5 ms·
I have to wonder if this, in part, has to do with the fact that poorer people here tend to ride the subway, and get exposed to a larger number of viruses, and b
by tombert 11y ago
I have to wonder if this, in part, has to do with the fact that poorer people here tend to ride the subway, and get exposed to a larger number of viruses, and building up an more immunities.
I'm no doctor, but it at least seems plausible from a lay-man's perspective.
- raverbashing 11y agoProbably it has more to do with the amount of stair climbing that riding the subway requires
- theandrewbailey 11y agoAnd also due to the extra half mile or so of walking to your local stop and final destination.
- jba 11y agoMy guess would be more along the lines that people who walk/subway are generally more fit than those who take a car everywhere. NYC doesn't have a lot of fat people in general. (though it's worse than it used to be)
- maxerickson 11y agoExposure to infections does not make you stronger. Immunity is highly specific. This is why the flu is a chronic problem, it mutates rapidly enough that exposure to previous generations of the virus does not confer immunity to current generations. Immunity is more like a collection of solutions to puzzles than it is a muscle. Being infected while in a healthier state and thus gaining immunity with less risk might be beneficial later, but you can look at mortality statistics and see that while infections are a major cause of death, they aren't responsible for a large portion of deaths: http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/deaths.htm http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/deaths.htm (Chronic lower respiratory disease there is stuff like COPD, not particularly infection related)
- tombert 11y agoThat's what I get for taking medical advice from a George Carlin stand-up... That's a fair point, I'll admit I was mistaken.
- o_____________o 11y ago> Exposure to infections does not make you stronger. * As an adult https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hygiene_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hygiene_hypothesis
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago> ride the subway If you take public trans all the time, then you're doing a lot of walking. Trans takes you close enough but the 'last mile' is always on foot. That's a decent amount of exercise, at least compared to someone who is always driving. This is how I grew up and when I was older, the move to the suburbs was pretty jarring. Everyone got fatter as we stopped getting all that city walking. Worse, the suburbs didn't have a lot of healthy food options. So you drove more and ate crappier. A pack of cigarettes in NYC is around $13. In a poor rural or suburban community, its half that. A lot of the urban poor simply can't afford smoking anymore. This must certainly affect things, at least as much as anti-smoking PSAs. NYC also has 1.1m Jews, who tend to have a slightly higher than average life expectancy, especially the religiously observant who follow strict dietary limits. That might skew things a little as well.
- codyb 11y agoMost of the cigarette trade here ends up being virginia taxed because of that cost for smokes. I thought it was 500,000 Jewish persons but it looks like 1.1m checks out from a quick google search. That's a huge percentage of the population.
- theandrewbailey 11y agoAbout 1 month ago, I moved to within a 15 minute walk of the Pittsburgh T. I really want to use it more. They allow bikes on the T, so I'm planning to get one to ride around downtown and out in the country. I am glad to get out of the suburban hell I was living in for 6 years.
- zhemao 11y agoThe strict dietary laws make their diet less healthy, generally. Orthodox Jews have a very restricted diet which is heavy on starch and fat. When you can't eat fresh fruit or vegetables because of the possibility of accidentally consuming insects, your diet isn't going to be the healthiest.
- eric_h 11y agoAgreed, and I would also suggest that the number of strictly observant jews is a small fraction of the New York population that identify as jewish and would be counted as such in a survey