4 ms·
It's changed so much since Carter's day: >Carter compared elections now-a-days to those when he was running for office, saying, “In those days when I ran again
by tim333 11y ago
It's changed so much since Carter's day:
>Carter compared elections now-a-days to those when he was running for office, saying, “In those days when I ran against Gerald Ford, who was incumbent president or later Ronald Reagan, who challenged me, we didn’t raise a single penny to finance our campaign to run against each other. We just used the $1 per person checkoff that every taxpayer indicates at the end of his or her income tax return."
Guess things could be changed back?
- bdavisx 11y agoWith the Citizens United decision, that's no longer possible without either a Constitutional Amendment or the Supreme Court overturning their own decision - neither one is very likely.
- agrover 11y agoWith Scalia gone you still think it's unlikely?
- BookmarkSaver 11y agoRegardless of the ideology of the court majority, they very rarely directly overturn previous decisions. It's not impossible (Brown vs. Board of Education) but it isn't just a matter of getting a challenge before a liberal court. The previous decision is binding, they would have to justify why they would be going against authority equal to their own.
- venomsnake 11y agoI don't claim to understand SCOTUS - but they are extremely conservative institution. I mean dictionary definition of conservative - upholding the status quo. And they prefer to not get involved in the day to day affairs of the country. So even a bad SCOTUS decision could stay on the books for a long time - just to save face and uphold the credibility of the institution. They look to rock the boat the least. Even in their current hyperpartisan state.
- pc86 11y agoSaying that the Court upholds precedent to "save face" shows an complete and total lack of understanding of the body.
- guelo 11y agoWith the Senate refusing to do its constitutional duty and confirm Obama's (very conservative) pick, it'll depend on who wins the presidential election. If it's Trump it'll probably be someone from left field completely unpredictable. With Hillary it'll probably be a middle of the road jurist not really willing to overturn things too much.
- r00fus 11y agoOr if Bernie wins, it might be someone left of Ginsberg...
- chimeracoder 11y ago> With the Citizens United decision, that's no longer possible without either a Constitutional Amendment or the Supreme Court overturning their own decision - neither one is very likely. Citizens United has implications for campaign finance, but the demise of publicly financed campaigns that GP is referring to began before that. In fact, it began with Obama's first election (2008), in which McCain agreed to take public financing. Obama, on the other hand, broke his earlier promise to take public funds, becoming the first candidate in history to do so[0][1]. Because accepting public financing means limiting total spending, Obama vastly outspent McCain by November. Obama won the popular vote, spending $10.94/vote, whereas McCain spent only half as much total money (amounting to $5.97/vote in the end.)[2] [0] http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/20/us/politics/20obamacnd.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/20/us/politics/20obamacnd.htm... [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/20/us/politics/20obama.html http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/20/us/politics/20obama.html [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundraising_for_the_2008_United_States_presidential_election https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundraising_for_the_2008_Unite...
- tim333 11y agoThough with Trump the favourite to be the Republican candidate we could see a Dem landslide which might allow something to be done.
- pc86 11y agoThe partisan composition of Congress will not have any immediate (or even short-term) effects on SCOTUS rulings.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- vkou 11y agoI don't imagine that the primary campaigns were funded by public money - and in the case of the presidency, they are just as important as the actual campaign.
- vitd 11y agoActually, many primary campaigns were funded by public money. There was an interesting episode of Planet Money recently [0] where they talked to Senator Fred Harris who got the US system started. A few years after getting it going, he used public funds to run against Jimmy Carter for the 1976 nomination by the Democrats. He lost to Carter and then Carter used public funds to run his presidential campaign against Ford. But Harris got ~$600,000.00 to run his nomination campaign. [0] http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/03/25/471905383/episode-692-the-secret-life-of-line-24 http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/03/25/471905383/episo...
- kbenson 11y agoIt's really surprising how often something trends on HN and there's a relevant Planet Money episode from within the last few weeks. I wonder if that's because in some cases other news outlets are spurred into covering it because of Planet Money (it's reach is relatively small compared to the Guardian, so the Guardian covering the topic will be seen as new to most), or if there's some journalistic social network (in the traditional sense, not the Facebook sense) that some outlets are better are responding to quickly than others?
- Pxtl 11y agoIn Canada we used to have something called the "Per Vote Subsidy". Every political party got $2 of taxpayer money per-vote, per year. It was, sadly, killed by the Conservative government (along with corporate donors) to prioritize an individual-fundraising-oriented system like you have in the USA.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> In Canada we used to have something called the "Per Vote Subsidy". Every political party got $2 of taxpayer money per-vote, per year. We have that in the US as well. It has existed since Watergate (1976). In 2008, Obama became the first candidate to opt out of the system, despite an earlier pledge to use them (McCain, his opponent, did not - he used public funds). Amusingly, Romney said that he'd prefer to use public funds, but the reason that he did not (in 2012) is that Obama did not, and he believed he couldn't be competitive against an incumbent president who would potentially be spending three times as much as he would be legally permitted to[0][1][2]. The system still exists, for any candidate willing to use it. Though I would not be surprised if McCain became the last candidate to take advantage of it. After 2008, no candidate who wants to be competitive will take public funds if their opponent isn't as well, and that's unlikely to be the case for both candidates in a race simultaneously. [0] Accepting public funds comes with limits on total spending [1] http://www.politico.com/blogs/politico-now/2012/08/romney-absolutely-would-return-to-public-funding-in-16-133234 http://www.politico.com/blogs/politico-now/2012/08/romney-ab... [2] And frankly, he was right - ultimately, he spent about the same amount as Obama did. If he'd been limited to the amounts that public financing would have restricted him to, he'd have lost in a landslide.
- Pxtl 11y agoIs the money/opt-out party-wide or is it tied to a specific candidate for a specific office. When you say "Obama" and "Romney" are you talking about them in their role as leading the entire party in the election or just their individual presidential runs?
- chimeracoder 11y ago
- neffy 11y agoHmm. Carter may be telling the truth as he knows it - but Robert Caro's biographies of LBJ make it quite clear that there has been enormous monetary corruption in US politics - going back to well before LBJ. See especially how his first senate race was financed in "The Path to Power"
- dnautics 11y agoForget monetary corruption: it was flat out political corruption. If anything the insurgent candidacies of Sanders and Trump show that being able to get media attention, raise money directly from the people, and in the case of Cruz (who is by no means a party favorite), raising money through super pacs, etc. Are a de-corrupting influence by opening up options outside of the anointed choices.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoYou mean "Landslide Lyndon"? That was overt and egregious ballot box mismanagement. Common as dirt in Texas politics. Political contributions work more like "rock and roll fantasy camps" than they buy access. Not always; sometimes they do, but the candidate will usually not have the bandwidth to give you their undivided attention.
- neffy 11y agoIt's worth reading the book. Ballot box mismanagement, especially on that scale isn't free - and it seems quite clear that he was not only receiving cash handouts for his own campaign, but he was also acting as a channel for money to other democrats campaigns - and this was what allowed him to gain the influence he held within the party and especially the senate.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoOh, absolutely. It's a master work. I did not mean to cast aspersions on Mr. Caro's work.
- zanny 11y agoWe could certainly do even better nowadays. Rather than get campaign funds from taxpayers, we could have the state run a web service for candidates to debate, posit positions, etc. You would need to expand library computer access to let those without technology access the information, but the status quo is already bad enough its an improvement all around. Then you abolish private campaign funding and advertising.