4 ms·
1) Avoiding tax is in legal bounds is completely moral and is practised by everyone who is able to do that. I know a _lot_ of programmers in US who establish pr
by golergka 11y ago
1) Avoiding tax is in legal bounds is completely moral and is practised by everyone who is able to do that. I know a _lot_ of programmers in US who establish private consulting companies to write off all their private expenses and get 15% effective tax rate. If you think avoiding tax is immoral, you should hate them just as much as you hate billionaires.
2) Most of the people believe in political causes that are likely to directly benefit them. College students and young professionals are upset about college loans, old people are concerned with pensions, etc.
3) It's completely legal and moral to put effort and money to support political causes you believe in.
So, everything the article describes is completely normal and moral for an ordinary man — but it seems that when billionaires exhibit the same behaviour, scaled with their personal wealth and it's influence, everyone thinks it's awful, immoral and illegal. How so?
- Eridrus 11y ago> 1) Avoiding tax is in legal bounds is completely moral and is practised by everyone who is able to do that. I know a _lot_ of programmers in US who establish private consulting companies to write off all their private expenses and get 15% effective tax rate. If you think avoiding tax is immoral, you should hate them just as much as you hate billionaires. Morality is not binary, and it is quite reasonable to think that while programmers evading taxes is bad, billionaires doing so is worse.
- golergka 11y agoWhy worse if it's the same %?
- rlucas 11y agoWhen does a difference in degree become a difference in kind? (Not arguing the specific point -- but differences of degree do matter in the messy empirical real world.)
- jtuente 11y agoWhether morality is or isn't binary isn't quite the point you should be making. It's that not everyone shares the same views of morality. Some people find private property immoral, for instance. The reason that we have moral "gray" areas isn't so much because morality isn't binary, but more because what different people view of as moral varies. In a purely utilitarian sense, non-binary morality is more concerned with how closely an action comes to the "greatest good" in that an action can be morally good but not morally greatest good. But what defines the greatest good depends on how person defines morality.
- rlucas 11y agoYour 1) above, indicating that a "lot" of programmers can funnel work through "private consulting companies" and get "15% effective tax rate" can be highly misleading to those (inside or outside the US) unfamiliar with how the tax code works here. In fact, if you are costing the same to your patron as either a consultant or employee (meaning, say, they outlay $100k for some number of hours of your labor, but indifferent as to how) it's far from clear that you can legally make for a much better tax situation by running it through a consulting company. A. Normally an employer and employee each pay about 7.5% (total 15%) in payroll deductions; these are split ER/EE in a normal situation. In a self-employed situation, you pay both parts yourself. No real advantage. B. Your private consulting company must be a pass-through entity (disregarded for taxation) otherwise it must pay taxes at its level. If it is not a pass-through, you can pay yourself favorable dividend rates from the profits, but you'll have to have paid income tax on those profits first at the corporate level. Oops. C. Either way, once that money gets through your consulting company to you as earned income -- either direct or passed-through to you, or paid to you as salary through the company -- you'll be paying ordinary tax rates. D. The rejoinder here by the unexperienced or the lax of compliance is "hey, but you can just deduct everything you ever spend as an expense of the company, and so you really can cut down on the reported income!" The problem here is that most things you can deduct legally as a consulting company you could also deduct as an individual. Mileage for travel, necessary expenses, etc. You can't (legally) deduct your shoes, your Netflix, your bar tab, your kids' tuition, etc. (That said -- there ARE situations where you would do much better with Schedule C business income, but they tend to be where complications other than "I write software for an hourly rate" come into play, like other losses to offset, equipment expenses, interest expenses, flexibility in setting up and administering tax-advantaged benefits accounts, etc.) E. The Internal Revenue Code is complicated for many reasons, but it's not just mindless. A good way to think about it is this: The likelihood that there exists a perfectly legal, lucrative, opt-in alternative means of structuring an otherwise economically identical arrangement for IRS purposes; such likelihood is inversely proportional to the number of taxpayers (not $ of tax collectible) who could take advantage of it. More cynically put: the tax regime is fairly watertight for those who sell their labor for money, and all of the leaks and loopholes are at much higher levels, tending to deal with those whose money begets money.
- bryondowd 11y agoWell, most people would get very upset about someone going 120mph through a 25mph school zone but range from mildly disapproving to understanding of someone going 75mph on a 55mph highway. Not an exact comparison, but it captures the general concept. Wage earners shaving some dollars off their taxes with exemptions likely has a much smaller impact on the country's financial health than those earning millions per year on ownership finding ways to lower their effective tax rate to the same levels. Ideally, everyone should pay their fair share, but in the meantime, the higher volume offenders are going to be a higher concern.
- zavi 11y agoCan you elaborate on programmers and their offshore consulting companies? Asking for a friend.
- bobwaycott 11y agoRead more closely. GP didn't say "offshore", it was "private".