5 ms·
As the person who wrote the code for the SEO part of the reddit URL, I can tell you that there is definitely an impact. It made a huge difference at the time,
by jedberg 11y ago
As the person who wrote the code for the SEO part of the reddit URL, I can tell you that there is definitely an impact. It made a huge difference at the time, because reddit wasn't really on Google's radar. Today I suspect it would have less impact for reddit.
For HN, I get the impression that they don't really want to be all that optimized for Google, so it probably hits their goals just fine, but it probably does hurt them a little bit. But since the words are in an H1 right at the top, probably not all that much.
Edit: The code in case anyone is interested:
https://github.com/reddit/reddit/blob/cfd979fa0119191257eadc4ccfcada60968984a1/r2/r2/lib/utils/utils.py#L936 https://github.com/reddit/reddit/blob/cfd979fa0119191257eadc...
- tobltobs 11y agoAre you sure that the impact was caused by changes in the URL part and not any other changes which were made at the same time.
- ketralnis 11y agoIt's impossible to be sure without asking Google, but there weren't many of us at the time and so there weren't many changes to conflate it with.
- avar 11y agoTo me your comment demonstrates why it's really hard to figure out anything worthwhile about SEO. You wrote that code almost 8 years ago[1]. Google and other search engines have changed a lot since then. Who knows if this has any impact today? Actually did you even A/B test it at the time? Or just turn it on along with a bunch of other changes? It's hard to tell, and there's so much SEO (mis)information out there based on old anecdotes, and all the players doing A/B testing for this sort of thing on a big scale keep their data to themselves. 1. https://github.com/reddit/reddit/commit/353ad2a https://github.com/reddit/reddit/commit/353ad2a
- jedberg 11y agoWe did not A/B test it, but we didn't release many changes at the same time either, so it's hard to say for sure, but we were pretty sure it made a difference. Also, SEO is not supposed to be easy, Google purposely makes it hard. They don't want you to be successful (with good reason). They've always said, make good content that easy for a human to find and Google will find it too. That's probably the best SEO advice you can get.
- rbinv 11y agoI'm pretty confident that no one A/B tests URLs for SEO purposes. How would you A/B test this anyway? You can't exactly serve Google different URLs and see what works (in fact, this would ruin both approaches).
- jasongill 11y agoYou're definitely wrong about that - there are whole businesses built on building "case studies" that try to decipher the inner workings of Google's algorithm. These days most tests are run by buying two domains that are a combination of random letters/numbers, setting up two nearly identical sites, and doing identical linkbuilding to both - then seeing which one ranks higher. It's not exactly scholastic research quality, but repeated enough times it gives you an idea of what's working "right now".
- tobltobs 11y agoThis method wouldn't work. To make both results comparable you would have to put the same content on both sites, which would result in one of both pages getting hit by the duplicate content problem.
- jasongill 11y agoIt actually works great; the "duplicate content problem" only impacts pages on the same domain, not identical content across multiple sites. It's possible to make a lot of money by taking the content of mild authority sites and putting it on a high authority domain - can outrank the source sites in short order.