up to the judges to either consult an expert or learn the facts themselves to deal with this information). Given our current laws and my understanding of them (probably poor), this is how I think it should currently function legally. Whether I think that's how they should function given changes, I'm not sure I would opt for the current system.
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> See, I think the "typical" usage would be your own usage. It's your own usage only if you're the only user, which is an invalid assumption even before Tor. People aren't shy about sharing wifi with house guests. Tor takes it from "could be any of 25 people" to "could be any of 7 billion people." But even regardless of that, why should the expected result of offering a service to the general public put you under suspicion? If you sell sandwiches you're going to end up with cash that has traces of drugs on it, even if you don't use drugs, because some of your customers or some people they transact with do. Everyone who sells sandwiches for cash will end up with population-typical cash in their possession. Which is exactly why having such cash isn't at all suspicious. It's the thing you would expect from an honest person in that situation which means it provides no utility in distinguishing honest people from criminals. > That doesn't mean every time, but I'm not going to immediately condemn them for looking into a crime. By what criteria do you propose that they distinguish the times they do from the times they don't, which would reasonably put the case in question in the "do the raid" category? > I also think how the police handle it has to do with the entity they are interacting with. If it's a multi-person business in good standing, I would expect a subpoena. If it's an individual, it might be a raid, because I think the chance and capability of an individual to destroy evidence is higher. A large super-majority of individuals work for a business in good standing. Why would they be less likely to destroy evidence at work than at home? Actually implementing such a rule would also seem to give undue comfort to criminal conspiracies. Would it not make more sense to issue a warrant only if the crime can be tied to the suspect with something more than an IP address known to be shared by multiple people?