3 ms·
>It's also why I don't understand all the whining (here and elsewhere) about requiring the Post Office to actually fund its pensions rather than just assume Unc
by justin66 11y ago
>It's also why I don't understand all the whining (here and elsewhere) about requiring the Post Office to actually fund its pensions rather than just assume Uncle Sam will have infinite funds to cover it later
Some people believe the post office is required to pay quite a bit more into those pension funds than is necessary for their financial well being. Nobody in that discussion claimed or assumed the government has infinite funds to cover the post office's obligations.
It's as if you were having a discussion with yourself that happened to occupy the same space as another, ongoing discussion on the same topic. Hence the way some tried to engage with you (unsuccessfully) and some just downvoted you.
- SilasX 11y agoI explained (with visible frustration) how it's eminently fair to expect a business to fully fund its obligations. If someone believes that the way this is calculated is unreasonable, then their primary complaint needs to be about that way, not (as every commenter does on this issue) complain about the mere requirement to fund the pension. A complete argument would look like this: "It's unfair to require the post office to fund future benefits by X standard, when common, reasonable practice is to use more lenient standard is Y." A complete but stupid argument would have X="include all obligations forever" and Y="ignore stuff after 75 years". This is because post-75 years can have non-trivial implications for its sustainability, and assuming them away does require belief in a bottomless pit. I'm interested in an exchange of ideas on this issue; I just wish people were capable of presenting a defensible argument about the Post Office pension requirement. Your own argument on the thread [1] does not meet that standard, as it was just "wow, that would be a lot of money". Well, yeah, if you've promised something with a (net discounted present) value of $75 trillion, then yeah, it's gonna be a pain to fund! Why is that an unreasonable requirement that you not just kick the can down the road? I'd like to hear an intelligent answer to that question. "They hate the Post Office and want it to fail" doesn't count as one. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11464618 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11464618
- justin66 11y ago> I explained (with visible frustration) You're being entirely too generous to yourself by characterizing your attitude as "frustration."