2 ms·
I'm not a physics genius. But to me it seems like the enthusiasm for this theory is based on some very old cultural assumptions about man vs. nature. For examp
by snowwrestler 11y ago
I'm not a physics genius. But to me it seems like the enthusiasm for this theory is based on some very old cultural assumptions about man vs. nature.
For example:
> “If I were a character in a computer game, I would also discover eventually that the rules seemed completely rigid and mathematical,” said Max Tegmark, a cosmologist at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). “That just reflects the computer code in which it was written.”
Computers are not exempt from nature, of course. The reason a computer works is because the physical laws of our universe can be described mathematically. If quantum theory didn't work mathematically, then neither would a computer.
So Tegmark is probably assigning the correlation the wrong way. A computer can only exist in a universe with mathematical physical laws; therefore the detection of mathematical laws doesn't tell us whether we're in a computer ourselves.
Likewise:
> Furthermore, ideas from information theory keep showing up in physics. “In my research I found this very strange thing,” said James Gates, a theoretical physicist at the University of Maryland. “I was driven to error-correcting codes—they’re what make browsers work. So why were they in the equations I was studying about quarks and electrons and supersymmetry?
Information is also not exempt from nature; it is a physical thing that is subject to the same laws of the universe as anything else. And what we call information theory arose from our study of real physical systems, like telegraphs and telephones.
Now, maybe information theory will turn out to be a better mathematical framework for describing the laws of the universe. But that does not mean that it is any more likely that we're living in a simulation. One mathematical framework is not more "natural" than another. And there are plenty of examples of where a math framework developed in one context became useful in another.
We use computers, and I think we still see ourselves as somehow distinct from the rest of nature. This lends itself to a somewhat supernatural way of thinking, like "I use a computer to manage information, so therefore if everything is information, then there must be a super-me running a super-computer."
But taking scientific theory at face value, a computer running SimCity is just as natural as a cat, or a palm tree swaying in the breeze. If our theory says that everything is information, then so are we, and so are our computers--so there is no need for anything else to explain that.