4 ms·
The major thing I took away from both the article and the comments originally submitted a few days ago is that nutrition science is too hard to create a one-siz
by AndrewKemendo 11y ago
The major thing I took away from both the article and the comments originally submitted a few days ago is that nutrition science is too hard to create a one-size fits all guideline to what people should eat.
If we have to have a one-size fits all solution to nutrition however, my anecdotal guess is that the answer shouldn't be what we should eat but how much. Namely as long as people aren't over or under eating they should be fine.
- bosdev 11y agoIs that really true? Or is the evidence pretty much in that all people shouldn't really be eating refined sugar?
- CuriouslyC 11y agoSomeone who is highly active can consume a lot more fructose-containing sugar than someone who is sedentary, and in fact fructose-containing sugar is more efficient at restoring liver glycogen than straight glucose. The problem comes when the liver's glycogen stores are full, and primary pathway for disposing of that fructose is via de-novo lipogenesis. Like anything, the problem is consumption to excess. Unfortunately, excess in this case (for the typical sedentary person) is quite a small amount.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoI don't think it's conclusive - that's my point. I think it is conclusive that there are no old obese people.
- stonemetal 11y agoIf there is evidence I haven't seen any. Pretty much everything I have seen suggests that A) You should meet your macro needs which are slightly different for everyone, B) after that don't over eat, but what you eat doesn't really matter. From a weight loss perspective low sugar diets are good for psychological reasons, not thermodynamic ones. Sugar tends to cause quick, but short lived fullness, where fat and protein take longer to kick in but once they do they are much longer lived.