3 ms·
There are two glaring areas of fraud that anyone can understand: Many derivatives are insurance by another name, and sold without insurance-like capital backing
by Zigurd 11y ago
There are two glaring areas of fraud that anyone can understand: Many derivatives are insurance by another name, and sold without insurance-like capital backing it. That's fraud. Then mis-rating those derivatives is fraud. There was clear and readily understood illegality at the core of the derivatives bomb. The rating agencies should have been prosecuted, the ibankers who fed them misinformation that caused misratings should be prosecuted, and the people who formulated and sold an insurance product outside the regulatory framework of insurance should be prosecuted.
- rayiner 11y ago> Many derivatives are insurance by another name, and sold without insurance-like capital backing it. That's fraud. So 1) you're going to get an expert up there to testify that derivatives and insurance are the same thing; 2) get a jury to believe you in the face of conflicting expert testimony that nobody in the industry thinks they are the same thing; and 3) get the jury to believe that the bankers who sold the derivatives knew that equivalency beyond a reasonable doubt. That's bonkers. I don't think you get past step 1. As for your second theory: the agencies couch all their ratings with the appropriate disclaimers (based on such and such models, etc). If they had a process, and followed that process to produce a rating, and disclosed as much, that's not fraud, even if the result of that process is garbage.
- Zigurd 11y agoIt's no more difficult than explaining that income, couched in all kinds of fancy lawyering, is still income, here or in Panama. On your W2 or in a unit trust. People understand that. Tax agencies regulate and prosecute that. Moreover prosecution is a light punishment for what these people did. They literally committed the fraud of the century, and stole massive amounts from the rest of us by it. I would find it difficult to vote to convict anyone who drags these asses into the street for a beating. At least until prosecutors get over having to work for a conviction.
- EdHominem 11y agoThe people involved 1) had a duty to understand the structure of the things they sold, and 2) have specific training meaning that they can't (realistically) say they were unable to understand them. If an engineer claimed not to understand the tools of their field they'd merely be trading one set of liability for another. If the same standards were applied to these people as are applied to the non-rich we'd agree that their university transcripts are proof that they understand the field and that their relationship with the people they recommended these investments to was "customer like" enough to show conflict of interest and misrepresentation. As for your process-protection theory, it doesn't hold up. Processes rule up until you have a reason to believe otherwise. You may normally delete email after three months but if you've been notified that the information in question is being sought as evidence in a trial all of a sudden your process has to change. If an engineer tells me he has a process and I show how that it is (dangerously) wrong he has a legal obligation to investigate and correct his recommendations. The ratings agencies had similar obligations and were given specific written evidence showing their claims to be incorrect. That they chose to ignore these communications means their process defense is worthless. And if they had a process that contributed to them not getting this information, that right there should be enough to show malfeasance from a financial organization.
- rayiner 11y ago> If the same standards were applied to these people as are applied to the non-rich we'd agree that their university transcripts are proof that they understand the field and that their relationship with the people they recommended these investments to was "customer like" enough to show conflict of interest and misrepresentation. Customer relationships aren't fiduciary relationships outside of finance either. How much utter crap do software companies knowingly sell to customers with zero liability? If selling crap as gold opened software companies up to liability, Microsoft wouldn't have survived the 1990's. > Processes rule up until you have a reason to believe otherwise. So if you tell US News that their college rankings don't correlate with employment outcomes, they have a legal obligation to fix their process?